Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Hernando Teacher of Year illustrates flaws in evaluation system

When we came upon the true Hernando County Teacher of the Year, we were told, we would know it.

We would experience the "wow" factor. One great teacher would clearly emerge from a field of very good ones.

Sure enough, as soon as Bethann Brooks came before the four of us on the selection committee, the Teacher of the Year contest didn't seem like a contest at all.

Brooks, 48, is a former full-time nurse who still works part time at her old job so she can bring up-to-date information to her new one — nursing instructor at Central High School.

Her list of volunteer activities at the school filled up a full page of her application. According to the recommendations we read, her bosses think she's a great teacher. So do all of the other Central teachers I've talked to since we picked Brooks in January.

So, it seems, the teachers unions have found the ideal poster person to illustrate the craziness of the state's new teacher evaluation system.

Brooks ended up with a merely "effective" evaluation when she clearly deserved to be rated "highly effective." Actually, she is the kind of teacher for whom an entire new category should be created, something along the lines of "super-duper."

In case you haven't kept up with this story, the new evaluations are partly based on a "value added" model, which, as the name implies, will eventually factor into teacher pay.

In Hernando, about half of teacher evaluations are based on test results. And some of you are probably thinking the following about the suit that Brooks and six other Florida teachers — and their state and national unions — filed against the state Board of Education last week: It's just another protest against teaching to tests, another attempt to duck accountability.

That's not it at all.

Teachers just want to be judged on the results of tests that cover subjects they teach, taken by students who have spent time in their classrooms.

As Lynne Webb, president of the teachers union in Pasco County put it: "They aren't opposed to merit pay; they just want the pay to be based on their own merit."

Reasonable enough, right?

But as it is now, tests are available in only a few subjects. Which is how Brooks, who teaches mostly juniors and seniors, came to be judged on the schoolwide reading scores of freshmen and sophomores.

This whole system was rushed into place two years ago by lawmakers eager to show that they could get tough with teachers.

It wasn't ready then. And considering the number of subjects that schools cover, it probably won't be ready before the 2014-15 school year, when the evaluations start factoring into pay.

Gov. Rick Scott needs to do something about this before then — at the very least lobby the Legislature to change the law during next year's session.

He's been trying to show that he's a friend of teachers recently. What better way than standing up for their right to be judged on their own work?

Hernando Teacher of Year illustrates flaws in evaluation system 04/22/13 [Last modified: Tuesday, April 23, 2013 6:25pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. DOT shows alternatives to former Tampa Bay Express toll lanes


    TAMPA — State transportation officials are evaluating at least a half-dozen alternatives to the controversial Tampa Bay interstate plan that they will workshop with the community for the next 18 months.

    Florida Department of Transportation consultant Brad Flom explains potential alternatives to adding toll lanes to Interstate 275 during a meeting Wednesday at DOT's Tampa office. Flom presented seven diagrams, all of which swapped toll lanes for transit, such as light rail or express bus, in the I-275 corridor from downtown Tampa to Bearss Ave. [CAITLIN JOHNSTON | Times]
  2. Florida Orchestra and Tampa Bay Master Chorale scrap search for a joint conductor


    TAMPA — After a yearlong effort, the Master Chorale of Tampa Bay and the Florida Orchestra have abandoned their search for a conductor capable of leading both groups.

    Doreen Rao conducts a concert with the Buffalo Philharmonic Chorus and Orchestra in December 2010. Photo by Enid Bloch.
  3. New in theaters July 4 weekend: 'Despicable Me 3,' 'Baby Driver,' 'The House,' 'The Beguiled'


    OPENING Thursday:


    One of Hollywood's most successful animation franchises isn't about "me" anymore; it's about them.

    Gru (Steve Carell) squares off against Balthazar Bratt (Trey Parker) in Despicable Me 3.
  4. Uhurus cancel Baker protest


    Jesse Nevel's campaign had planned to stage an anti-Rick Baker protest outside the St. Petersburg Yacht Club this evening while Baker held a fundraiser inside.

    Now, that's not happening.

    Jesse Nevel's Uhuru-affiliated campaign postpones protest
  5. Claim: State pressured CFO, used secret recordings to shut down Universal Health Care


    ST. PETERSBURG — The founder of St. Petersburg's Universal Health Care alleges that Florida regulators conspired with the company's chief financial officer to drive the once high-flying Medicare insurer out of business.

    Federal agents raided the headquarters of Universal Health Care in 2013, ordering employees to leave the building. The insolvent St. Petersburg Medicare insurer was then in the process of being liquidated by state regulators.
[DIRK SHADD   |   Times file photo]