Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Observers say judicial campaigns have crossed line

TAMPA — Campaign mailings for two Hillsborough judicial candidates have people debating what is acceptable political speech for nonpartisan races and stirring up what had been a quiet election season.

One judicial candidate called her opponent, an incumbent, "inefficient and ineffective." An e-mail on behalf of another judicial candidate suggests a competitor is "more liberal."

Critics say the statements go too far. The candidates disagree.

In a mailer sent to absentee voters, veteran family law attorney Catherine Catlin criticizes incumbent Circuit Judge J. Kevin Carey as "inefficient and ineffective." The mailer says "Our Taxpayers Deserve Better — a judge who controls a courtroom, makes rulings without months of delay and puts in a full day's work 'just like the rest of us.' "

Carey supporters, many of them lawyers who last week flooded editorial writers' e-mail with letters, are fuming over what they feel is an unwarranted attack. They describe Carey, elected to the bench in 2002, as tireless and diligent.

"I'm disappointed," Thomas Scarritt Jr., a lawyer and Carey's campaign coordinator, said of the mailer. "It's bringing down the level of the integrity of the system."

According to the rules that govern judicial elections, candidates generally may criticize a political opponent as long as the statements are "truthful, pertinent and material to judicial office." They must not "knowingly misrepresent the identity, qualifications, present position or other fact" about another judicial candidate.

Catlin said voters want to know why she is challenging an incumbent. The mailer is based on her personal experiences from practicing law in front of Carey for 3 1/2 years and can be corroborated by other lawyers, she said.

"That is my opinion," she said. "You do not give up your right for free speech just because you're running for judge."

Pat Anderson, who has prosecuted cases for the Judicial Qualifications Commission, said judicial candidates must walk a "fine and difficult line" with their campaign literature. Catlin, she said, may have crossed it.

"She's making a direct personal attack on this incumbent," said Anderson, who is not involved in either campaign. "She might be completely accurate in her comment but, believe it or not, that's not really the standard."

The campaign rhetoric also has heated up in the race between Linda Courtney Clark and Lisa Campbell, both private lawyers seeking to replace retiring Circuit Judge J. Rogers Padgett.

A letter authored by former state Sen. John Grant and circulating on e-mail listservs notes that Clark "has a tough campaign and faces someone who takes a far more liberal position on the social and moral issues that you and I care about." The letter mentions Clark's church involvement but nothing about her legal background.

In an interview, Grant, a conservative Republican, said he considers Campbell more liberal because she is a registered Democrat who supports Barack Obama for president. He said Campbell can be judged by her affiliations even though judicial races in Florida are supposed to be strictly nonpartisan.

"Everybody still takes their views to the bench," Grant said. "They don't go in a vacuum."

Campbell declined to say who she supports for president, because she's running in a nonpartisan race.

Grant's letter prompted a sharply worded response from Campbell supporter and lawyer Morris "Sandy" Weinberg Jr., who said partisan comments "absolutely have no place in a judicial race."

"I really find that to be beyond the pale," Weinberg said. "He's a lawyer. He knows better."

Anderson, the lawyer who is unaffiliated with the campaigns, said Grant is using "code language" to imply that Campbell's political beliefs would negatively affect her ability to serve.

"He's injected partisanship into a nonpartisan race," Anderson said. "And he probably should not do that."

Colleen Jenkins can be reached at or (813) 226-3337.

Observers say judicial campaigns have crossed line 08/05/08 [Last modified: Sunday, August 10, 2008 12:21pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'There's nothing left': $253,000 worth of missing pianos stirs outrage


    Lisa Williams was going through a messy divorce. Money was tight. She had to move to a smaller house, but there was no room for the beloved Schimmel baby grand piano she bought for her daughter two decades ago.

    Lisa Williams of Pinellas Park is one of several people who had their pianos stolen, and then lost the money they were supposed to get for them. Largo police are saying they were ripped off through a scheme run by the owner of a defunct piano shop in Clearwater.
[EVE EDELHEIT   |   Times]
  2. MacDill tanker crews keep fighter planes in the air during the battle against ISIS


    AL UDEID AIR BASE, QATAR — Settled into the cockpit, headed for the combat zone of Iraq, the three-man crew from MacDill Air Force Base can't wait to get in the air.

    But wait they must.

     Air Force Capt. Doug Karl (L) and Maj. Ryan Jahnke check landing coordinates on their tablets as they fly toward Royal Air Force Mildenhall from MacDill Air Force Base. [HOWARD ALTMAN  |  Times
  3. Lifestyle changes to stave off Alzheimer's? Hints, no proof


    WASHINGTON — There are no proven ways to stave off Alzheimer's, but a new report raises the prospect that avoiding nine key risks starting in childhood just might delay or even prevent about a third of dementia cases around the world.

    In this Oct. 7, 2003, file photo, a section of a human brain with Alzheimer's disease is on display at the Museum of Neuroanatomy at the University at Buffalo, in Buffalo, N.Y. There are no proven ways to stave off Alzheimer's, but a new report raises the prospect that avoiding nine risks starting in childhood just might delay or even prevent about a third of dementia cases. [AP Photo/David Duprey, File]
  4. City Attorney: State won't pursue criminal charges in St. Pete's sewage crisis


    The St. Petersburg City Council is expected to approve a consent order later today that requires the city to spend $326 million on improving its sewer system.

    St. Petersburg's sewage crisis appears to be winding down
  5. Review: 'A Really Big Lunch' a fitting last supper from Jim Harrison


    As much as I loved Jim Harrison's fiction and poetry, I've always had a special affection for his food writing. Boisterous and erudite and opinionated and wildly sensual, it always seemed his most personal writing, slipping the veil of fiction and the rigor of poems, and rippling with humor.