Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

U.S. Ethics Bowl draws teams from Eckerd College, USF St. Pete, UCF

Facing, from left, Tony Leyh, 20, Ryan Jarrett, 20, Baalika Patel, 19, and Rebecca Hutchinson, 20, listen to Sarah Seniuk, 19, right, develop a case to ban or not ban a caffeinated alcoholic beverage in Scotland.


Facing, from left, Tony Leyh, 20, Ryan Jarrett, 20, Baalika Patel, 19, and Rebecca Hutchinson, 20, listen to Sarah Seniuk, 19, right, develop a case to ban or not ban a caffeinated alcoholic beverage in Scotland.

ST. PETERSBURG — Is bullfighting ethical? Is computer-generated child pornography? What about illegal immigration?

Think about it. Sometimes, the answers might not be clear-cut.

If you're not sure, ask members of the Eckerd College Ethics Bowl team. These were some of the cases that won them the Southeast competition last fall for the seventh year in a row.

In March, the group of seven students will head to Cincinnati for the national competition.

"The challenge of the debater is to ultimately decide what is going to be the best outcome for the general public," said co-captain Kate Hamilton, 20. "It's a gut sense of justice. You can feel what's ethical and what's wrong."

Teams from the University of Central Florida and the University of South Florida St. Petersburg also advanced to the nationals, finishing second and third, respectively. The 2010 Southeast Regional Ethics Bowl was held Nov. 13 and featured 24 teams from colleges and universities across the Southeast.

At Eckerd, the Ethics Bowl is an extracurricular activity not guided by a class or program. Students meet weekly to research arguments for cases, which are provided ahead of time and often involve current events.

They debate in head-to-head rounds at tournament-style competitions. Prompted with a question from a case, each team presents its answer and offers rebuttals.

"The more research I do, the more I look into it," said Elizabeth Renihan, 21, the team's other captain. "You find that things are never black and white. Things are never clear."

The key, the captains said, is to consider every perspective. Looking at all the players and stakes, they have found themselves pondering unusual stances — like whether animal conservationists' actions against Japanese whalers actually endanger the very whales they try to protect.

"One of the great things about Ethics Bowl is so much of the debate in this country has become very polarized: 'I'm right. You're wrong,' " Renihan said.

"This is very, very civil. It's great to have these very spirited debates."

Stephanie Wang can be reached at or (813) 661-2443.

The bowl

What: Seventeenth Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl

When: March 3

Where: Cincinnati

The cases: Teams will be questioned on one of 15 cases posted online in advance. They will not know which one beforehand. Some of the cases focus on current issues like the "Don't ask, don't tell" policy on gays in the military, the Arizona law that allows police to stop people if they suspect they are in the country illegally, and a Colorado bill passed last year that ties tenure to teacher effectiveness.

Read the full cases at

Noodle on this

Think about these three cases, adapted from the regional Ethics Bowl competition and the arguments prepared by the Eckerd College team.

Does a ban on computer-generated child pornography violate your right to privacy?

Eckerd's team said: Virtual child pornography should stay banned under federal law. Likening your right to privacy to your freedom of speech, obscene materials are not protected by the First Amendment. Based on today's societal norms — one of the ways we define "obscene" — child pornography, computer-generated or not, is obscene and provides no ethical good.

Should Spanish bullfighting be legally protected against animal cruelty laws because of its history in the country's culture?

Eckerd's team said: Bullfighting has become a symbol of Spain and a national tradition, but the widely recognized symbol of Spain does not reflect the popularity of the practice among Spaniards themselves. A Gallup poll in 2006 reported that 72 percent of Spaniards have no interest in bullfighting. Culture changes over time: 82 percent of surveyed Spaniards between ages 18 and 25 said they had no interest in bullfighting. Animal rights should also be acknowledged as a cultural belief.

Should all children born in the United States be granted citizenship regardless of their parents' nationalities?

Eckerd's team said: There is no way to consider all sides — children of illegal immigrants, illegal immigrants as parents, foreign nationals who want to legally immigrate, American society in general — and find a solution without significantly disadvantaging one party. A test case should be brought to the U.S. Supreme Court to re-examine the 14th Amendment and find an appropriate interpretation for today's society.

U.S. Ethics Bowl draws teams from Eckerd College, USF St. Pete, UCF 02/05/11 [Last modified: Saturday, February 5, 2011 3:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Shooting sends man to hospital in St. Pete


    ST. PETERSBURG — Police were investigating a shooting that occurred around 4:40 p.m. on Tuesday and sent a man to the hospital.

  2. Police: Man tries to lure child with puppy in Polk County


    Times staff

    HAINES CITY — A man was arrested Sunday after he tried to entice a young girl into his camper to view a puppy, according to police.

    Dale Collins, 63, faces a charge of luring or enticing a child under the age of 12. [Photo courtesy of the Polk County Sheriff's Office]
  3. Editorial: Coming together to reduce car thefts


    The simple, knee-jerk response to the juvenile car theft epidemic in Pinellas County would be to crack down on offenders with an increased police presence and stiffer sentences. Thankfully, local community leaders did not stop there. As detailed in a recent Tampa Bay Times follow-up to its 
As detailed in a recent Tampa Bay Times follow-up to its "Hot Wheels" investigation into youth car thefts, a variety of ideas from multiple directions increases the odds of actually solving the cause and not just treating the symptoms.

  4. Editorial: Floridians' health care now at risk in Washington


    The health care for millions of Floridians is now at risk. The U.S. Senate's dramatic vote Tuesday to begin debate on repealing and replacing the Affordable Care Act with no idea what will happen is a dangerous gamble with American lives and the national economy. Barring an unexpected bipartisan compromise, a handful of …

    Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., dramatically returned to the Senate for the first time since his brain cancer was diagnosed and cast the key vote that enabled Vice President Mike Pence to break the 50-50 tie and allow the health care debate to proceed.
  5. Former Marine from Florida dies fighting for Kurdish militia

    ORLANDO — A former Marine who secretly traveled to Syria earlier this year to battle the Islamic State was killed while fighting for a Kurdish militia, his father said Tuesday.

    David Taylor, with his father David Taylor Sr., was killed earlier this month in Syria while fighting for a Kurdish militia.