Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

John Romano: The House's hypocrisy on school vouchers — accountability

Give them credit, your representatives in the state House. They don't know the meaning of the word "quit."

They also don't seem to know the meaning of shame. Or hypocrisy. Or fairness. Or equality.

Yes, after the state Senate was ambivalent about radically expanding the school voucher system, the House simply repackaged the same idea with a new sales pitch.

And — surprise! — failed to address the gigantic flaw.

Before going any further, let's once again acknowledge there are valid reasons to support the concept of school vouchers. The tax credit scholarship program diverts public funds to low-income families so their children can attend private schools.

In theory, this is a commendable attempt to break the cycle of poverty. In practice, it falls short.


Because, after more than a decade of micromanaging public schools to ensure uniform accountability across the state, legislators are zealously pushing an agenda to hand over your tax dollars to private schools that are completely immune to accountability.

Is this fair? No.

Is it logical? No.

Is it an example of fiduciary responsibility from the most conservative members of your state Legislature? Heck no.

Supporters of vouchers will point out that scholarship students at private schools have been taking a standardized test similar to the FCAT, but that argument is hollow.

Unlike public schools, a poor score on the test does not necessarily mean a student at a private school is in danger of being held back. It doesn't mean the student's teacher is in danger of a poor job evaluation and possible termination. It doesn't mean the school is in danger of losing funding because of a low mark on the state's school grading system.

A standardized test with no ramifications is not accountability. It's window dressing.

Of course, the problems do not end there.

When the state Supreme Court ruled Gov. Jeb Bush's original voucher program unconstitutional in 2006, Justice Barbara Pariente pointed out private school teachers are not held to the same standards as public school teachers. Bachelor's degrees are not required, and neither are teacher certifications or background checks.

Curriculum, which our legislators think is their responsibility to monitor, is also unregulated in private schools.

Before this legislative session began, House Speaker Will Weatherford said teacher evaluation, standardized testing, curriculum standards and the school grading system were "the four horsemen'' of education in Florida.

Yet, when it comes to private schools, those horsemen are still standing in the corral.

Just to be clear, none of this is meant to disparage private schools. I have no doubt that many private schools are providing educational outcomes superior to public schools. And there are highly qualified and effective teachers at private schools across the state.

The point is the state cannot treat public and private schools differently. Not when you're writing more than $1 billion worth of checks to private schools in the next few years. And certainly not when you're trying to write legislation to increase that spending.

You can't be fanatical about the impact of standardized tests in public schools, then act as if they're inconsequential when it comes to private schools.

It's disingenuous. It's deceitful. In the end, it's unconstitutional.

John Romano: The House's hypocrisy on school vouchers — accountability 03/31/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, April 1, 2014 8:11am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Retired Florida Supreme Court Justice Parker Lee McDonald dies

    TALLAHASSEE — A former Florida Supreme Court justice, who wrote a decision that prevented lawyers from excluding jurors because of their race, has died.

    Former Florida Supreme Court Justice Parker Lee McDonald died Saturday, the court said in a statement. He was 93.
  2. CIA chief: Intel leaks on the rise amid 'worship' of leakers


    WASHINGTON — CIA director Mike Pompeo says he thinks disclosure of America's secret intelligence is on the rise, fueled partly by the "worship" of leakers like Edward Snowden.

    CIA director Mike Pompeo said the U.S. must redouble its efforts to stop information from leaking.
  3. ABC Racing kennel advances three into semifinals


    ST. PETERSBURG — The maiden voyage by Don Burk into the $30,000 St. Petersburg Derby series — his first as the ABC Racing kennel owner — went as easy as ABC.

  4. Why Grenfell tower burned: Regulators put cost before safety


    The doorbell woke Yassin Adam just before 1 a.m. A neighbor was frantically alerting others on the fourth floor of Grenfell Tower about a fire in his apartment. "My fridge blew up," the man shouted.

    At least 79 people were killed in the fire at the Grenfell Tower apartment building in London, and the toll is expected to rise.
  5. Bullpen melts down as Rays lose to Orioles (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — Jacob Faria allowed his first two big-league home runs and was touched for a career-high three runs Saturday by the Orioles. Other than that, the rookie making his fourth major-league start did okay against the Baltimore bats.

    The bullpen, not so much.

    Tampa Bay Rays relief pitcher Jumbo Diaz wipes his face as he walks off the mound after the Baltimore Orioles scored four runs during the eighth inning of a baseball game Saturday, June 24, 2017, in St. Petersburg, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) SPD118