Tuesday, April 24, 2018
News Roundup

Carlton column: In Schenecker case, a verdict but not an answer

The salon blond of the suburban mom was gone from her hair, now mousy and escaping wildly from a messy braid at the nape of her neck. She wore no discernible makeup, the kind a Tampa Palms mom might put on for a trip to Target or the kids' soccer carpool, just a naked, empty face in the courtroom.

And even after days of watching Julie Schenecker on trial for the murders of her own children, of hearing that she was either insane or knew exactly what she was doing, you could not know what was behind that face.

She did not take the stand to defend herself, but after the jury said "guilty" swiftly on Thursday — surprising pretty much no one — she stood to speak before the judge.

"I know I shot my son and daughter," she said. "I don't know why.'' And no matter how you felt about those doctors' differing opinions, maybe like me you believed at least this.

Haggard and strange, rambling but lucid, Schenecker apologized to everyone — friends, family, strangers — and praised the judge, her public defenders, the justice system even. She said she was sorry if children might have heard how she shot her own — Beau, 13, still in the family van in the garage, and then daughter Calyx, 16, who was upstairs doing homework — and wonder about their own mother.

But really, did the words matter? The kids were still gone.

Notably, she did not mention her now ex-husband, father of their murdered children, who sat still as a stone in the courtroom. Stoic on the witness stand, blamed by those who asked how he could have left his children with this damaged person, former Army Col. Parker Schenecker remains a mystery.

Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty to appease the angry, and that was right. When Assistant State Attorney Jay Pruner showed the jury the worst of the photographs, thankfully he angled them so courtroom spectators could not see what was there.

But there were other photos in the news: a Schenecker family portrait, everyone smiling in Santa hats. Beau with his fishing pole, Calyx running track. Dad and the kids on a beach somewhere. A younger, softer Julie with her babies. It makes no sense.

Under the law, that jury of women and men, mothers and fathers, had to determine if she knew what she was doing, if she knew it was wrong. She was depressed and heavily medicated and drinking and she had bipolar disorder. She also deliberately bought a gun and lied about why, waited the waiting period and planned her plans. Under the law, the verdict was probably not all that complicated.

The guilty-so-say-we-all gave cable TV mouthpiece Nancy Grace one last chance to gnash teeth and dab tears before moving on to the next juicy case. The judge, Emmett Lamar Battles, did not use the moment of reckoning to wring hands or thunder pronouncements from the bench. He said levelly that it was almost too much to comprehend what brought everyone there. Then he pronounced the state-mandated punishment that she will never be free again. That was all. It has to be enough.

And so she was led away by bailiffs to begin the rest of her life in prison, disappearing like smoke out a courtroom side door. Then everyone left quietly. There was nothing to be glad of here — a verdict and an ending but not an answer.

Comments
Waffle House shooter’s guns were seized but then returned

Waffle House shooter’s guns were seized but then returned

Travis Reinking exhibited multiple warning signs that he was mentally unstable: He talked openly about delusions that he was being stalked by Taylor Swift. He insisted unknown people were making barking noises outside his home. He even went to the Wh...
Updated: 6 minutes ago
Bruins’ Brad Marchand: ‘You have to be willing to do anything … in order to win’

Bruins’ Brad Marchand: ‘You have to be willing to do anything … in order to win’

Brad Marchand might be the ultimate pest, but he's not the original.Not even in his own family.The Boston Bruins left wing writes in a first-person story published last week in The Players' Tribune that he got his inspiration from his younger br...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
Rays prospect Adames hits for cycle

Rays prospect Adames hits for cycle

Willy Adames, the Rays top position player prospect, touched all the bases in hitting for the cycle in Triple-A Durham's Monday's win over Buffalo.Adames doubled in the first inning, singled in the fifth, tripled in the sixth and completed the rare f...
Updated: 8 minutes ago
Forecast: After storms produce damage in Ruskin, clear conditions ahead for Tampa Bay

Forecast: After storms produce damage in Ruskin, clear conditions ahead for Tampa Bay

ST. PETERSBURG — Forecasters said rain could fall on Monday before conditions cleared, leaving drier air and less humidity behind.That rain moved through Ruskin with a vengeance Monday night, and produced a treacherous early-morning commute for resid...
Updated: 18 minutes ago
The Daystarter: A Murphy-Jolly gubernatorial run?; ALF residents’ deplorable conditions; committee to pick pier art; Lightning must wait to learn opponent

The Daystarter: A Murphy-Jolly gubernatorial run?; ALF residents’ deplorable conditions; committee to pick pier art; Lightning must wait to learn opponent

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what to know today.   • Give thanks for drier air. There is a small rain chance this morning, but things dry out by the afternoon, according to 10Weather WTSP. Beats yesterday’s humidity. The...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
Ex-Bucs QB Jeff Garcia doesn’t care about NFL draft: ‘I have a life’

Ex-Bucs QB Jeff Garcia doesn’t care about NFL draft: ‘I have a life’

So much of the attention Monday surrounding the Bucs' announcing who'd be announcing their late-round draft picks was, of course, that a parrot would be delivering the name of the fourth-round pick to the pirate ship at Raymond James Stadium.But late...
Updated: 1 hour ago
NFL Draft: Date, time, TV schedule and draft order for the April 26-28 draft

NFL Draft: Date, time, TV schedule and draft order for the April 26-28 draft

The NFL Draft starts Thursday from Arlington, Texas, with coverage of the first round beginning at 8 p.m. ET. Here's a look at the broadcast schedule for all three days and the draft order for every round:Schedule(all times Eastern)Thursday, April 26...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Authorities searching for missing Wesley Chapel boy, 12

Authorities searching for missing Wesley Chapel boy, 12

A Florida Missing Child Alert has been issued for a 12-year-old boy in Wesley Chapel.According to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Tyshawn Govan was last seen near the 2200 block of Marsh View Drive.He is 5 feet 6 and 110 pounds, with blac...
Updated: 1 hour ago
St. Pete Pier public arts committee to meet with finalists, make decision

St. Pete Pier public arts committee to meet with finalists, make decision

ST. PETERSBURG — The pier public arts committee is expected to decide today which artist or artists will have their work showcased in the new 26-acre Pier District. The committee, which selected six finalists with the help of consultant Ann Wykell, w...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Twin sisters from Tampa helping shape Fox’s ‘Empire’ say they’d like to tell Tampa stories

Twin sisters from Tampa helping shape Fox’s ‘Empire’ say they’d like to tell Tampa stories

JaNeika and JaSheika James’ television obsession was fueled by scarcity and convenience. As self-described "military brats" living in Germany, the girls treasured the VHS tapes their grandmother shipped overseas filled with English-language Saturday ...
Updated: 2 hours ago