Wednesday, June 20, 2018
Education

Officials: Few Hillsborough teachers to be fired under Gates evaluation system

TAMPA — It was to be a carrot-and-stick approach: Great teachers would be rewarded for their greatness. And those who could not or would not measure up? They'd be asked to find another line of work.

Critics of the Gates-funded Empowering Effective Teachers often paint the massive overhaul of the teacher evaluation process as a union-busting scheme to get rid of experienced, well-paid teachers.

The reality, district and union officials say, is quite different.

As the Hillsborough County School District analyzes its second full year of written evaluations and waits for data that will complete the scores, it's likely very few teachers will be let go.

Officials anticipate so few terminations that they're not bothered that scores will not be complete until September or October of the new school year.

"We expect the number would be really small," said Jean Clements, president of the Hillsborough Classroom Teachers Association.

David Steele, the district's chief technology officer who heads the project, estimated that only 40 teachers worked this past year after earning the lowest rating of "unsatisfactory." That's minuscule in a district with more than 13,000 teachers.

Teachers can be recommended for termination after two consecutive unsatisfactory ratings. But such firings were unusual under the old system and should remain unusual now, Clements and Steele said.

One reason: Struggling teachers often quit or retire before they are shown the door.

Another: Under the new system, teachers get early warning about problems and have a chance to correct deficiencies.

"If they were in that (unsatisfactory) category, they had lots of observations," Clements said.

She said she had heard of imperiled teachers whose scores improved this year, possibly because of the new process.

"In the past, teachers did not receive that much feedback," she said. "This system gives them a better chance. It allows you to identify weaknesses very early in a career, and in a school year."

Whether the new system helps or demoralizes teachers — or both — is a topic of disagreement.

Clements has said consistently that Hillsborough was lucky to win a $100 million grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to launch Empowering Effective Teachers in 2010.

By joining in the Gates effort, the district was freed from some provisions of a 2011 state law that ordered districts to move from a seniority system to one based on performance.

Hillsborough is taking seven years to develop Empowering Effective Teachers. And unlike the state formula, which bases at least 50 percent of a teacher's rating on student performance, Hillsborough's system has three components.

Up to 30 points come from the principal, 30 from a peer evaluator, and 40 from student performance data.

Some teachers have struggled with the peer evaluation component. Lucy O'Regan, an East Bay High School English teacher entering her final year before retirement, said she can name a dozen who are leaving the field because of the new system.

"It has destroyed morale and made people watch their backs," said O'Regan, who has a Facebook page called "EET Concerns."

Complaints about the peer evaluation process were an issue for Clements this year when she ran for re-election as union president. Challenged by a teacher who had rejected his evaluator, Clements won with 54 percent of the vote after nearly a decade in office.

Since then, district and union officials have been polling teachers on issues that concern them, though critics such as O'Regan say the polling is not extensive enough.

One such issue is the notice given before informal "drop-in" evaluations from peers. The union did not want these visits to be a complete surprise, so the district agreed to give notice, typically a window of several days.

Some teachers felt rattled during those days. So the district and union asked: Would you rather the visit be a surprise? Or do you prefer some notice?

Of the 6,500 teachers and administrators who responded, 92 percent voted to keep the notification system as is.

There also were concerns about the word "developing," which evaluators use when a teacher appears not to have mastered a particular aspect of the job. Most wanted a different word. The greatest number (34 percent) chose "progressing."

The third question asked whether principals and peer evaluators should give the same number of points, even though some parts of the evaluation are completed only by the principal — for example, how well the teacher maintains records and collaborates with colleagues.

Seventy-four percent voted to readjust the 30-30-40 scoring formula to give about 35 points to principals and only 25 to peer evaluators.

The union plans to discuss these preferences during contract negotiations, which begin this week.

Like O'Regan, retired teacher Renee Kelly believes the process is flawed and good teachers are needlessly being discouraged.

