Tuesday, July 17, 2018
Education

Joining a national debate, Eckerd College takes big stand on campus free speech

ST. PETERSBURG — When the Wesleyan campus newspaper ran an op-ed critical of the Black Lives Matter movement, outraged students petitioned to slash the paper's funding.

When Duke University assigned a graphic novel featuring lesbian sex as summer reading, some freshmen objected, calling it "pornographic."

When a Yale professor's wife pushed back against the school's suggestion to avoid offensive Halloween costumes, she and her husband stepped down as housing leaders amid student outcry.

A debate is roiling college campuses across the country, pitting students concerned about inclusion and injustice against universities who are sympathetic but committed to free expression.

Free speech advocates paint a picture of coddled millennials who grew up insulated from difficult ideas and now bristle at the slightest offense. On the other side are student activists, often advocating for marginalized students in a college landscape of increasing diversity, whose protests have made headlines.

Now comes Eckerd College, the laid-back liberal arts school on Boca Ciega Bay, which has adopted a statement designed to head off the free speech fights that have erupted elsewhere.

"Without a vibrant commitment to free and open inquiry, a college ceases to be a college," the document says, borrowing from a statement released in 2015 by the University of Chicago.

Hear something offensive? Debate it. Loathe an idea? Protest it. But don't expect the college to limit free expression, the Eckerd statement says.

The school, with an enrollment of fewer than 1,800, will circulate it to students in the coming weeks.

It is not a policy, and it doesn't have penalties. It draws a line at hate speech and harassment. But it makes clear that the college won't disinvite controversial speakers or obstruct protests, encouraging students to engage rather than flee from difficult discussions.

"College should challenge the set of beliefs you arrive with," said Eckerd's dean of faculty, Suzan Harrison. "That's part of the point of college, to expose you to new ideas, some of which will make you uncomfortable."

Two of the most contentious — maligned — terms in the free speech debate are "trigger warnings" and "safe spaces."

Safe spaces, broadly speaking, are places where students can gather with peers, such as an LGBT center or Hillel house. A trigger warning is a heads-up that something potentially distressing might arise, often for students who have experienced trauma.

Critics point to extreme examples, such as a situation Harrison described in which an Eckerd student visiting a circus-themed display in the library saw photographs of clowns. Horrified, the student told administrators they should have been warned.

More often, trigger warnings are a benign act of compassion. Last year's summer reading at Eckerd dealt with incest and sexual assault. Professors told students they could skip those topics on certain pages if needed.

Those concepts coexist with free speech, said dean of students James Annarelli.

Eckerd faculty members adopted the statement unanimously at their final meeting last year. The next step is to share it with students and start a discussion.

"A statement like this is really just a reaffirmation of the norms students have come to expect," said Claire Russell, Eckerd student government's vice president for academic affairs.

"I definitely support the needs of my fellow students, but I do also think that a lot of these topics can aid in better conversation and a deeper understanding," Russell said. "When those topics are shut down or completely eliminated from the classroom, then students don't get to have those conversations."

Jack Layden, student body president, said the statement is just "preaching to the choir."

Bombarded with anti-bullying messages since they were kids, today's students have been conditioned to report hostility, said Tom Miller, associate professor at the University of South Florida College of Education.

Finding that offensive speech on campus is protected can be jarring, he said, but learning to respond will help students in the future dealing with a racist supervisor or antagonistic neighbor.

Harrison said some students believe racism and sexism are relics, no longer a threat.

"I don't want us to perpetuate those beliefs because then we send them out into the world ill-equipped to deal with what they will encounter," she said. "Silencing ideas that are dangerous and negative doesn't make them go away — it often drives them underground."

Public institutions such as USF and the University of Florida have a baked-in commitment to the First Amendment, something USF makes clear when students take offense at a campus preacher or bloody posters set up by anti-abortion activists.

"There are students who want us to arrest them, repress them, tell them to stop," Miller said. "That is something we have to allow."

The school is working on setting up a bias response team, which will work with students who hear things that make them feel unwelcome, such as a racist epithet. It will not police speech.

"What we can say to a student who feels uncomfortable is that the statement is inconsistent with the values of the institution," he said.

The focus at UF is on creating a "culture of care," said dean of students Jen Day Shaw, an approach that balances free speech and the idea that "every Gator counts."

For example, the school facilitates visits from controversial speakers, but also helps protesters negotiate their demands and stay safe, she said.

Private schools have more leeway to adopt speech policies. The University of Tampa sees no need.

"We're in a real sweet spot where we feel like we really value rigorous intellectual inquiry and free speech, and we also foster an environment that allows all our students and faculty to feel safe and supported," said dean of students Stephanie Russell Krebs.

Eckerd leaders described a similar environment at their school, but felt the statement was a way to reaffirm that commitment in a time of upheaval.

