Wednesday, October 17, 2018
Education

Romano: Schools of hope is just one more gimmick set up to fail in Florida

Competing education plans are about to collide in Tallahassee.

If you're inclined to skip over a bunch of the details, the basic difference is this:

The Senate is looking for a solution to Florida's persistent education gap, and the House is looking for an excuse to create more charter schools.

And hanging in the balance?

Only tens of thousands of kids.

This is how life works in Tallahassee, where ideology often comes before common sense. And in this case, the House's ideology is a long-standing mission to turn education over to private interests.

Everyone agrees education in lower-income neighborhoods is a problem. An elusive and cruel problem. Some communities have handled it better than others, but most agree there is no simple switch to flip.

And yet the House is billing its "schools of hope'' plan in just that way.

Essentially, House leaders want to create a fund of $200 million to attract qualified charter school operators to skydive into low-income communities and compete with struggling public schools.

Lawmakers say public schools have had ample opportunity to correct the problem, and now it's time to let charters have a chance with their innovative ideas.

This would be a fine plan except for a few crucial facts:

• Charter schools in Florida have roughly the same success rate as traditional schools;

• The "qualified" charters the House seeks are very picky about where they go;

• Traditional schools don't get the chance to be innovative because the Legislature has burdened them with too many top-down edicts and regulations.

That last fact may be the most important of all. Florida has spent the last 20 years operating under the banner of Jeb Bush's school reforms, and the education gap remains stubbornly wide.

Or here's another way of saying it: They created the circumstances, and now they are criticizing the results.

I don't say that flippantly. In 1998, Bush was selling his accountability plan, with A-F school grades, high-stakes standardized tests, bonus revenues and school choice, as the solution to the education gap.

"Any fair and objective analysis of the comprehensive components of our A+Plan would reveal that it is designed to destroy the institutionalization of lower expectations for children based on their socioeconomic status,'' Bush wrote to the Times in 1999. "To permit the continued institutionalization of these lower expectations would inevitably and tragically lead to the 'Two Floridas' of which I warned in my State of the State address.''

And yet here we are in 2017 with lawmakers lamenting the problem of disparate educational opportunities.

I'm not criticizing Bush's attempt to find a solution here. I'm just suggesting it's hypocritical of the House to blame traditional schools for carrying out Tallahassee's own policy demands.

Meanwhile, the real question is this:

Can charter schools, which use public funds but operate independently, be a solution?

Yes, they absolutely can. The national charter company KIPP, for instance, has gotten good reviews with poverty-level students in Jacksonville, even if its school grades remain somewhat subpar.

But KIPP is also drawing tons of philanthropic money from the business community to help implement its turnaround strategy. Obviously, that's a wonderful thing. But the state can't count on that money to magically show up in every community overnight. And high-level charter companies are not going to rush into situations without a high probability of community support and success.

This is why the Senate's plan is more appealing than the House's "schools of hope'' gimmick. The Senate doesn't rule out the possibility of charters where appropriate, but it also acknowledges that spending too much money on competing schools could be counterproductive.

The Senate also suggests taking the Legislature's shackles off traditional schools and allowing them to implement charter-like ideas. Public schools could even be turned into charters with individual school districts in charge, instead of inviting out-of-state corporations to take over.

It's time Tallahassee took responsibility for Florida's education gap. State leaders have been following the same script for two decades. They've set the policies, they've doled out the insufficient funds.

If they're not happy with the results, they might want to look at themselves as the cause.

Comments
Can new family resource center reshape struggling Hernando County school?

Can new family resource center reshape struggling Hernando County school?

State Schools of Hope grant provides after-school and evening classes and services to help students and their families.
Published: 10/16/18

School notes for Oct. 19

School calendar, events, briefs
Published: 10/15/18
How many active shooter drills is too many? Florida schools don’t know either.

How many active shooter drills is too many? Florida schools don’t know either.

As Florida educators work to make schools less vulnerable to attack, a single line in state law is making that job more confusing.The wording, drafted by legislators in the emotion-filled weeks after the Feb. 14 shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas H...
Published: 10/12/18
MSNBC's Katy Tur hosting live panel with USF students during 'Battleground College Tour'

MSNBC's Katy Tur hosting live panel with USF students during 'Battleground College Tour'

MSNBC's Katy Tur will speak to USF students during a live panel in front of USF's Marshall Student Center on Friday from 2 to 3 p.m.
Published: 10/12/18
Pinellas education news: Financial aid, school choice, USF homecoming and more

Pinellas education news: Financial aid, school choice, USF homecoming and more

SPC invites families to learn about college financial aidSt. Petersburg College will host an event to acquaint parents and students with the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, or FAFSA, a required form for families seeking financial aid for co...
Published: 10/12/18

Berkeley Prep capital campaign reaches $65-million mark

Berkeley Preparatory School has completed one of the largest capital campaign efforts in the country for an independent day school.With more than 250 supporters in attendance at the Power of Community campaign celebration on Oct. 3, the school celebr...
Published: 10/10/18
Andrew Gillum wants to pay starting teachers $50,000. Could that ever happen in Florida?

Andrew Gillum wants to pay starting teachers $50,000. Could that ever happen in Florida?

When Valerie Chuchman moved to Florida from Wisconsin eight years ago, her new principal joked that while she was taking a significant salary cut, she would be repaid in sunshine.Unfortunately, the Riverview High School chemistry teacher said, sunshi...
Published: 10/10/18
Pasco School Board candidates focus on experiences, support in campaign to replace retiring incumbent

Pasco School Board candidates focus on experiences, support in campaign to replace retiring incumbent

One is a teacher. The other is a lawyer and parent. Each believes her experience gives her the edge.
Published: 10/10/18
Sheriff: Officer at Carwise Middle retires amid sexual harassment investigation

Sheriff: Officer at Carwise Middle retires amid sexual harassment investigation

A school resource officer and deputy with the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office retired Tuesday amid allegations that he sexually harassed a female employee at Carwise Middle School while on duty.The Sheriff’s Office received a letter on Oct. 1, which...
Published: 10/09/18
Updated: 10/10/18

School Board seeks to protect teachers leading health courses out of field

And Plato Academy Trinity moves into its new buildings.
Published: 10/09/18