Her daughter is a teacher and her son is studying to become a teacher, she said. Kelly, 56, left the field early, she said, largely because of her dissatisfaction with the new evaluation system.

She has encouraged her children to stay with it. As she sees it, the accountability movement and the Gates project, like many aspects of education, are cyclical.

"I've seen things come and I've seen things go,'" she said. "So I tell them, 'Ride it out.' "

Marlene Sokol can be reached at (813) 226-3356 or [email protected]

Comments
Hernando school officials set to discuss replacement, sever ties after firing Superintendent Lori Romano

Hernando school officials set to discuss replacement, sever ties after firing Superintendent Lori Romano

BROOKSVILLE — With dust still settling from the Hernando County School Board’s close vote to fire Superintendent Lori Romano — and days before her time as head of the district runs out — school officials and community members seem to be already movin...
Updated: 17 minutes ago
Budget analysis projects deficit, deepened by security costs, for Pasco schools in coming year

Budget analysis projects deficit, deepened by security costs, for Pasco schools in coming year

An early analysis of the Pasco County School District’s 2018-2019 budget projects a deficit of more than a million dollars, with more than half of that coming from a shortfall in funding new school safety requirements.Costs to hire and train 53 new s...
Updated: 3 hours ago
New dorm still coming to USF St. Petersburg, but in a smaller package

New dorm still coming to USF St. Petersburg, but in a smaller package

ST. PETERSBURG — Originally pitched as a nine- or 10-story, 550-bed dorm for the overcrowded University of South Florida St. Petersburg campus, USF’s latest residence hall project will likely look much different by the time it’s done.For starters, it...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Carlton: From Sun Dome to Beer Stadium: Don’t let suds scare you

Carlton: From Sun Dome to Beer Stadium: Don’t let suds scare you

Am I missing something in the — pardon the expression — brouhaha over the renaming of the University of South Florida Sun Dome to the Yuengling Center? In trading a college arena’s longtime name for that of a big-name beer brewed ne...
Updated: 8 hours ago

Hillsborough school district will pursue two kinds of local taxes

TAMPA — Hillsborough County School District officials took an important step Tuesday toward asking the voters to pay higher taxes for schools that, they say, are not getting enough money from the state.The board voted 5-0 to submit a tax referendum r...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Ethan Hooper steps up with a salute to teachers

Ethan Hooper steps up with a salute to teachers

Editor’s note: Ethan Hooper wrote today’s column to give Ernest Hooper Father’s Day off.In May, I graduated from the University of Central Florida with a degree in elementary education, and I recently secured a job as a first-grade teacher with Orang...
Published: 06/18/18
AP World History course is dropping thousands of years of human events - and critics are furious

AP World History course is dropping thousands of years of human events - and critics are furious

Since 2002, the AP World History course has covered thousands of years of human activity around the planet, starting 10,000 years back. But now the College Board, which owns the Advanced Placement program, wants to cut out most of that history and st...
Published: 06/16/18
School board races attract new faces

School board races attract new faces

TAMPA — When long-time Hillsborough County School Board member Susan Valdes resigned this month from the board to run for the State House of Representatives, the decision affected more than just her seat in west Hillsborough’s District 1.It also coul...
Published: 06/14/18
Updated: 06/17/18
Hillsborough schools tax referendum is unlikely for November

Hillsborough schools tax referendum is unlikely for November

TAMPA — Money that the Hillsborough County School District needs to build schools and replace air conditioners might be farther from reach, thanks to a new state law and a bureaucratic process required before the voters can decide on a tax referendum...
Published: 06/14/18
University of Chicago eliminates SAT/ACT requirement

University of Chicago eliminates SAT/ACT requirement

The University of Chicago will no longer require ACT or SAT scores from U.S. students, sending a jolt through elite institutions of higher education as it becomes the first top-10 research university to join the test-optional movement.Numerous school...
Published: 06/14/18