Tuesday, April 24, 2018
Education

Florida Board of Education votes 4-3 to pad school grades

Florida school grades are due by late July, but their validity will be in serious doubt this year.

A divided state Board of Education voted Tuesday to prevent the grades from dropping more than one letter at any school, marking the second straight year the board padded grades.

The change brought sharp criticism from some of the very people who helped create the state's accountability system a decade and a half ago. Many publicly questioned whether the grades at the center of that system still had any meaning.

Of the 262 schools slated to earn an F this year, just 108 will get that grade now, board member Sally Bradshaw said.

In a 4-3 vote, the board adopted Education Commissioner Tony Bennett's recommendation to maintain a "safety net" for schools as the state imposes higher academic standards within the next few years. Bennett proposed the change after several superintendents complained that low grades projected this year at many schools would not accurately reflect student performance.

But debate among board members raised significant questions about whether the A-F grading model, which has been copied in several states, has become invalid in its 14 years.

"We've overcomplicated the model," said veteran board member Kathleen Shanahan, once the chief of staff for former Gov. Jeb Bush, who is widely considered the author of Florida's school grading system. "I am struggling with the integrity of the accountability system . . . and the reliability of the grades."

Said Bradshaw: "I don't understand when it became acceptable to disguise and manipulate the truth simply because the truth is uncomfortable."

Even board Chairman Gary Chartrand, who voted to pad the grades, harbored doubts. "I don't think the truth is being revealed in the current grading system," he said, adding that he trusted Bennett to fix the problem.

In the early years, school grades were controversial but simple, giving the public an easy gauge of school success.

The grades quickly became prominent in school vernacular. School board members and elected superintendents touted them in campaigns. Residents used them when buying and selling homes. Mayors gave out awards based on school grades.

Principals at highly rated schools celebrated their successes, while those at low performers looked for ways to improve. In both cases, the leaders looked less at the actual grades than the data behind them, which revealed where instruction needed attention.

In time, the system changed to reflect nuances in the results. Bennett said it had become "overly nuanced" in the past 30 months, with the state inserting new calculations "to account for specific situations."

Concerns over such manipulations arose in 2012, when the state board lowered the passing score for the FCAT writing exam to avoid a dip in grades. Board members said the changes were temporary, aimed at helping schools adjust to new standards.

This year, as superintendents continued to warn that grades would drop because of machinations with the formula, board members called for a review. That led to Bennett's "safety net" on school grades and the debate over whether it harmed the system's validity.

Bradshaw argued the model had grown heavy with politics, straying from its mission of monitoring whether students are doing well on the FCAT.

She argued the state would not condone padding students' report card grades and suggested that doing so for schools did more to bolster the self-esteem of adults than to make schools better.

"How could we in good conscience let an F school become a C or a D?" she asked, adding the change could prevent assistance from getting to schools that need it. "The truth will lead to better schools in the long run."

Bennett, who implemented a similar program while Indiana's education chief, stressed that he firmly supported providing adequate information to parents and others who want to know how schools are performing.

"I think we will have to make sure that everyone understands true school performance," he said. "The data will speak for itself."

He rejected the idea of lowering the bar now, saying students and teachers must be prepared for the more rigorous Common Core State Standards and their associated tests. And he swatted aside Shanahan's suggestion that the state not issue grades for a year while it sorts things out.

"I believe as a purist on accountability that taking a break from accountability is very simply bad policy," he said. "It sends the wrong message."

State law also requires school grades every year.

Bennett said he considered the safety net a reasonable compromise that would cushion the state's transition to its next accountability system. He said he would not recommend it continue beyond that point.

Staff writer Cara Fitzpatrick contributed to this report.

Comments
Hillsborough: No way we can afford teacher raises this year

Hillsborough: No way we can afford teacher raises this year

TAMPA — The Hillsborough County School District is in bad financial shape and its reputation for sound management is perhaps undeserved, the district’s own fiscal team testified Monday in a hearing concerning teacher salaries.The district "made finan...
Updated: 8 hours ago

School news for April 27

School Calendar• May 17-20: High school graduations• May 25: Last day of school for studentsBriefs• School Safety Town Hall Meetings will be held from 6 to 8 p.m. May 2 at River Ridge Middle/High, 11646 Town Center Road, New Port Richey and 6 to 8 p....
Published: 04/23/18
A Florida school shooting suspect charged with terrorism says ‘sorry’ to injured student

A Florida school shooting suspect charged with terrorism says ‘sorry’ to injured student

The young man in a white jail jumpsuit, handcuffed and shackled, looked past the throng of reporters pointing microphones toward his face, barely opening his mouth as he answered questions."I shot through the door," he said, looking at a female repor...
Published: 04/21/18
After months, no action on Hillsborough’s substitute teacher problem

After months, no action on Hillsborough’s substitute teacher problem

TAMPA — Confronted in late 2017 with reports of misconduct by substitute teachers hired through a contractor, Hillsborough County school superintendent Jeff Eakins said he would ask tough questions and demand answers. He had his lawyer, Jeff Gibson, ...
Published: 04/21/18
Tampa Bay students voice opinions on gun laws during school walkouts

Tampa Bay students voice opinions on gun laws during school walkouts

Nicole Leary and Taylor Redington stood outside St. Petersburg High School on Friday morning with parents and protesters who had gathered with bullhorns and signs. In a few minutes they would lead about 70 students on a walk to City Hall, joining oth...
Published: 04/20/18
Official: Shotgun in guitar case was used in school shooting

Official: Shotgun in guitar case was used in school shooting

FORT LAUDERDALE — A gunman who carried a shotgun in a guitar case opened fire Friday in a Florida high school, wounding one student before he was arrested on a day planned for a national classroom walkout to protest gun violence, authorities said. It...
Published: 04/20/18
Eakins: New ‘achievement zone’ would lift struggling schools

Eakins: New ‘achievement zone’ would lift struggling schools

TAMPA — Hillsborough County school superintendent Jeff Eakins is preparing to reorganize his cabinet — for the third time since 2015 — in an effort to coordinate programs at the district’s highest-needs schools.In an interview this week, Eakins descr...
Published: 04/20/18
Today: Area high school students to join national walkout in memory of Columbine

Today: Area high school students to join national walkout in memory of Columbine

High school students from both sides of Tampa Bay will commemorate the anniversary of the Columbine High School shootings on Friday, although in very different ways. In St. Petersburg, students from several schools will gather at noon at City Hall f...
Published: 04/20/18
Hooper: A tribute to my Godby High School instructors

Hooper: A tribute to my Godby High School instructors

Every time I see an algebraic formula, Mrs. Watson, Mrs. Landreth and Mrs. McBee flash through my mind.If you say history, I say Mr. Groot and Mrs. Melton. If you say civics, I say Mrs. Jennings and Mrs. Hunt.I type using the "home keys" because Mrs....
Published: 04/19/18
Updated: 04/21/18
Hillsborough targets bilingual teachers’ aides in latest school cuts

Hillsborough targets bilingual teachers’ aides in latest school cuts

TAMPA — The Hillsborough County School District, with a large and growing population of children from foreign cultures, is reducing the ranks of teachers’ aides who help them master the English language.Next year’s workforce will have about 164 fewer...
Published: 04/19/18