Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

State Supreme Court to discipline judge for written opinion

TALLAHASSEE — For the first time, the Florida Supreme Court will discipline a judge for something he wrote in a court opinion.

The high court on Thursday ordered a public reprimand for Judge Michael E. Allen of the 1st District Court of Appeal, because he questioned the ethics of a fellow judge in a written opinion.

Five members of the state's high court, in an unsigned opinion, ordered Allen to appear before them for a reprimand. The court's two newest justices did not participate in the case.

The court accepted a recommendation of the Judicial Qualifications Commission that said Allen crossed the line when he criticized Judge Charles J. Kahn Jr. for participating in a criminal case involving former Senate President W.D. Childers of Pensacola.

Kahn once practiced law with Pensacola lawyer Fred Levin, a longtime friend of Childers who helped the former senator and then-Gov. Lawton Chiles craft the law that allowed the state to sue tobacco companies.

In a 2006 opinion, Allen said Kahn's attempt to overturn Childers' bribery conviction might be misconstrued by Floridians familiar with newspaper stories describing the relationship between Kahn, Levin and Chiles.

The high court was especially critical of Allen for using newspaper accounts, though the court then went on to take note of newspaper stories written about Allen's opinion, saying they did not promote public confidence in the judiciary.

The court also had a warning for the JQC: "we caution that our opinion today should not be viewed as a license for the JQC to judge and evaluate judicial opinions.''

Judges sometimes use intemperate or colorful language, the court said, but it said Allen crossed the line by falsely accusing Judge Kahn of corruption and using unverified statements from materials outside of the record of the case.

The Supreme Court opinion made no mention of the uproar surrounding Kahn's alleged affair with a court clerk — a situation that prompted 13 of his fellow judges to force Kahn out of the chief judge's job and file a JQC complaint against him.

The commission dismissed that complaint, but the hearing panel that recommended a reprimand for Allen urged JQC investigators to take another look at Kahn's behavior.

Bruce Rogow, the Fort Lauderdale lawyer who represents Allen, said the judge is disappointed. "He wrote the opinion to explain his reasons for voting … and is sorry that it was misunderstood by the court,'' Rogow said. He complimented the court for at least recognizing the importance of judicial independence and said Judge Allen is ready to move on.

In suggesting a public reprimand, the JQC said Allen has led a long unblemished and distinguished career. Allen was a public defender in North Florida when he was appointed to the appellate court in 1990 by then-Gov. Bob Martinez.

No date was set for Allen to appear before the court.

Lucy Morgan can be reached at or (850) 224-7263.

State Supreme Court to discipline judge for written opinion 12/18/08 [Last modified: Monday, December 22, 2008 12:32pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Once 'angry' about Obamacare, Republican David Jolly came to see it as 'safety net'


    Former Congressman David Jolly, who ran against Obamacare in 2013, said in an interview Monday night that he now considers it a "safety net."

  2. Five children hospitalized after chlorine release at Tampa pool store


    Five children were sickened at a pool store north of Tampa on Monday after a cloud of chlorine was released, according to Hillsborough County Fire Rescue.

  3. Deputies find unidentified decomposing body in Dunedin canal

    Public Safety

    DUNEDIN — Pinellas County sheriff's deputies found an unidentified male body floating in a Dunedin canal Monday afternoon, the Sheriff's Office said.

  4. Rays acquire slick-fielding shortstop Adeiny Hechavarria from Marlins

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Chaim Bloom said the Rays weren't necessarily in the market for a shortstop. The team has a number of those. But when the Marlins recently began shopping Adeiny Hechavarria, well, that was too much to pass up.

    Adeiny Hechavarria has emerged as one of baseball’s top defensive shortstops in the past three seasons with the Marlins.
  5. Lightning journal: Forward Yanni Gourde agrees to two-year deal

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — Just three years ago, Yanni Gourde was fighting to stay in pro hockey.

    Tampa Bay Lightning center Yanni Gourde celebrates after scoring against the Florida Panthers during the second period of an NHL hockey game, Saturday, March 11, 2017, in Tampa, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) TPA108