Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Supreme Court's campaign donations ruling likely to have little effect on Tampa Bay judges

Members of the Tampa Bay area legal community don't expect much local fallout from the U.S. Supreme Court decision this week that, for the first time, requires elected judges to take themselves off cases involving generous campaign donors.

Justices and appellate judges in Florida are appointed, unlike the West Virginia Supreme Court justice ordered off a case that overturned a $50 million verdict against a company whose chief executive contributed $3 million in his election.

The state's county and circuit judges face re-election every four to six years, respectively. But they can't get more than $500 in individual campaign contributors, and their donations rarely come from corporate fat cats.

Instead, their campaigns are funded largely by the attorneys who practice before them. That system comes with its own concerns, though local attorneys and judges insist that due process is not dictated by campaign money.

"I know it sounds almost Pollyannish," said Hillsborough Circuit Judge William Levens, but "the reality is the judges take (their) oath more seriously than any debt that would flow from a campaign contribution."

Laughing, he added, "I have ruled against contributors."

When Levens filed for re-election last year, all but three of his 155 contributors were lawyers. He returned the bulk of the money after drawing no challengers.

One of those contributors, civil trial attorney Chris Knopik, said some people might contribute to judicial races hoping that their clients will somehow benefit. But he suspects the majority of lawyers write checks for the same reason he does: "Because I felt that they were definitely the superior candidate and not because I expected anything."

Lawyers are often the only people contributing to judicial campaigns because they are also the only ones paying attention to them, said Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge W. Douglas Baird.

"The public doesn't know whether (judges) are good or bad, or smart or stupid," he said. "This is the whole problem with electing judges."

Legal types acknowledged, however, the corrupting political influence that could occur with an appointment-only system.

Though local judicial races have grown more expensive, none has had anywhere near the money involved in the extreme case at the center of this week's Supreme Court decision.

Justice Anthony Kennedy said not every campaign contribution by a litigant or attorney creates a "probability of bias."

Supreme Court's campaign donations ruling likely to have little effect on Tampa Bay judges 06/09/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, June 9, 2009 10:49pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Gay, black leaders speak about finding their place


    When Lillian Dunlap moved to Florida at age 52 in 1999 she could finally breathe. The journalism professor from the University of Missouri and the University of Indiana hadn't been able live openly as a gay woman until then. She had considered coming out before but never did.

    Terri Lipsey Scott (standing) welcomed panelists Bob Devin Jones, Desmond Clark, Lillian Dunlap, Trevor Pettiford and Sheree Greer. Moderator Nadine Smith not pictured.
  2. Bar review: Les Partners Lounge goes old-school in Clearwater

    Bars & Spirits

    There are some local places that I'm shocked aren't more well known, and I think that's the result of a general aversion to stepping out of one's comfort zone. I make regular concerted efforts to step outside of mine, which often leads me to strange and rewarding drinking establishments.

    Les Partners Lounge is an old-school, smoker-friendly cocktail lounge and live music venue tucked away in a nondescript shopping plaza in Island Estates.
  3. Local craft beer of the week: Plongeur a L'eponge, Saint Somewhere Brewing Co.

    Bars & Spirits

    Tarpon Springs' Saint Somewhere Brewing Co. has a somewhat idiosyncratic approach to wild ale brewing, utilizing an open brewing approach involving uncovered fermenters in order to brew beer with local ambient microbes, reminiscent in some ways to the fermentation techniques used by rustic farmhouse breweries in Belgium …

     Plongeur a?€š€™L?ˆš??ponge, Saint Somewhere Brewing Company, 6/23/17  Electric Chair Sour Shandy, Angry Chair Brewing, 6/30/17   Pulp Friction Grapefruit IPA, Motorworks Brewing 7/7/17
  4. No tapes: Trump says he didn't record meetings with Comey


    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump said Thursday he "did not make" and doesn't have any recordings of his private conversations with ousted FBI Director James Comey, speaking up on Twitter after a month-long guessing game that began with him delivering an ominous warning and ended with his administration ensnared …

    President Donald Trump speaks during the "American Leadership in Emerging Technology" event in the East Room of the White House, Thursday, June 22, 2017, in Washington. [AP Photo/Evan Vucci]
  5. Ramadan having an economic impact on local charities, businesses

    Economic Development

    TAMPA — Dodging the rain, a few families and customers gathered inside Petra Restaurant on Busch Boulevard. Around 8:30 p.m., the adham (or call to prayer) music begins, signaling Iftar, the end of the daily fast. Customers grabbed a plate to dig into the feast.

    Baha Abdullah, 35, the owner of the Sultan Market makes kataif, a common dessert that is eaten during the month long celebration of Ramadan in Tampa. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]