Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida judge: Cuts to state employees' pay violated contract

TALLAHASSEE — The decision to cut state and local government workers pay 3 percent and shift the money to the state's pension fund broke the state's contract with employees, a Leon County circuit judge told lawyers for Gov. Rick Scott and the Florida Legislature on Wednesday.

But was the move illegal? That's the question Circuit Judge Jackie Fulford left undecided as she ended the day-long hearing on the lawsuit brought by the Florida Education Association and other state and local government unions.

The unions sued the state for changing the rules of the game on pensions for current employees when it cut worker salaries 3 percent, eliminated cost of living adjustments, or COLAs, for retirement benefits, and shifted the money into the Florida Retirement System to save the state $1 billion during the 2011 legislative session.

The state argues that it was entitled to make the changes, which it called "modifications," under its budgetary authority and denies it violated the collective bargaining rights of state workers when it made the changes without renegotiating employee contracts.

Fulford wasn't buying it. "The more you work, the longer there is a reduction in the COLA,'' she said.

In a dramatic move at one point during the hearing, Fulford left the bench and pointed to numbers on a spreadsheet projected on a courtroom screen.

"I disagree with you,'' Fulford told David Godofsky, a lawyer representing the Florida attorney general. Godofsky, of the Washington, D.C., law firm of Alston & Bird, had argued that the changes to the retirement system would not result in less money going to workers when they retire.

An expert witness, testifying on behalf of the state, told the court that despite the elimination of the cost-of-living benefits, workers would collect a smaller percentage in COLA benefits but their retirement funds would still increase — because the longer they worked, the more they would collect in savings.

Fulford countered. The employee "is paying more, getting less and, in fact, COLA does change,'' she said forcefully.

When Godofsky suggested that the employee's bank account would grow under the plan as long as the employee kept working, she chided him.

"Why are you arguing about the size of his bank account?'' she said. "You are punishing him for continuing to work and you want to use it against him for his bank account continuing to grow.''

FEA lawyer Ron Meyer urged Fulford to reject the benefits cuts and require the state to return the money to state and local employees.

"If the state can simply walk away from its contractual rights ... and spend it on whatever it likes, there would be no contractual rights,'' he said.

He told the court that the Legislature could have changed the rules for future employees, as it did when it altered the rules for police and firefighters, but instead, "the state got greedy. The state wanted more money."

Doug Hinson, arguing on behalf of the state, pointed to a 1981 ruling in which the Florida Supreme Court ruled in a case involving the Florida Sheriffs Association. That case said that the Legislature has the right to modify retirement benefits of active employees when it affects benefits they have not yet earned. "We're not going back and violating something they have already funded,'' Hinson said.

The judge said she did not know when she would rule on the case. In July, she rejected the unions' request to force the state to set aside the money it was collecting from workers for their retirement in the event the workers win the lawsuit.

This is the second high-profile case Fulford has handled involving the Scott administration and the Legislature. Last month, she ruled that legislators violated the state Constitution when they approved a plan to privatize 32 South Florida prisons in the state budget, rather than in a separate bill. The administration has not appealed that ruling.

Mary Ellen Klas can be reached at or on Twitter @MaryEllenKlas

Florida judge: Cuts to state employees' pay violated contract 10/26/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, October 26, 2011 6:42pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pinellas licensing board executive director settled hundreds of cases without getting his board's approval

    Local Government

    By Mark Puente

    Times Staff Writer

    Eleanor Morrison complained to the Pinellas licensing board in 2015 that her contractor installed crooked walls and windows and poured too much concrete for her carport.

    Eleanor Morrison poses at her home in Treasure Island, 5/26/17. Morrison filed a complaint with the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board and later learned that its former Executive Director, Rodney Fischer, dismissed the case in a private meeting with the contractor.
  2. Report: Kusher wanted secret communications channel with Kremlin


    Jared Kushner and Russia's ambassador to Washington discussed the possibility of setting up a secret and secure communications channel between Donald Trump's transition team and the Kremlin, using Russian diplomatic facilities in an apparent move to shield their pre-inauguration discussions from monitoring, U.S. …

    The name of Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's White House senior adviser, has come up as part of the Russia investigation. [Associated Press]
  3. Rays pitchers rave about Twins pitching coach, ex-mentor Neil Allen

    The Heater

    MINNEAPOLIS — There have been a lot of coaches who have had a hand in helping Chris Archer get to the big leagues and to the front of the Rays rotation, and as he took the mound Friday night at Target Field, he had reason to nod appreciatively toward the home dugout.

    Minnesota Twins pitching coach Neil Allen jogs back to the dugout after paying starting pitcher Tyler Duffey a visit on the mound in the first inning of a baseball game against the Texas Rangers on Thursday, July 7, 2016, in Arlington, Texas. (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez)
  4. Swan sculpture deputies say was stolen by naked man found near Lakeland pond


    A $25,000 swan sculpture that Polk County sheriff's deputies say was stolen by a naked man last weekend was found near a pond in Lakeland on Thursday.

    A swan sculpture that was stolen in Lakeland on May 19 was recovered by the Polk Sheriff’s Office on Friday.
  5. Mayor Rick Kriseman says St. Petersburg mayoral election is about going forward, not back


    ST. PETERSBURG — Mayor Rick Kriseman christened his campaign office Friday evening by telling his supporters that the mayoral election was about moving forward, not backward.

    Mayor Rick Kriseman says mayoral election is about inclusiveness Friday at campaign office rally