Tuesday, November 20, 2018
Education

Romano: Florida’s schools engaged in double standard of epic proportions

Your religious views matter, and don’t let anyone ever tell you differently.

This goes for evangelicals and agnostics, and everyone in between. A lawyer might argue it’s a First Amendment right, but it’s also a courtesy we should all embrace.

Even, or especially, when we don’t agree.

I mention this because of a story I read over the weekend. The Orlando Sentinel pointed out that many of the state’s private schools are using textbooks from a handful of Christian publishing companies that have, shall we say, alternative viewpoints of accepted scientific and historical data.

For instance, some of the books suggest Noah brought baby dinosaurs aboard his ark during the biblical flood. An eighth-grade textbook suggested the Protestant Reformation flourished in North America because God provided this land to keep Catholics from overrunning the Americas.

A workbook seemingly downplayed slavery by suggesting a black slave who believed in Christ had more freedom than "a free person who did not know the Savior.’’

Some people will read that and scoff. For others, it aligns perfectly with spiritual beliefs.

That’s not the point.

We already know people of faith and science sometimes view the world through different lenses. When you think about it, we should be proud that so many of us coexist despite those disparate views.

The more important point is this:

The state’s voucher program is funneling more than $1 billion annually to private schools, and the Florida Department of Education does not regulate, or even monitor, what’s being taught.

I’m not suggesting private schools shouldn’t be allowed to teach what they want. And I’m not suggesting parents shouldn’t be allowed to enroll their children in their schools of choice.

What am I suggesting is Florida is engaging in a double standard of epic proportions.

Our traditional public schools are micromanaged by the Legislature to an absurd degree, while private schools take advantage of taxpayer largesse with virtually no accountability.

This isn’t just about textbooks. Lawmakers are fanatical about public school children being forced to take a series of standardized tests, no matter what their parents have to say on the topic. And those tests have become so closely tied to school funding and teacher evaluations that curriculum is heavily monitored and narrowly focused toward the materials on the test.

Meanwhile, private school students don’t have to take those tests.

And private school textbooks do not have to be approved.

And private school teachers do not have to be certified.

And yet those private schools still get voucher money.

This isn’t about whether you believe in Adam and Eve or the Origin of Species. It isn’t even about whether the Legislature is circumventing the state Constitution with its voucher program.

The bigger picture is that the state has created an uneven playing field. It is pushing private and charter schools as being more innovative and parent-friendly, while at the same time handcuffing traditional public schools with more and more onerous regulations.

Surely, there is something in those religious textbooks that covers hypocrisy.

 

Comments
Pasco residents call for changes to school district policies on transgender students, club participation

Pasco residents call for changes to school district policies on transgender students, club participation

The conservative Liberty Counsel, based in Orlando, has helped families keep the heat on the district.
Updated: 10 minutes ago
Florida education news: College recruiting, dress code, leadership and more

Florida education news: College recruiting, dress code, leadership and more

A roundup of stories from around the state.
Updated: 8 hours ago
First-time voters prepared to make choices

First-time voters prepared to make choices

River Ridge High School students Brielle Brodd, Katelyn Kirves and Claire Kraft, all recent 18th birthday celebrants, voted for the first time in the November 6 election.
Published: 11/20/18
FAMU’S Fall President’s Tour delivers a distinct message to high schoolers

FAMU’S Fall President’s Tour delivers a distinct message to high schoolers

The Tallahassee school wants to add to the 400 Hillsborough County students who enrolled in 2018.
Updated: 9 hours ago
Florida education news: Employee pay, charter schools, safety checks and more

Florida education news: Employee pay, charter schools, safety checks and more

A roundup of stories from around the state.
Published: 11/19/18
Pinellas School Board approves raises for administrators, support staff

Pinellas School Board approves raises for administrators, support staff

Administrators and support staff in Pinellas County schools will get a boost in salary and benefits just in time for the holidays, following a recent, unanimous vote by the School Board.Months of negotiations between the district and two employe...
Published: 11/19/18

School notes for Nov. 23

Pasco schools calendar, events and briefs
Published: 11/19/18
Hillsborough Sheriff: Man dead after crashing into deputy, fleeing, then crashing again

Hillsborough Sheriff: Man dead after crashing into deputy, fleeing, then crashing again

Deputies said he hit a sheriff's office cruiser, then sped away before losing control and crashing again. He died on the scene.
Published: 11/17/18
Man injured in Pasco County paramotor crash

Man injured in Pasco County paramotor crash

An man was hospitalized Saturday after crashing a paramotor in rural San Antonio, Pasco County Fire Rescue officials said.The crash happened about 11:30 a.m. in the 26500 block of Fields Farm Lane, west of Bellamy Brothers Boulevard and north of Stat...
Published: 11/17/18
Sheriff: Pasco teacher filmed student undressing, arrested on voyeurism charge

Sheriff: Pasco teacher filmed student undressing, arrested on voyeurism charge

Deputies said Fivay High School teacher Thomas Kovack admitted to recording a 17-year-old student as she changed her shirt.
Published: 11/17/18