Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Next governor may put stamp on Florida Supreme Court

TALLAHASSEE — Florida's 2014 governor's race may become an expensive popularity contest over who steers the state in the next four years but one little-discussed job — the power to appoint — could give the next governor a legacy that lasts much longer.

Four members of the seven-member state Supreme Court reach mandatory retirement age during the next four years and, depending on how the retirements play out, the next governor may have the power to pick their replacements.

The prospect of choosing the men and women who serve as a powerful check on legislative and executive power is so potent it has already become a significant fundraising draw in the governor's race for both Democrat Charlie Crist and Republican Gov. Rick Scott.

But, in addition to the power of the pick, there is palace intrigue: Florida law is so unsettled about the exact timing of judicial retirement that some suggest three of the justices could wait out the next governor until the last day of his term in January 2019, and it could take a lawsuit to resolve it­ — which could be decided by the retiring justices.

Florida's Constitution requires justices to retire on their 70th birthday or at the end of a six-year term, if they are halfway through the term, whichever is later.

Barbara Pariente, R. Fred Lewis and Peggy Quince are the longest-serving members of the court, each having been appointed more than 15 years ago by former Gov. Lawton Chiles, a Democrat. They must retire by January 2019.

The other justice, James E.C. Perry, was appointed by Crist in 2009, when he was a Republican governor. Perry turns 70 in January but, because he is halfway through his six-year term, he is not required to retire until his term ends in January 2017.

For Pariente, Lewis and Quince, the state Constitution allows the justices to serve out their six-year terms but each must turn over the robes no later than the precise moment the sitting governor's term ends.

That leaves open an unsettled question in Florida law: What happens when a justice announces his retirement will take effect the moment the sitting governor would cease to be governor?

Since the Chiles contingent composes the court's liberal faction, there is a possibility that if Scott is re-elected, the justices won't retire until they know who his successor is.

A similar scenario occurred in 1998, when then-Justice Ben Overton made his retirement effective the moment Chiles' term ended after Jeb Bush won the governor's race. Bush signaled he would litigate if Chiles did not consult him, so the two agreed on Quince, and she became the only justice to be appointed by two governors at once.

Lawyers who have studied the issue don't want to discuss it on the record, but several agree that if Pariente, Lewis and Quince don't retire early and Scott is governor, there is a chance he could attempt to fill their pending vacancies before his successor takes office — and that could draw a lawsuit. They could decide the lawsuit.

With this uncertainty pending, Crist is primed to make the court a campaign issue.

Crist tells audiences that Scott "would put a bunch of ideologues" on the Florida Supreme Court.

"If that happens, if we don't win and he does, forget about it," Crist told an audience of Democratic lawyers at a fundraiser in Palm Beach earlier this month.

His opponents, of course, share a similar view — about him.

"A Charlie Crist Florida Supreme Court would be a liberal, trial lawyer-led, John Morgan court," said Republican Party of Florida chairman Lenny Curry, referring to the trial lawyer who employs Crist, who is also a lawyer. "That would be antibusiness, antijobs and wouldn't be good for Florida."

Crist said he hears not only from lawyers but from the general public that the judiciary is the branch "holding Florida together."

"It affects gays, minorities, immigrants, women, public education and voter rights," he said. "If we don't have justices who are fair-minded, it's bad for the executive and the Legislature but it's horrific for the judicial branch."

Meanwhile, the Florida Supreme Court has not always been good to Scott and the Republican-controlled state Legislature.

In the past four years, the court has rejected the Legislature's attempts to put constitutional amendments on the ballot that would ban the state from participating in the Affordable Care Act, weaken a citizen redistricting initiative, give tax breaks to first-time home buyers and weaken the voter-approved class-size amendment.

In August 2011, the justices said in a 5-2 opinion that Scott had violated the separation of powers doctrine when he suspended rule making by state agencies as one of his first acts in office. Just this month, the court ruled 5-2 against Republicans to require that legislators must testify about their motives in a dispute over redistricting. And the court raised doubts about the constitutionality of a law passed last year and signed by Scott to limit medical malpractice lawsuits when it rejected a procedural rule on expert witnesses by a 5-2 margin.

While Scott and legislative leaders did not campaign against Pariente, Lewis and Quince when they were up for merit-retention election in 2012, their public comments made it clear they did not support them.

"The current administration is not receptive to the rights of the individual," said Lance Block, former chairman of the Academy of Trial Lawyers. "There's so much at stake this election, you'll see trial lawyers participate at a very significant rate."

Since announcing his candidacy in November, Crist has raised more than $3 million for his political committee and his election fund, and more than a third has come from lawyers and law firms. The largest donation came from Grossman Roth PA, a personal injury law firm in Coral Gables.

"The only real check we've had on legislative power since Republicans took control of both chambers has been the Supreme Court,'' said Neal Roth, who has spent a career defending patients in medical malpractice disputes.

He also believes Scott has imposed a litmus test on his court appointees, rejecting dozens of applicants because of their party affiliation and temperament, and he considers that short-sighted. "I want honest umpires. That's what I'm looking for,'' he said.

Roth believes that when Crist was a Republican his record was more moderate and he was more inclined to pick judges that "don't start out with some preconceived notion of where these cases should land."

By contrast, Scott's political committee has raised more than $22 million, much of it from groups who want to see the Supreme Court more aligned with the conservative principles of the governor and Legislature.

Scott's general counsel, Pete Antonacci, who advises the governor on his court appointments, rejects the notion that the governor applies an ideological litmus test to his court picks.

