Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

School vouchers study finds little difference between public schools, private schools

Supporters often say school vouchers are lifelines to low-income students trapped in subpar public schools.

But academically, students using vouchers to attend private schools in Florida are doing no better and no worse than similar students in public schools, says a study ordered by the state Legislature.

"We consider the report a validation of what we've always said," said Mark Pudlow, a spokesman for the state teachers union. "There is no quick fix for struggling students."

Northwestern University economics professor David Figlio compared test scores of students in the voucher program, which served 23,259 students last year, to eligible public school students who opted not to participate.

Figlio said it's too early to draw hard-and-fast conclusions, and outlined some technical complications he expects to resolve with another year's worth of data.

But he said more data isn't likely to change the bottom line.

"I'm confident that it's highly unlikely that we're going to see huge differential positive test score gains from this program" or negative results either, he said after the report was released Monday. "My hunch is, when all is said and done … it's going to be a wash in terms of test scores."

But voucher supporters said the findings prove private schools are educating voucher students as well as public schools, and for a lot less money. Per-pupil spending in Florida is about $7,000 a year. A voucher costs taxpayers $3,950.

"The fact that we're keeping (pace) and we're spending 57 cents on the dollar is a good first step,'' said Doug Tuthill, president of Step Up For Students, the Tampa nonprofit group that oversees the voucher program.

But critics said the findings show vouchers have failed to deliver. And to a point, one voucher researcher agreed.

Backers "promised the moon, and public policy almost never delivers the moon," said Jay Greene, a University of Arkansas professor who has studied Florida vouchers. "It doesn't mean that these programs can't be a lifeline.'' But don't expect to see that instantaneously.

The report comes as the tide in Florida's decade-long vouchers war seems to be turning.

In the last two legislative sessions, GOP supporters have successfully expanded the program, which offers businesses a dollar-for-dollar tax credit in return for donations. And a growing number of Democrats have signed on.

Voucher students don't have to take the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test. But since 2006 the state has required that they take a comparable test.

Figlio compared test results from 2006-07 and 2007-08.

Vouchers are available to any student who qualifies for free or reduced lunch. But he found that students who accept them are more likely to be minorities, and be poorer. And while in public schools, they tended to be among the lowest performers. The latter finding undermines an argument by anti-voucher critics.

"Opponents have always said that you're picking off the best and brightest," said Rep. Will Weatherford, R-Wesley Chapel, who spearheaded last year's voucher expansion.

Figlio does not offer an exact comparison. The 2006-07 data was incomplete, and the applicant pool appears to have been skewed by a high number of families who applied for free or reduced lunch even though they did not qualify. Higher-income families usually correlate to higher-performing students.

With those caveats, Figlio concluded that voucher students made slightly smaller gains than similar nonvoucher students in reading and math, though the difference was not statistically significant.

Monday's report did not dissuade voucher parents, or provoucher lawmakers.

"I know my daughter," said Trinette Hicks, whose 9-year-old daughter, Tekoa, attends Southside Christian in St. Petersburg on a tax credit voucher. In private school, Hicks said, "She gets more attention."

Parents "are passionate about the value of their choice," said Sen. Don Gaetz, R-Niceville.

But the new study's results shouldn't be ignored, said Sen. Dan Gelber, D-Miami Beach, a longtime voucher opponent.

"If the kids aren't doing better, then we really ought to reconsider why we're doing it," he said.

Fla. tax credit vouchers

(2008-2009 school year)

# of schools # of students
Pinellas 47 572
Hillsborough 62 1,088
Pasco 19 195
Hernando 6 103
Florida 988 23,259

School vouchers study finds little difference between public schools, private schools 06/29/09 [Last modified: Tuesday, June 30, 2009 12:39pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Trigaux: How Moffitt Cancer's M2Gen startup won $75 million from Hearst

    Business

    TAMPA — A Moffitt Cancer Center spin-off that's building a massive genetic data base of individual patient cancer information just caught the attention of a deep-pocketed health care investor.

    Richard P. Malloch is the president of Hearst Business Media, which is announcing a $75 million investment in M2Gen, the for-profit cancer informatics unit spun off by Tampa's Moffitt Cancer Center. Malloch's job is to find innovative investments for the Hearst family fortune. A substantial amount has been invested in health care, financial and the transportation and logistics industries.
  2. A boat lays on its side off the shore of Sainte-Anne on the French Caribbean island of Guadeloupe, early Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017, after the passing of Hurricane Maria. [Dominique Chomereau-Lamotte | Associated Press]
  3. 7.1 magnitude quake kills at least 149, collapses buildings in Mexico

    World

    MEXICO CITY — A magnitude 7.1 earthquake stunned central Mexico on Tuesday, killing at least 149 people as buildings collapsed in plumes of dust. Thousands fled into the streets in panic, and many stayed to help rescue those trapped.

    A woman is lifted on a stretcher from of a building that collapsed during an earthquake in Mexico City, Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017. [Rebecca Blackwell | Associated Press]
  4. FHP seeks semitrailer truck driver that left fiery wreck on I-75

    Accidents

    TAMPA — The Florida Highway Patrol is looking for the driver of a semitrailer truck that sped off from an Interstate 75 crash that left another car burning on Tuesday afternoon.

    Troopers were looking for the driver of a semitrailer truck that sped off from an accident scene on Interstate 75 in Tampa on Tuesday afternoon that caused a car to catch fire. [Courtesy of Florida Highway Patrol]
  5. Joe Maddon gets warm reception in return to the Trop

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — The night was arranged to honor former Rays manager Joe Maddon in his first visit back to the Trop, and the standing ovation from the bipartisan crowd and scoreboard video tribute seemed proper acknowledgments of his hefty role in the Rays' success during his nine-year stint.

    Chicago Cubs manager Joe Maddon (70) talks with reporters during a press conference before the start of the game between the Chicago Cubs and the Tampa Bay Rays at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017.