Last year, protests over racist incidents at the University of Missouri saw clashes between students advocating for the removal of the university system's president and student journalists documenting the upheaval.

And tensions remain high at the University of Chicago, where a Committee on Free Expression drafted the statement that more than a dozen schools — including Eckerd — have adopted.

"That was in the real early stages of what has become an avalanche," said Geoffrey R. Stone, a professor of law who chaired the Chicago committee. He credited this generation of students for being vocal.

"They actually have the courage to say, 'This is upsetting,' " he said. "It's great that they're speaking out. I don't think what they should be doing is calling for censorship."

President Barack Obama joined the debate last year, urging students to argue issues and lamenting the "coddled" ones who would ban campus speakers with whom they disagree.

"That's not the way we learn either," he said.

Protesters seem to believe it is their right not to have a speaker come to campus, said Azhar Majeed, director of policy reform at the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, who is worried by calls for censorship.

"That is a very broad and dangerous notion that seems to be picking up steam on college campuses," he said.

To students skeptical of the Chicago statement, who feel it doesn't respect the legitimate concerns of students, Stone has a warning.

"Once you open the door to suppression of ideas, you don't get to control whose ideas get suppressed," he said. "Once you create the precedent that says, okay, the university is allowed to do that, your ideas are going to get suppressed."

Contact Claire McNeill at [email protected] or (727) 893-8321.

     
   
Comments
Fired Hernando school superintendent Lori Romano finds a job in the county next door — Pasco

Fired Hernando school superintendent Lori Romano finds a job in the county next door — Pasco

Lori Romano, fired from the Hernando County superintendent post for "ineffective leadership" a month ago, has snagged a job in the neighboring Pasco County school district.She won’t be nearly as high up the administrative ladder in her new role.Subje...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Artist, advocate, Marine: New Pasco school security director compelled to serve

Artist, advocate, Marine: New Pasco school security director compelled to serve

LAND O’ LAKES — Chris Stowe has a storied past as an explosives technician in the U.S. Marine Corps.The retired master gunnery sergeant has mementos of his service — a field knife mounted to the lid of an explosives box, for instance — hanging promin...
Published: 07/17/18
Members new and old appointed to Pasco-Hernando State College boards

Members new and old appointed to Pasco-Hernando State College boards

Three trustees for Pasco-Hernando State College have been reappointed to their posts by Gov. Rick Scott, and a new member joined the college’s Foundation Board of Directors.The reappointments to the Board of Trustees are Alvaro Hernandez, Lee Maggard...
Published: 07/17/18
Hillsborough training school resource officers during active shooter exercise

Hillsborough training school resource officers during active shooter exercise

DOVER — With the start of classes nearly three weeks away, Hillsborough County school resource officers are receiving extensive active shooter training Tuesday morning to prepare them in the event of another school tragedy.Members of the Hillsborough...
Published: 07/17/18
Teacher on a plane talked about her low-income students. Passengers overheard and gave her more than $500 in cash.

Teacher on a plane talked about her low-income students. Passengers overheard and gave her more than $500 in cash.

Chicago schoolteacher Kimberly Bermudez has always been the chatty type.So when she was on a Southwest Airlines flight to Florida to visit her parents last week, and her seatmate asked her what she did for a living, she told him about her first-grade...
Published: 07/17/18
In District 6, School Board candidates offer ideas on teacher pay, achievement gap and more

In District 6, School Board candidates offer ideas on teacher pay, achievement gap and more

In Pinellas County’s only School Board race without an incumbent, three longtime Pinellas residents — a retired City Council member and coach, a human resources manager and a special education teacher — will duke it out for the District 6 seat. All t...
Published: 07/17/18

New student address verification rules on tap for Pasco schools

Pasco County parents have demanded for more than two years that their school district make sure students are not lying about their addresses. They’ve done so in hopes it might alleviate the need to change attendance zones at crowded schools.They migh...
Published: 07/17/18
Hillsborough headed for a new mark: 25,000 charter school students

Hillsborough headed for a new mark: 25,000 charter school students

TAMPA — Three more charter schools will join the Hillsborough County system this year, pushing the number of students in these tax-funded, but privately operated institutions to well over 10 percent of the enrollment.District officials predict that 2...
Published: 07/13/18
District 3 candidates see challenges and potential for Pinellas schools

District 3 candidates see challenges and potential for Pinellas schools

A three-term incumbent, an educational specialist with a doctorate in school counseling and a teacher with 33 years of classroom experience are vying for the countywide District 3 seat on the Pinellas County School Board.All three have clear ideas on...
Published: 07/12/18

Pasco moms ask school district for more anti-discrimination efforts and training

Sheena Lofton-Huggins saw her son struggle this past year dealing with racism and prejudice at Mitchell High School. He didn’t have all the support he needed, Lofton-Huggins said, or the strategies to stand firm. When she sought to send her son to Co...
Published: 07/11/18