Wednesday, January 17, 2018
Education

State exploring ways to revise school grading system

Florida's A-F school grading system, respected and copied in other states, faces a credibility test here where it began.

For the second straight year, the state Board of Education is contemplating possible revisions to the grading calculation because of concerns that the test scores they're based on could make the schools look bad.

A year ago, board members lowered the FCAT writing passing score after learning that students fared poorly under stricter standards and school grades would likely suffer. This year, the board directed that a task force look into superintendents' concerns that a return to tougher policies threatened to drive up the number of F schools.

School grades are intended to be a consistent measure of how schools are performing. But as Florida has discovered over the years, the formula needs to be changed from time to time — either to raise standards or to account for glitches like the looming perception problem that gave rise to the task force.

The goal, board chairman Gary Chartrand said, is to make sure the system is accurate and valid, while maintaining high expectations. Time is short, as grades are due in July.

"It may be late, but it's not too late," Chartrand said, as he instructed Education Commissioner Tony Bennett to form a group to recommend any necessary fixes.

The task force meets Monday.

The stakes are high, said panel member Alberto Carvalho, the Miami-Dade superintendent who questioned the impact of more than a dozen grading changes. If the public sees a disconnect between grades and performance, he said, it could sour perception of the entire system.

"I believe in accountability as key to systemic reform in public education," Carvalho said. "But accountability cannot exist as an entity unto itself. More and more, it has become this monstrous giant that is tweaked up every year and continues to change."

Bennett said he sees regular alterations, such as increasing expectations, as key to promoting higher achievement. School grades, he said, are a tool to drive that endeavor.

In working with the task force, then, Bennett said he will listen for ideas that keep that framework intact, while looking for a way to transition from Florida's current standards and tests to tougher new standards known as the Common Core.

"My intent going forward isn't simply to make schools look better," he said, declining to offer any judgment of the State Board's controversial 2012 decision to change the writing score. "My intent will be to find the right answer."

Michael Petrilli, editor of the reform-focused Education Next journal, urged caution as Florida moves ahead.

Purposeful grading formula adjustments to promote higher goals are one thing, he said. Rewrites on the fly to mitigate expected poor results are another.

"Tweaks are okay and inevitable," Petrilli said. "But major changes for political reasons can really hurt the credibility of the system."

Even if the grades are low, he suggested, Florida's best choice might be to simply explain why and move forward.

Matt DiCarlo, a senior fellow at the teacher union-affiliated Albert Shanker Institute, has long argued that Florida's school grading system does a poor job of measuring school effectiveness. What it measures, he contends, is how performance compares between schools with different demographic make-ups.

He also noted that Florida has revamped its grading methodology several times, making annual comparisons meaningless.

That doesn't mean the state shouldn't revise its rules, even if it causes frustration, DiCarlo said. "But changes should also be evaluated in terms of whether or not they improve the quality of measurement of a system. Balancing these priorities is often difficult."

DePaul University education professor Mike Klonsky, a critic of the education "reform" initiative, argued that a simplistic A-F grading system doesn't provide useful information about children's development as learners. He called the system arbitrary.

At one point, he noted, Gov. Jeb Bush used grades to show how well Florida schools were performing while his brother, President George W. Bush, implemented the federal "adequate yearly progress" model that suggested many of Florida's A-rated schools were failing.

If school grades have a value, he said, "they are easy to comprehend and they're good for selling real estate."

He suggested the state should move away from school grading and high-stakes testing, and instead adopt a system that focuses on more authentic measures of student learning.

Getting rid of school grades, even temporarily, is not in Bennett's plans.

"I think it's a very bad political decision," he said. "Florida students have done very well, and our accountability system has been one of the catalysts for that. … We have to utilize this situation as an opportunity to continue that."

Education officials in other states are watching.

Both Utah and Maine, for instance, are poised to implement school grading models at the encouragement of Jeb Bush and his Foundation for Excellence in Education. So Florida's ups and downs keenly interest leaders there.

Judy Park, Utah's associate superintendent for accountability, said she's interested in seeing how Florida resolves its issues. Utah is looking at enacting school grades primarily for information purposes, without many of the related interventions that Florida has, such as financial incentives for schools.

"Utah is in a great position to prove whether or not school grading (alone) will make a difference," Park said.

