Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

U.S. Supreme Court to decide: Were Tampa police clear about suspect's Miranda rights?

Inside a small interview room at the Tampa Police Department in August 2004, an officer read Kevin Dewayne Powell his rights.

Among them: "You have the right to talk to a lawyer before answering any of our questions. … You have the right to use any of these rights at any time you want during this interview."

It's a portion of the ubiquitous Miranda warning, a fundamental element of the criminal justice system and one now ingrained in the American psyche thanks to television cop dramas.

But it's a little more complicated than what is shown on TV. The Supreme Court, which required that suspects be made aware of their rights through its Miranda ruling in 1966, has resisted establishing a template for the warning. So different jurisdictions have various, though similar, Miranda warnings.

"On the surface it seems like a simple rule, but it has spawned a lot of litigation over the meaning of the words," said Richard Leo, a law professor and author on the issue.

Powell's case is no different. The U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments today about whether the Tampa Police Department adequately advised Powell of his right to an attorney.

Law enforcement agencies nationwide are expected to closely watch the hearing and subsequent decision, which could affect an untold number of cases.

Police arrested Powell on a charge of possession of a firearm by a convicted felon when they saw him leaving a room where they found a gun hidden under a bed. Powell signed a form acknowledging his rights and confessed to owning the gun.

At trial, he reversed himself, explaining that the police officers threatened to arrest his girlfriend and take away her children if he didn't take responsibility. A jury convicted him and the judge sentenced him to 10 years in prison.

The state's highest court, in its September 2008 ruling, said authorities needed to expressly convey the right to have an attorney present during questioning. The Tampa police's warning "suggests to a reasonable person in the suspect's shoes that he or she can only consult with an attorney before questioning," the opinion stated.

Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum asked the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene, calling clarification of the issue "crucial."

"The Florida Supreme Court … is demanding more from law enforcement than (the U.S. Supreme Court) ever envisioned or deemed necessary in Miranda," the state's argument reads, citing the landmark decision.

Tampa police no longer use the exact warning in question. But a handful of cases in Florida, including the death penalty case of Thomas Rigterink of Winter Haven, are pending a clarification of the Miranda standard.

McCollum's chief of staff, Joe Jacquot, 39, will argue the state's case in Washington. He is asking the court to determine that the spirit of the warning is more important than the actual language.

"The goal of Miranda is to ensure voluntary confessions," said Jacquot (pronounced Jay-co). "I would imagine that in law enforcement agencies across the nation every day there is a missed word or inconsistent translation … those confessions need to be protected."

The case is Jacquot's first before the high court, but he will get support from the U.S. Solicitor General's Office, whose interest in the case suggests its importance for the law enforcement community.

Attorneys in Florida and criminal law experts are looking to the Supreme Court to distill the necessary wording.

"There's not much clarity here," said Wayne Logan, a law professor at Florida State University. "What we need here is something more structural to get rid of the word parsing."

The view is echoed by Leo, the professor at the University of San Francisco and an expert on Miranda law. He conducted a study that found 89 out of 90 law enforcement agencies in Florida included the words "during questioning" in their warnings.

He filed a brief in the case supporting Powell, that argued if the state wins the case, it would create incentives for law enforcement to experiment with the Miranda warnings to generate more confessions.

"The Supreme Court has completely emasculated the law in the past and created a number of loopholes for law enforcement."

John Frank can be reached at jfrank@sptimes.com or (850) 224-7263.

U.S. Supreme Court to decide: Were Tampa police clear about suspect's Miranda rights? 12/06/09 [Last modified: Sunday, December 6, 2009 10:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Strategic Property Partners launches website for Water Street Tampa

    Business

    Strategic Property Partners has launched its official website for Water Street Tampa, its 53-acre redevelopment project in downtown Tampa Tuesday.

    Strategic Property Partners on Tuesday announced the name of its new development: Water Street Tampa. [Photos courtesy of SPP]
  2. Is Mikhail Sergachev, who debuts with Lightning at Wednesday camp, ready for the NHL?

    Lightning Strikes

    BRANDON — When defenseman Mikhail Sergachev was taken ninth overall by the Canadiens in the 2016 NHL draft, a horde of Montreal media surrounded him for his first news conference.

    Mikhail Sergachev takes a shot during warmups prior to a game between the Canadiens and Arizona Coyotes in October in Montreal. [Getty Images]
  3. ReliaQuest CEO Brian Murphy named sole Tampa Bay winner in EY state entrepreneur contest

    Business

    ReliaQuest founder and CEO Brian Murphy was named one of nine winners statewide and the only one from the Tampa Bay area in the Ernst and Young Entrepreneur Of The Year 2017 Florida Awards program. Murphy won in the IT security division after starting ReliaQuest in 2007. Five of the nine winners were from the Miami …

    Tampa's ReliaQuest founder and CEO Brian Murphy was named one of nine winners statewide and the only one from the Tampa Bay area in the Ernst and Young Entrepreneur Of The Year 2017 Florida Awards program. Murphy won in the IT security division after starting ReliaQuest in 2007.
  4. Top pick Brendan McKay signing with Rays for $7M bonus

    Blogs

    The Rays are set to sign top pick 1B/LHP Brendan McKay for a bonus just over $7-million, the Tampa Bay Times has learned.

    McKay was the No. 4 overall pick in the June 12 draft as he starred as a two-way player leading Louisville to the College World Series.

    The deal is expected to be finalized …

    Brendan McKay was the No. 4 overall pick in the June 12 draft as he starred as a two-way player leading Louisville to the College World Series.
  5. Man found dead in Dunedin canal identified as missing 63-year-old

    Public Safety

    DUNEDIN — Pinellas County sheriff's deputies on Tuesday identified the man found floating in a Dunedin canal as the man who was reported missing last week.

    Charles P. Morris, 63, was found dead in a canal in Dunedin behind Cedar Creek Mobile Home Park, at 605 Michigan Blvd. around 3:48 p.m. Monday. He was reported missing June 21 after he was last seen leaving his home the night before to walk his dog. [ Courtesy of the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]