Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida school districts rush to revamp teacher evaluation

TAMPA — From poor to great in four months.

That's the assignment facing Florida school districts under the game-changing education bill signed into law last month by Gov. Rick Scott. By August, all 67 districts will need a teacher evaluation system that discerns between strong educators and weak ones.

Experts say it's a tall order for a system that last year rated 99 percent of all teachers as satisfactory or better.

"We have a system where nobody wants to give teachers low scores, everybody has high scores," said education researcher Robert Marzano, who designed the evaluation system being offered to districts by the Florida Department of Education. "I don't think it's going to be easy to change that culture quickly."

In an interview Friday during the National Association of Elementary School Principals convention in Tampa, Marzano said he supports the broad goals of Senate Bill 736, which ends automatic pay raises based on seniority, puts new teachers on one-year contracts and phases in a merit-based salary schedule.

But he said it would be a mistake to quickly fire those with low evaluation scores, especially if they're new to the profession.

"Let's say I'm a beginning teacher, I have a lot of heart, you know I'm going to be good someday," Marzano said. "I'm not (great) now, but you don't want to give me 'unsatisfactories.' "

Under SB 736, districts will be barred from offering a new contract to teachers who receive two straight "unsatisfactory" ratings, two within a three-year period, or three straight years of "needs improvement." The other possible categories are "effective" and "highly effective."

Districts must publicly announce the numbers of teachers in each category annually beginning in 2012 and report individual teacher scores to the Department of Education.

Frederick Hess, resident scholar at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, said it's a recipe for disaster. At Education Week magazine online (, he predicted that the law will bring a "train wreck" of errors and controversy.

He told the St. Petersburg Times that SB 736 is based on the "incredibly sensible idea" of determining which teachers are doing the best work and rewarding them accordingly.

"But we risk taking this idea and turning it into a rigid state statute that is going to breed frustration and lead to news stories that can point out lots of places where this tight formula didn't yield the desired effect," Hess said.

He worries about the law's requirement to base 50 percent of teachers' evaluations on student test scores, using a "value-added" statistical formula that has been found to carry high error rates. And he predicts that it will be hard to find enough time and money to quickly train people in a new teacher observation model.

"What I worry about is we're trying to build teacher evaluation and pay systems here that don't leave enough room for human judgment and for responsible school and district leaders to make big decisions for which they'll be held accountable," Hess added.

Officials with the state Department of Education didn't respond Friday to specific questions about the pace of Florida's reforms. But in recent interviews they have said districts will receive plenty of opportunities to learn the new system.

"It's a much more precise way to look at teacher practice and student learning improvement," said Kathy Hebda, deputy chancellor for educator quality.

The state has hired Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Educational Consulting Services and Learning Sciences International to run a dozen training academies and offer Internet-based seminars around the state for districts, using Marzano's teacher evaluation system as a model, she said.

The size of that contract has not been finalized but will be paid for using part of Florida's $700 million Race to the Top federal stimulus grant, officials said.

Some districts, including Hillsborough and Miami-Dade, have opted to use a state-approved system of their own. Hillsborough spent much of last summer and fall training its principals and peer evaluators, using money from a $100 million grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

It wasn't easy work. They watched summer school classes and evaluated them. But at first, many of their ratings — which teachers were "exemplary" and which ones needed improvement — disagreed.

"It is labor intensive, but there really isn't anything more important that a principal does," Hebda said, describing their role in helping teachers to improve. "We're going to make sure it's saturated around the state."

Marzano, who's not involved in that training, said he supports Florida's effort to push rapid changes into districts that have never made a real effort on teacher evaluation.

But he worries that his work will be used to quickly push low-performing teachers out the door, rather than being used as a tool to help them do a better job.

"We have to change the culture to one where it's okay to get low scores, and that doesn't mean you're doing a bad job," Marzano said. "It means you need improvement."

Tom Marshall can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 226-3400.

Florida school districts rush to revamp teacher evaluation 04/08/11 [Last modified: Friday, April 8, 2011 10:33pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Datz to open in St. Petersburg, join the James Museum of Western and Wildlife Art

    Food & Dining

    Now Datz news.

    Get it? Tuesday, Datz, the longtime line-out-the-door, oft-Instagrammed and -Yelped Tampa stalwart known for shock-and-awe sandwiches and oh-so-much bacon, announced it is coming to St. Petersburg.

    Lunch guest eat at Datz Deli at 2616 South MacDill Ave. in Tampa. Times files.
  2. Republican leader McConnell pulls the plug on latest Obamacare repeal effort

    WASHINGTON --- Sen. Mitch McConnell on Tuesday officially pulled the plug on the latest plan to repeal the health care law, telling senators they will not vote on the measure and effectively admitting defeat in the last-gasp drive to fulfill a core promise of President Donald Trump and Republican lawmakers.

    Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Ky. listens during a news conference on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, Feb. 7, 2017, after the Senate confirmed Betsy DeVos as education secretary. DeVos was approved by the narrowest of margins, with Vice President Mike Pence breaking a 50-50 tie in a historic vote. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite) DCSA119
  3. Lightning's Brayden Point could be perfect fit alongside Steven Stamkos, Nikita Kucherov

    Lightning Strikes

    SUNRISE — Brayden Point ended last season as the Lightning's No. 1 center, thrust into the role as a rookie due to injuries.

    Lightning center Brayden Point (21) advances the puck through the neutral zone during Friday's preseason game against the Nashville Predators. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Times]
  4. For starters: Rays at Yankees, with Blake Snell starting, Wilson Ramos cashing in


    The Rays open their final road series of the season tonight at Yankee Stadium, which is also where they played their first of the season.

    LHP Blake Snell will be on the mound for the Rays, looking to continue his successful late-season run, in which he is 4-0, 2,57 over his last eight starts.

    Tonight marks Wilson Ramos' 55th start of the season.
  5. Cannon Fodder podcast: Considering Gerald McCoy's comments


    Greg Auman talks about Gerald McCoy's comments — both about fan criticism online and Donald Trump — in the latest episode of our Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast.

    Gerald McCoy, front, said Monday that he would love to have a conversation with any of the fans who take to social media to criticize him and his Bucs teammates. [LOREN ELLIOTT | Times]