Carvalho said he was "pleasantly surprised" that the state board agreed to convene the task force to consider the problems he and other superintendents found. Among his many criticisms, Carvalho argued that the state did not explore the impact on school grades of changes such as computerized testing, new exams and higher passing scores, together with fluctuating calculations.

"The state went too far too fast" in its effort to raise the bar, he said. "If this was Olympic diving, you are raising the height of the platform but you are making the depth of the pool much shallower. The risk is much greater."

He said he hoped the state board will take a closer look at the impacts, while also considering the validity of the tests. He also called for clear public communication about how new grades compare to past ones, and for a long-range plan to move Florida accountability forward.

"I know there are some people … that simply want to get it done," Carvalho said. "More than just getting it done is getting it done right."

Jeffrey S. Solochek can be reached at [email protected], (813) 909-4614 or on Twitter @jeffsolochek.

 
Comments
9 face hazing charges in death of Florida State fraternity pledge

9 face hazing charges in death of Florida State fraternity pledge

TALLAHASSEE — The death of a fraternity pledge from alcohol poisoning has led to hazing charges against nine Florida State University students.State attorney Jack Campbell filed charges on Wednesday in Leon County Court.All nine will be charged with ...
Updated: 10 hours ago
From the archive: USF St. Petersburg’s long journey to autonomy

From the archive: USF St. Petersburg’s long journey to autonomy

As the Florida Legislature considers undoing the current governance of the University of South Florida by folding the three branches of its system into one entity, here is a look at some Times coverage of the long-running struggle for independence at...
Updated: 12 hours ago
How a small campus grew into an independent USF St. Petersburg

How a small campus grew into an independent USF St. Petersburg

Just a satellite campus many decades ago, the University of South Florida St. Petersburg has managed to carve out considerable autonomy within the arms of the USF System. But a bill moving through the state House of Representatives could undo its sep...
Published: 01/17/18
A closer look at graduation rates. How did your school do?

A closer look at graduation rates. How did your school do?

Published: 01/17/18
Young Pasco teacher faces cancer with support of students

Young Pasco teacher faces cancer with support of students

NEW PORT RICHEY — At age 28, things were really shaping up for Joel Santos-Gonzalez. Fulfilling his lifelong dream of becoming a teacher, he had just completed his third year at Gulf Middle School."I always liked to talk to people on an intellectual...
Published: 01/17/18
School board member is ‘dumbfounded’ by Times report on Hillsborough substitute teachers

School board member is ‘dumbfounded’ by Times report on Hillsborough substitute teachers

TAMPA — Members of the Hillsborough County School Board reacted with outrage, mild concern or, in some cases, not at all to a Tampa Bay Times report on misconduct by contracted substitute teachers.Responding to the Times article published Sunday, mem...
Updated: 7 hours ago
In major shift, House bill would turn three USF universities into one

In major shift, House bill would turn three USF universities into one

Separate accreditation has long been a point of pride and a stamp of independence for the St. Petersburg and Sarasota-Manatee branches of the University of South Florida.Graduates of those schools frame diplomas bearing the name of their own universi...
Published: 01/16/18
Top Hillsborough teaching honor goes to a Lewis Elementary educator

Top Hillsborough teaching honor goes to a Lewis Elementary educator

TAMPA — The Hillsborough County Teacher of the Year is a self-described "busy, busy bee" who never tires of exploring new ways to help students learn, even if she has to be creative.At 56, Bonnie Bresnyan also is a mentor for the next generation of s...
Published: 01/16/18

Pasco class notes for Jan. 19

Theatre/Art/MusicCenter for the Arts at River Ridge, 11646 Town Center Road, New Port Richey. (727) 774-7382.• The center’s Learn it Live! series presents The Three Little Pigs, at 10:30 a.m. Jan. 24- 25. Pre-K – grade 4. Public show at 11 a.m. Jan. ...
Published: 01/16/18
Bill to sweeten Bright Futures scholarship sails through Senate

Bill to sweeten Bright Futures scholarship sails through Senate

Nearly a decade since the luster on Florida’s signature merit scholarship program began to grow dim, state lawmakers have taken a decisive step toward restoring its appeal. Just three days into the 2018 Legislative session, the Florida Senate ...
Published: 01/11/18
Updated: 01/12/18