Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Study: Despite claims, many textbooks not aligned to Common Core

A study led by Morgan Polikoff of the University of Southern California disproved claims by the publisher of Go Math!.

Education Writers Association

A study led by Morgan Polikoff of the University of Southern California disproved claims by the publisher of Go Math!.

To sell children on math, textbooks sometimes have colorful fictions on their covers. Iguanas look through kaleidoscopes. Skunks swing baseball bats. Rabbits float away after clutching a few too many balloons.

Now, there's concern that a darker unreality is on the cover of textbooks in order to sell the books to adults: seals that say the texts are aligned to the new Common Core standards.

According to a study by a University of Southern California researcher, textbooks marketed as being in step with the Common Core and currently used in Tampa Bay classrooms fail to capture key concepts of the higher-level standards that have been adopted by Florida and most other states.

Florida education officials defended their adoption process for the books, including the Common Core edition of Go Math!, a Houghton Mifflin Harcourt text used in Pinellas and Pasco's fourth-grade classrooms. Hillsborough plans to begin using this edition in the fall.

The study, by USC assistant professor of education Morgan Polikoff, found that Go Math! is about 38 percent aligned to the Common Core standards. He also says the book does not cover 16 percent of the fourth-grade Common Core content.

The previous version, aligned to Florida's old standards, wasn't much more on the ball, he says: The book was about 45 percent aligned to the Next Generation Sunshine State standards. In fact, the two versions of the book are quite similar.

Because of the time and money involved in overhauling a textbook, there are few incentives for publishers to make significant changes from one edition to the next, Polikoff says. "One of my inclinations is they don't want to make big revisions. This is what a typical textbook has looked like for a long time."

In all, he analyzed four textbooks approved by the Florida Department of Education to teach the Common Core math standards to fourth-grade students.

He found that Common Core content is left out of textbooks, the books spend pages on the wrong content, and they fail to reach the higher levels of cognitive demand that separate the new standards from the old.

For instance, the Common Core calls for 40 percent of a fourth-grader's time to be spent on advanced problem-solving such as demonstrating, generalizing and analyzing. But the textbooks require students to do so only 7 to 12 percent of the time, instead requiring them to memorize or do rote drills.

"The simple fact is that, for a lot of teachers, particularly elementary teachers, if something isn't in a textbook, it doesn't get taught," Polikoff says.

William Schmidt, the co-director of the education policy center at Michigan State University, conducted his own analysis of dozens of textbooks covering first through ninth grades and used by about 60 percent of students nationwide.

At a recent seminar hosted by the Education Writers Association in Los Angeles, Schmidt said that "page by page, paragraph by paragraph," many textbooks were identical to previous editions.

"It is a shame that all these snake-oil salesmen" say textbooks are aligned with the Common Core, Schmidt said of publishers.

Houghton Mifflin Harcourt did not return calls seeking comment. Polikoff also analyzed enVisionMATH, published by Pearson, and Math Connects, from MacMillan/McGraw Hill.

Brian Belardi, a spokesman for MacMillan/McGraw Hill, said of the research, "In some sense, it's not terribly surprising."

When the Common Core was pitched in 2010, Belardi says they worked quickly to put out a book, resulting in Math Connects. They've since developed another book that Belardi says is fully aligned. He said he was not aware why Math Connects was marketed as such.

"We did the best we could under the time frame."

Richard Heater, Pearson's vice president of product for elementary math and literacy, pushed back against the research's findings that certain standards aren't well-represented in the textbook.

"Not all standards are created equal, and we should be spending the majority of the time on major clusters," Heater says.

He also questioned why Polikoff did not look at teacher's editions of the textbooks, which may contain resources to elevate instruction beyond the text.

Mary Jane Tappen, the state Education Department's vice chancellor for K-12 standards and instructional support, says the state was careful when approving these books. The department employs experts in elementary mathematics, and has local district officials and trained teachers review the books before they're considered, Tappen says.

She also thought it made sense that the textbooks were not much different from those aligned to Florida's old standards, which she says were as rigorous as the Common Core.

"We've actually gotten a lot of feedback from parents, regarding how difficult the K-5 math is," Tappen says.

In Pinellas, where Go Math! is in full swing, officials are mindful to identify gaps in the book and help teachers cover those concepts, says Pam Moore, associate superintendent for teaching and learning services.

Her staff sat down over the summer and "mapped that out so (teachers) can see where the gaps are," she says. They'll do it again this summer after conferring with teachers about what worked.

"I can't overemphasize that the book does not represent the (math) program," Moore says. "Books don't teach kids; teachers teach kids. We ensure that, because we know there are gaps."

Contact Lisa Gartner at Follow her on Twitter @lisagartner.

Modestly aligned?

These textbooks claim they are aligned to the Common Core standards. Florida approved them for use in local schools. But new research suggests there's only a modest correlation between the texts and the standards they purport to cover.

Go Math!: 38% alignment

to Common Core

enVisionMATH: 34% alignment

Math Connects: 28% alignment

Saxon: 27% alignment

Source: Morgan Polikoff, assistant professor of education at the University of Southern California

Study: Despite claims, many textbooks not aligned to Common Core 03/09/14 [Last modified: Sunday, March 9, 2014 10:01pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. A second mistrial: Jury deadlocks in Ohio cop's murder retrial


    CINCINNATI — A mistrial was declared Friday in the murder retrial of a white University of Cincinnati police officer after the jury said it was hopelessly deadlocked on charges in the fatal traffic stop shooting of an unarmed black motorist.

    Former University of Cincinnati police officer Raymond Tensing, left, and his attorney Stew Mathews listen as Hamilton County Common Pleas Judge Leslie Ghiz tells the jury to continue deliberations after the jury said they are deadlocked during Tensing's trial on Friday in Cincinnati. [AP photo]
  2. SI ranks Quinton Flowers on top 100, above Deondre Francois


    Sports Illustrated's ongoing countdown of the top 100 players in college football includes some high praise for USF quarterback Quinton Flowers.

  3. What to watch this weekend: 'GLOW,' second season of 'Preacher'


    Ready to rumble: GLOW

    Four words: Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling. Yes, the fluorescent, body-slamming soap opera GLOW starring a cast of exaggerated characters is back, this time as a fictionalized Netflix series. Alison Brie (Community, Mad Men) stars as Ruth, a down-on-her-luck actor …

    Alison Brie, left, and Betty Gilpin in GLOW on Netflix.
  4. Exploratory Lab Boot Camp provides real-life technology training to students


    CLEARWATER — At this graduation ceremony featuring some of the brightest local minds in tech, it was the youngsters who stood out.

    Laszlo Leedy, 17, a senior at Shorecrest Prep, presents part of his team's project for SPC's Exploratory Lab Boot Camp. Students presented their ideas at the end of the SPC Exploratory Lab Boot Camp. The program provides real-time business training to students. This year's graduation celebrated 15 students that finished the program. 
[JIM DAMASKE   |   Times]
  5. Editorial: Trump, not military, should set troop levels in Afghanistan


    There is no task more solemn for any American president than the decision to send troops off to war. In delegating authority over troops levels in Afghanistan to the Pentagon, President Donald Trump has shirked his obligation to own and defend his Afghan policy, while further divorcing America's military strategy there …