Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

State Sen. J.D. Alexander fired American citizens and green card holders, hired guest workers instead, lawsuit says

TALLAHASSEE — In the waning days of the 2011 legislative session, Sen. JD Alexander, one of the state's most powerful lawmakers, delivered an impassioned floor speech against a measure that would have required employers to check the immigration status of new hires.

Alexander, a Republican from Lake Wales, offered a firsthand account of housing guest workers from Mexico to help pick his crops.

"You can't get anybody to come do this stuff, folks. And it's the same thing, whether it's construction, or whether it's hotels. Americans don't want to do it," Alexander said moments before the Senate defeated the legislation, a top priority of Gov. Rick Scott.

Now, Alexander, who owns a farm in Polk County, is facing a lawsuit from two farmworkers who say he violated federal law by firing American citizens and green card holders and replacing them with guest workers.

Alexander, the chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, declined to comment for this story.

"It's pending litigation," he said. "I've been advised not to comment."

According to the lawsuit, Jose Luis Castro-Mata, a green card holder who picked strawberries on Alexander's Blue Head Farms in the 2009-10 season, was fired after Alexander discovered he was not a guest worker, said Gregory Schell, part of the Migrant Farmworker Justice Project.

"They told him we don't need you anymore. Get lost," Schell said, adding that Alexander then hired guest workers instead.

Why would Alexander do that?

"Guest workers only can work for one employer, the one who got them their Visa. So they're less likely to complain," Schell said. "They want to hire the young motivated Mexican whose choice is to work here or go back to Third World poverty."

Schell's client isn't the only farmworker making that claim.

Colin Abbott, an attorney for Florida Rural Legal Services, represents about 100 American citizens and green card holders who say they, too, were dismissed and replaced with guest workers.

"They didn't receive the work that they were promised," said Abbott, who has not yet filed a lawsuit.

Abbott said he has met several times with Alexander's attorneys, and is trying to work out an agreement to get his clients — most of them black — paid for the work they were promised.

"Several of my clients have gone back to work at Blue Head. They don't consider Blue Head to be not a good employer. The fact is, that one season that just happened," Abbott said. "Pretty much we're looking for justice for the 2009-10 work season because they feel they didn't get the wages they deserved."

The suit filed by Schell on August 24 in U.S. District Court in Fort Myers, asks for lost wages for Castro-Mata as well as Miguel Patino-Flores, a guest worker from Mexico.

Both men say Alexander paid them $8.56 an hour, rather than the $9.08 rate set for guest workers in Florida by the U.S. Department of Labor in May 2009.

Although Castro-Mata was not a guest worker, federal law requires that growers pay domestic workers the same rate as guest workers.

Pay rates for guest workers, though, are being challenged in a federal court in North Carolina. In June 2009, a judge issued an injunction against the Department of Labor, freezing the old payment schedule.

David Koon, CFO of Alexander's Atlantic Blue Group, Inc., which includes Blue Head Farms, said the company used the old rate when paying workers in the 2009-2010 season.

"The company believes it acted applicably and legally," Koon said.

Schell said the decision to sue over the amount workers were paid per hour was included in the lawsuit to avoid a two-year statute of limitations on unpaid wage disputes.

"If the North Carolina court ultimately decides they should get the money, it doesn't do any good if the two-year statute of limitations has run out," Schell said. "We're about getting the people the money."

Janet Zink can be reached at or (850) 224-7263.

State Sen. J.D. Alexander fired American citizens and green card holders, hired guest workers instead, lawsuit says 09/08/11 [Last modified: Friday, September 9, 2011 10:44am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Deputies say Wesley Chapel man admitted to having child pornography


    WESLEY CHAPEL — A man admitted to possessing child pornography, according to the Pasco Sheriff's Office, after authorities seized several computers, tablets, thumb drives, DVDs and cell phones from his property.

    Jeffrey D. Stanford was arrested on 10 counts of possessing child pornography. [Photo courtesy of Pasco Sheriff's Office]
  2. Scalise discharged from hospital, beginning rehabilitation


    WASHINGTON — House Majority Whip Steve Scalise — who was critically wounded in a shooting at a baseball practice last month — has been discharged from a Washington hospital.

    House Majority Whip Rep. Steve Scalise of La., speaks with the media on Capitol Hill in Washington on May 17, 2017. Scalise, critically wounded in a shooting at a baseball practice last month, has been discharged from a Washington hospital. [Associated Press]
  3. FWC identifies boaters seen dragging shark in viral video


    Officials with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission have identified the individuals shown on a viral video dragging a shark behind a boat on a rope as men laugh each time its body slams the water.

    The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission is investigating a viral video that shows a shark being dragged behind a boat on a rope as men laugh each time its body slams the water. [Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission]
  4. Steve Schale: Democrats and Republicans chose wisely for Miami senate race


    Democratic strategist Steve Schale breaks down the Florida Senate District 40 special election contest between Republican  Jose Felix 'Pepi' Diaz and Democrat  Annette Taddeo, saying primary voters chose right and that either could win. Diaz and Taddeo

  5. Atomic Blonde does not live up to its giant movie poster hype


    Beware of movies spending money selling one scene, like the Atomic Blonde poster big enough to block a restroom entry, as it has for a while at AMC Westshore 14.

    Charlize Theron, left, and Sofia Boutella in "Atomic Blonde." (Jonathan Prime/Focus Features via AP)