Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Why only 6 on the Zimmerman jury?

With all eyes on Central Florida for the George Zimmerman trial and its aftermath, one question keeps surfacing: Why are juries made up of just six people?

Throughout most of the country, 12 jurors determine the guilt or innocence of suspects in felony trials.

But in Florida and a handful of other states, only six jurors are seated in the majority of felony cases — even in some of the most violent and serious crimes.

This element of Florida's criminal-justice system was highlighted during Zimmerman's trial and after his acquittal on second-degree-murder charges in the shooting death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin on Feb. 26, 2012.

When the all-female jury was chosen, critics pointed out the lack of diversity on the panel.

And now, in the wake of Zimmerman's acquittal, U.S. Rep. Randolph Bracy, D-Fla., is calling for state leaders to change Florida's law so that in felony trials, juries must have 12 members.

"It's more of a jury of one's peers when you have more jurors," said Bracy. "I think that is better for the people of Florida and for our criminal-justice system in general."

Legal experts and researchers back up Bracy's premise: that six-member juries are less diverse than 12-member panels, said Susan Rozelle, a law professor at Stetson University College of Law.

Defendants are constitutionally entitled to a fair cross-section of potential jurors, but that doesn't mean the people who are actually seated for the jury have to demonstrate that diversity, she said.

In Zimmerman's trial, all of the jurors were women — five of them white — and they ranged in age from 20s to 60s. Rozelle said even if the jury pool is ethnically diverse, a smaller panel lessens the likelihood of having other kinds of diversity.

Rozelle said if every juror on any panel has the same background, the same life experiences, and are the same demographic, they are likely going to view the facts the same. They may not see an alternative perspective because it simply didn't occur to them and they have no one to point it out, she said.

In some cases, the law professor said, "everyone agrees what the facts are, but they disagree bitterly on what those facts mean. If the trial is about truth seeking, it helps to have all possible interpretations of those facts considered."

In the days since Zimmerman was acquitted, the Seminole County jurors who found him not guilty have faced sharp criticism from legal observers and others. Some have questioned why there were no blacks on the jury because there were several in the pool that was culled from several hundred to 40 after a week of jury selection.

After one juror, known only as B-37, spoke out on CNN last week, saying race was not a consideration in deliberations, some critics said the homogeny of the panel led to a lack of empathy for the dead teenager.

Benjamin Crump, an attorney for Trayvon's parents, Sybrina Fulton and Tracy Martin, said it more pointedly: "(Juror B-37) never, ever saw Sybrina Fulton's child, Trayvon, as her child," Crump told CNN's Anderson Cooper. "She never saw that that could have been her child."

In addition to added diversity and range of experience, 12-member juries are more likely to deadlock, or "hang," than smaller panels, some experts say.

But researchers say further studies need to be conducted to determine other differences between six- and 12-member juries.

"The jury is really out on if it is more efficient or not" to have a smaller panel, said Mark Summers, a law professor at Barry University and former federal prosecutor and defense attorney.

Summers noted that jurors only have to come back with a simple guilty or not guilty verdict. They do not need to explain why or how they reached that conclusion.

And that poses a significant question, he says. Without knowing why a jury made the decision it did, "How do you say that your trial was unfair based on the fact you had a six-person jury?"

Why only 6 on the Zimmerman jury? 07/23/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, July 23, 2013 11:34am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Tribune News Service.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. IT failure blamed for British Airways cancellations (w/video)


    LONDON — British Airways canceled all flights from London's Heathrow and Gatwick airports on Saturday as a global IT failure upended the travel plans of tens of thousands of people on a busy U.K. holiday weekend.

    Passengers wait at a British Airways check-in desk after the airport suffered an IT systems failure Saturday at London''s Gatwick Airport. [Associated Press]
  2. Florida softball returns to World Series; FSU baseball in ACC title game


    GAINESVILLE — Florida defeated Alabama 2-1 Saturday to win the deciding Game 3 of their softball Super Region, putting the Gators in the Women's College World Series for the eighth time in program history.

    ’NOLE POWER: FSU’s Dylan Busby, right, is congratulated by teammate Taylor Walls after Busby’s homer against Duke.
  3. Calvary Christian routs Pensacola Christian to win state baseball title


    FORT MYERS — Calvary Christian left no doubt as to which baseball team in Class 4A was the best in Florida this season. The Warriors defeated Pensacola Catholic 11-1 in six innings Saturday night at Hammond Stadium to claim the school's first state championship in any team sport. It also solidified a perfect 30-0 …

    Matheu Nelson of Calvary Christian celebrates scoring on a wild pitch during the first inning.
  4. Mayor: Men stabbed after anti-Muslin rant died as 'heroes' (w/video)


    PORTLAND, Ore. — Police said Saturday they'll examine what appears to be the extremist ideology of an Oregon man accused of fatally stabbing two men who tried to intervene when the suspect yelled racial slurs at two young women who appeared to be Muslim on a Portland light-rail train.

    A sign of thanks rests against a traffic light pole at a memorial outside the transit center on Saturday in Portland, Ore. [Associated Press]
  5. Numerous lapses add up to frustrating Rays loss to Twins

    The Heater

    MINNEAPOLIS — While the Rays made some good defensive plays, threw a couple of big pitches when they needed to and got a few, and just a few, key hits, there were some obvious things they did wrong that led to them losing Saturday's game to the Twins 5-3:

    Rays reliever Tommy Hunter says the Twins’ tiebreaking homer came on a pitch that was “close to where I wanted it.”