Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Tampa Bay schools express disappointment after donating to Pennies for Peace

For months, students at Thurgood Marshall Fundamental Middle School dug in their pockets and solicited parents for spare change. The grade level with the most money at the end would win a dress-down day, but that's not why they did it.

It was the kids a world away, kids who needed them, that really got the Thurgood students donating.

"We all thought we were doing something good," seventh-grader Tarek Ziad said.

So did the students at the 20 or so Tampa Bay area schools — and hundreds of others nationwide — that raised money for Pennies for Peace, founded by Three Tea Cups author Greg Mortenson.

The goal: to build schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

But a recent 60 Minutes investigation alleging that Mortenson lied about his experiences and mismanaged funds for the nonprofit has left the schools and students wondering whether their efforts were worth it.

"I think that's really disappointing because the guy had such a good thing going for him, helping out these people," Ziad said. "He had a really good reputation, and he just kind of ruined it."

Ziad wrote a story for the school's newspaper after the fundraising effort, extolling the nearly $500 in pennies, nickels, dimes and dollars that students raised for the organization.

Across the bay, Pennies for Peace never raised any flags.

Administrators at the private Berkeley Preparatory School in Tampa review every charity that students sponsor, spokeswoman Heather Mackin said.

Students gave the nonprofit more than $1,000.

"They understand the importance of giving back," Mackin said. "They would be very disappointed if the money they raised was not given to those in need."

In both Pinellas and Hillsborough counties, public school fundraising drives are regulated by school board rules, according to policy handbooks.

Pinellas encourages schools to support projects with educational missions. Hillsborough schools may raise money for approved organizations after the principal gives his or her approval.

Judi Dunlap, school director at the private Montessori by the Sea elementary school in St. Pete Beach, said Pennies for Peace is a popular charity for schools primarily because of Mortenson's compelling story.

In his book, Mortenson describes how a group of people from a northern Pakistani village cared for him after he was separated from a mountain climbing expedition in 1993. The locals took him to their village, where Mortenson wrote that he promised the children he would come back some day and build them a school.

The tale is the foundation for Mortenson's charity, which indeed has built schools in the Middle East but perhaps not as many as Mortenson has said, 60 Minutes reported.

"I stand by the information conveyed in my book," Mortenson wrote on the website of the Central Asia Institute, the nonprofit group he co-founded to promote education, especially for girls, in remote regions of northern Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Dunlap said Mortenson is a frequent speaker at school seminars. In fact, he was recently at a Montessori-specific conference that Dunlap attended. She missed his speech to catch a plane but heard that people came away from it deeply motivated to help.

It never seemed like something schools should have investigated further, Dunlap said.

Students at her school collected hundreds of dollars for Pennies for Peace before teachers heard about the 60 Minutes findings.

"I don't think I'll share it with any of the children," Dunlap said. "I don't want them to feel cynical."

Times staff writer Sharon Wynne contributed to this report. Reach Kim Wilmath at [email protected] or (813) 226-3337.

Who donated

Some of the local schools that contributed:

• Azalea Elementary in St. Petersburg; $1,162

• Bay Vista Fundamental Elementary in St. Petersburg; $1,606

• Berkeley Preparatory School in Tampa; More than $1,000

• Starkey Elementary School in Largo; $643

• Mitchell University in Tampa; $535

• Thurgood Marshall Fundamental Middle in St. Petersburg; $499

• Bear Creek Elementary in St. Petersburg; $275

• Macfarlane Park Elementary Magnet School in Tampa; $250

• Unitarian Universalists of Clearwater; a couple hundred

• Montessori by the Sea in St. Pete Beach; In the $100s

• Seven Springs Elementary School in New Port Richey; $50

• Countryside Montessori Charter School in Land O' Lakes, Lincoln Elementary Magnet School in Plant City; Academy of the Holy Names in Tampa; Greco Middle School; Unitarian Universalist Church of Tampa; Learning Express at Westchase; unknown amounts:

Information from Pennies for Peace, Hillsborough and Pinellas counties' school districts, individual schools

Tampa Bay schools express disappointment after donating to Pennies for Peace 04/22/11 [Last modified: Friday, April 22, 2011 10:04pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Ford offers to inspect, repair 1.3 million Explorers for free amid carbon monoxide concerns


    DETROIT – Responding to consumer concerns about exhaust fumes, Ford is offering to inspect and repair Explorer SUVs at no cost to owners.

    Ford is offering customers who own Explorers manufactered between 2011-2017 free inspections and repairs amid carbon monoxide concerns. [Chris Carlson  |  AP]
  2. With Vegas in mind, officers conduct active shooter training at Tampa International Airport

    Public Safety

    TAMPA — Black marked the dead.

    After everyone ran away and was cleared out, two people remained on the ground, playing dead between baggage carousels nine and 10. Firefighters tied black ribbons around their wrists during triage, a quick way to tell other first responders not to waste time on them. Luggage …

    Mock "active shooter" D.J. Colestock, corporal with the Tampa International Airport police, is apprehended by TIA police officer Tom Olsen, right, on Wednesday  during an active shooter training exercise at the airport in Tampa. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Times]
  3. Dirk Koetter, not Jameis Winston, has to make the call


    “Touchdown” Tom Jones, the best Bucs columnist in town, htook it to the house Tuesday when he wrote that Jameis Winston should do the right thing and take a seat if he’s not perfectly healthy to play at Buffalo.

    Whether Jameis Winston plays Sunday or not is Dirk Koetter's call.
  4. This is no time for Jameis Winston to play hero


    Don't be a hero, Jameis.

    Do the right thing. Do what's best.

     Quarterback Jameis Winston #3 of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers sits on the bench during the NFL game against the Arizona Cardinals at the University of Phoenix Stadium on October 15, 2017 in Glendale, Arizona.  (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images) 700070683
  5. NBA off and running to its usual ending


    The NBA season began Tuesday night.

    It ends in June.

    Call me when the Warriors win.

    True, there was news Tuesday night, bad news, grisly news, as Celtics small forward and newcomer Gordon Hayward dislocated his ankle and broke his tibia in a look-away injury early in Boston’s opener at LeBron.

    Call me when the Warriors win, Martin Fennelly writes.