Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Duke Energy customers face $1 billion-plus tab whether nuclear plant is fixed or not

It will cost at least $1.5 billion to fix the Crystal River nuclear plant, and possibly twice that much. If the plant isn’t fixed, customers likely will have to pay for whatever new plant replaces it.

WILL VRAGOVIC | Times (2011)

It will cost at least $1.5 billion to fix the Crystal River nuclear plant, and possibly twice that much. If the plant isn’t fixed, customers likely will have to pay for whatever new plant replaces it.

Duke Energy faces a potentially $3 billion decision on whether to fix its busted Crystal River nuclear plant. Regardless of their choice, however, customers will still get stuck paying for the billion-dollar-plus blunder.

If Duke shuts down the plant, customers will have to pay at least $1.6 billion to build another power source and buy alternate energy. If Duke fixes the plant, customers will be on the hook for buying more than $1 billion in alternate power even if they escape paying repair costs.

Those back-of-the-envelope numbers emerged in the wake of the independent review of repair options made public Monday. A close look at the details also reveals a major obstacle to any repair plan: the containment building's long history of structural problems. That, the report says, raises the risk that any attempted repair could itself further damage the plant, potentially doubling the repair cost.

The state Public Counsel's Office thinks the report, by Charlotte, N.C., consultant Zapata Inc., may portend some good news.

"I think this report was probably well done in terms of identifying the risks," said Charles Rehwinkel, deputy public counsel. "It's a valid due diligence that Duke did."

That, he said, may persuade the plant's insurer to pay for more of the repair than it has thus far.

Nevertheless, the bottom line will still be in the billions, and for Duke and its customers, there will be no easy way out.

• • •

As the Tampa Bay Times reported Tuesday, the Zapata report gives a best-case estimate of $1.5 billion to fix Crystal River and a worst case of more than $3 billion. But if Duke fixes the plant, customers also must continue paying for expensive power to replace the cheap energy Crystal River once generated. Replacement power would cost about $300 million a year.

The best-case estimate for the plant to return to service is in 2016 — seven years after it went offline during a botched maintenance and upgrade job. By then, the company will have spent about $2 billion on replacement power.

As part of a previous settlement agreement with the state, the utility agreed to refund customers $288 million of the replacement power costs. If Duke opts to repair the plant but can't begin this year — which appears likely — the utility will have to refund an additional $100 million.

If the plant isn't fixed, customers likely will have to pay for whatever type of new plant replaces it, such as a natural gas plant at roughly $1 billion plus replacement power during a couple of years of construction.

Duke maintains a decommissioning fund for Crystal River with about $600 million, but it could cost hundreds of millions more to completely shut down the facility.

Mitigating those expenses is whatever insurance pays toward repair and replacement power.

The insurer, the Nuclear Electric Insurance Limited, or NEIL, has not paid any money for damage at Crystal River since the second quarter of 2011. The policy includes coverage of more than $2 billion for repairs and $490 million for replacement power.

Duke officials have said negotiations over payment from NEIL would begin in the fourth quarter, but could not give a more definitive date Tuesday. "We're trying to be as diligent and responsible as possible," Duke spokesman Mike Hughes said.

The Zapata report explained just how difficult the repair is, starting with a concrete reactor containment building that has a history of structural weakness.

The dome atop the building cracked in 1976 during construction of the plant. The plant's 42-inch-thick walls cracked three times after workers cut into the building to replace old steam generators.

Engineers are looking at replacing the building's walls. The fear is that replacing the walls will cause the dome to crack again.

Some have nicknamed Crystal River the "Humpty Dumpty" plant.

If Duke makes too many changes to the building, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission could require the utility to file an amendment to its operating license. That would require public hearings.

"It opens the plant up to public participation, again," said Arnie Gundersen, a nuclear engineer and consultant. "They're terrified of letting this process open up."

The Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, an environmental group that has been scrutinizing Duke's nuclear plans in Florida, called on the state to seek other ways to meet its energy needs rather than repairing a 36-year-old nuclear plant.

Ivan Penn can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 892-2332.

Duke Energy customers face $1 billion-plus tab whether nuclear plant is fixed or not 10/02/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, October 2, 2012 7:55pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa Bay small businesses give Tampa B+ for regulatory climate


    In a recent survey about small business sentiments toward state and local government policies that affect them, Tampa Bay ranked at No. 25 out of 80 — a B+ overall.

    Tampa Bay ranked No. 25 out of 80 in a recent survey about how small business owners feel about state and local government policies that affect them. | [Times file photo]
  2. Dirk Koetter to Bucs: Take your complaints to someone who can help


    TAMPA — It was just another day of aching bellies at One Save Face.

    Dirk Koetter: “All of our issues are self-inflicted right now.”
  3. Seminole Heights murders: fear and warnings, but no answers


    TAMPA — Interim Tampa police Chief Brian Dugan elicited loud gasps from the crowd of about 400 who showed up at Edison Elementary School on Monday night to learn more about the string of unsolved killings that have left the southeast Seminole Heights neighborhood gripped by fear.

    Kimberly Overman, left, comforts Angelique Dupree, center, as she spoke about the death of her nephew Benjamin Mitchell, 22, last week in Seminole Heights. The Tampa Police Department held a town hall meeting Monday night where concerned residents hoped to learn more about the investigation into the three shooting deaths over 11 days in southeast Seminole Heights. But police could give the crowd at Edison Elementary School few answers. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]
  4. Juvenile justice reform seen as help for teen car theft problem


    ST. PETERSBURG — One of Tampa Bay's largest religious organizations has decided to make reforming the juvenile justice system one of its top priorities for next year.

    One of Tampa Bay's largest religious organizations, Faith & Action for Strength Together (FAST), voted Monday night to make reforming the juvenile justice system one of its top priorities for next year. FAST believes civil citations could help Pinellas County?€™s teen car theft epidemic by keeping children out of the juvenile justice system for minor offenses. [ZACHARY T. SAMPSON  |  Times]
  5. U.S. general lays out Niger attack details; questions remain (w/video)


    WASHINGTON — The U.S. Special Forces unit ambushed by Islamic militants in Niger didn't call for help until an hour into their first contact with the enemy, the top U.S. general said Monday, as he tried to clear up some of the murky details of the assault that killed four American troops and has triggered a nasty …

    Gen. Joseph Dunford said much is still unclear about the ambush.