"He wants people with humility,'' Antonacci said. "And he wants judges who will follow the law and not make it up as they go along."

Florida law requires that the governor make selections for trial and appellate court judges from a list supplied by 26 judicial nominating commissions. But Scott has worked hard to make sure he has a stamp on the nine-member commissions.

The governor appoints five of the members and picks the four others from a list provided by the Florida Bar's Board of Governors, some of whom are Democrats who opposed Scott's election.

Scott has rejected dozens of attorneys nominated by the Florida Bar, many of whom are Democrats or aligned with left-leaning groups, to be appointed to judicial nominating commissions and has made it clear he wants conservatives appointed to the court.

If Crist is re-elected, this time as a Democrat, and each of the current Supreme Court justices up for retirement steps down while he is in office, his appointees will fill the entire court. The three justices who will not reach the mandatory retirement age in the next four years — Jorge Labarga, Charles Canady and Ricky Polston — were each appointed by Crist.

While Chiles' appointees have composed the more liberal-minded wing of the court, Crist's appointees reflect his political shift. Polston and Canady, appointed when Crist was trying to shore up his conservative bona fides, are the strict conservatives while Labarga and Perry have provided the swing vote in several pivotal cases.

In a handful of cases, the moderates on the court have sided with the conservatives.

Last year, for example, the court gave Gov. Scott the biggest legal victory of his term, a 4-3 decision upholding a 2011 law that reduced state employees' payments by 3 percent to offset the state's contribution to their retirement. In that case, Canady, Polston, Labarga and Pariente made up the majority. In the dissent were Justices Quince, Perry and Lewis.

But more frequent have been the 5-2 decisions on controversial political cases. Crist said that when he was governor, he interviewed every candidate before he made his selections and imposing an ideological litmus test was never his marker, fairness was.

Now, he says that, going forward: "There might not be a bigger issue."

Contact Mary Ellen Klas at

Changing the court

Florida's Constitution requires that state Supreme Court justices retire at age 70, or at the end of their six-year term, if they are halfway through the term, whichever is later. In the next four years, four of the seven justices reach mandatory retirement age:

Barbara J. Pariente

• Appointed by Democrat Gov. Lawton Chiles

• Took office 1997

• Turns 70 on Dec. 24, 2018

• Mandatory retirement January 2019

R. Fred Lewis

• Appointed by Democrat Gov. Lawton Chiles

• Took office 1999

• Turns 70 on Dec. 14, 2017

• Mandatory retirement January 2019

Peggy A. Quince

• Appointed jointly by Democrat Gov. Lawton Chiles and Republican Gov. Jeb Bush

• Took office 1999

• Turns 70 on Jan. 3, 2018

• Mandatory retirement January 2019

James E.C. Perry

• Appointed by then-Republican Gov. Charlie Crist

• Took office 2009

• Turns 70 in January 2014 and term expires in December 2016

• Mandatory retirement in January 2017

Next governor may put stamp on Florida Supreme Court 12/21/13 [Last modified: Saturday, December 21, 2013 10:35pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Last steel beam marks construction milestone for Tom and Mary James' museum


    ST. PETERSBURG — Tom and Mary James on Wednesday signed their names to the last steel beam framing the 105-ton stone mesa that will be built at the entrance of the museum that bears their name: the James Museum of Western and Wildlife Art.

    The topping-out ceremony of the James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art was held Wednesday morning in downtown St. Petersburg. Mary James (from left), husband Tom and Mayor Rick Kriseman signed the final beam before it was put into place. When finished, the $55 million museum at 100 Central Ave. will hold up to 500 pieces of the couple's 3,000-piece art collection. [Courtesy of James Museum of Western & Wildlife Art]
  2. Florida's school grades improve as educators get the hang of a new system


    Following a trend, Florida's school grades showed strong gains in the third year after the state changed its grading formula and the standardized tests that students take every year.

    After finding out earlier Wednesday that her school went from a low C to an A,  Bear Creek Elementary principal Willette Houston celebrates with her students in the YMCA After School program at the school in St. Petersburg. Houston is giving a high five to rising fifth grader Jonaven Viera. Rising 4th grader Jonathan Cafaro is in foreground with his back to camera. [CHERIE DIEZ   |   Times]
  3. Tampa Bay woman, 11-year-old boy had sex up to 20 times the year their baby was born, detectives say.


    TAMPA — A woman sexually battered an 11-year-old Brandon boy, got pregnant and raised the baby for three years before a tip led to her arrest, Hillsborough County sheriff's officials said.

    Marissa Mowry, now 25,  had sex as many as 20 times in 2014 with a boy who was 11 when he impregnated her, Hillsborough County detectives allege. [Photo courtesy of Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office]
  4. Heights Public Market to host two Tampa Bay food trucks


    TAMPA — The Heights Public Market announced the first two food trucks for its "rotating stall," which will feature new restaurants every four months. Surf and Turf and Empamamas will be rolled out first.

    Heights Public Market is opening this summer inside the Tampa Armature Works building.
[SKIP O'ROURKE   |   Times file photo]

  5. Mariners lose lefty Drew Smyly to Tommy John surgery


    SEATTLE — Drew Smyly was the centerpiece to one of Seattle's many offseason moves by general manager Jerry Dipoto. He was a priority acquisition as a proven lefty for the rotation the Mariners believed would thrive pitching at Safeco Field.

    Drew Smyly will undergo Tommy John surgery after being diagnosed with a torn ulnar collateral ligament. Seattle announced the diagnosis on Wednesday, ending Smyly's hopes of returning during the 2017 season. [AP photo]