Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Chug to this: Lowering drinking age won't stop abuse

The scenario would seem to defy logic.

If the drinking age were lowered from 21 to 18, an initiative currently endorsed by the heads of about 100 colleges and universities nationwide, picture this:

Across the country, freshmen will suddenly shun an extra cup of suds from the frat house keg and refuse one more dip into the Everclear punch. On quarter beer night, they will return to their dorms with change still jingling in their pockets.

"Given this new rule, my school has entrusted me with great responsibility despite my tender age," young students will say, strains of their college fight songs rising in the background. "Therefore, I reject binge drinking, on principle and in practice!"

Or, not.

Among the ostensible reasons for what's being called the Amethyst Initiative — joined by schools from Duke to our own Eckerd College — is to try to curb a culture of dangerous binge drinking "often conducted off-campus."

For the record, binge drinking is bad and should be curbed.

But is letting kids drink at a younger age really how we accomplish this?

"Twenty-one is not working," the initiative's Web site declares, and given that underage imbibing has become something of a college tradition, there is some truth to that.

But even people who went to school back when the magic number was 18 can tell you stories of partying gone out of control, of holding back a roomie's hair at night's end.

Binge drinking is not something newly discovered by the current crop.

Another reason cited by those who support the lowered age: Students use fake IDs and therefore "make ethical compromises that erode respect for the law."

This one makes my head hurt.

We should make illegal acts legal so no one risks compromising themselves by breaking the law?

Wouldn't logic have us believe that at least some portion of the population avoids violating a law simply because the law exists? We don't necessarily honor that "no right on red" traffic sign because we endorse its message. We do it because we're not allowed, and because we might get caught.

And wouldn't you think the law, however imperfect, keeps bartenders and store owners on notice and makes it at least somewhat harder to accomplish the act?

Predictably, MADD does not love the idea of younger legal drinkers. Neither the University of Florida nor the University of Miami have joined the effort.

"We haven't signed, and we haven't seen any evidence to suggest we should," University of South Florida spokesman Michael Hoad told me this week.

Now, you would hate to think, as critics have suggested, that some school officials who support this push simply don't want the responsibility of policing underage drinking themselves, that it's just one more in loco parentis headache.

And speaking of parents, the real ones bear responsibility.

Lessons in moderation, respect and appropriateness when it comes to alcohol start at home.

The answer is not in relaxing restrictions.

It lies somewhere between education and enforcement, not in abdicating responsibility. Because where's the logic in that?

Chug to this: Lowering drinking age won't stop abuse 08/22/08 [Last modified: Monday, August 25, 2008 11:32am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Review: Bruno Mars' charisma glitters like gold at Tampa's Amalie Arena


    Nothing in this world should be as easy as Bruno Mars makes it look. Not singing, not dancing, and certainly not playfully seducing more than 17,500 starry-eyed Tampa fans with one of pop music’s best bands at your back.

    Bruno Mars performed at Tampa's Amalie Arena on Oct. 19, 2017.
  2. Mikhail Sergachev scores twice as Lightning shuts out Blue Jackets (w/ video)

    Lightning Strikes

    COLUMBUS, Ohio — Mikhail Sergachev said he blacked out for a few seconds after his first NHL goal Thursday night, a rocket slap shot from the point.

    Mikhail Sergachev, front, looks like he’s very in the moment with teammate Dan Girardi after scoring his first NHL goal, though he says he blacked out for a bit. He scores again in the second.
  3. Dodgers rout Cubs 11-1 to win pennant, head to World Series for first time since '88


    CHICAGO — Enrique Hernandez put a Hollywood ending on an LA story three decades in the making.

    The Dodgers celebrate their Game 5 victory Thursday night over the Cubs at Wrigley Field, putting Los Angeles in the World Series for the first time since 1988.
  4. Another suspicious death in Tampa's Seminole Heights


    TAMPA — Police were investigating what they were calling a suspicious death in southeast Seminole Heights Thursday night, near the location of two fatal shootings last week.

    Interim Tampa police Chief Brian Dugan addresses reporters about the latest suspicious death in southeast Seminole Heights Thursday night. [JONATHAN CAPRIEL | Times]
  5. Duke tops preseason coaches' basketball poll; Gators No. 7


    Duke has been tabbed basketball's preseason No. 1 for the second straight season in the coaches' poll, released Thursday.

    Florida point guard Chris Chiozza launches the shot of last season’s NCAA Tournament, a winning 3
against Wisconsin that put the Gators into the Elite Eight. Chiozza returns to lead a UF team that’s getting its share of preseason attention, including a No. 7 ranking in the coaches’ poll.