Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Angelo's says DEP once supported controversial Dade City landfill

TEMPLE TERRACE — State officials who twice refused to allow a controversial household garbage landfill to be built near Dade City once supported the project, according to the company's project manager.

John Arnold said representatives of Angelo's Aggregate Materials had 20 face-to-face meetings with staffers from the state Department of Environmental Protection since the company started buying the land in 2005.

"Each time, it was almost exclusively to understand the comments we received from them," said Arnold, who testified Tuesday in the Largo-based company's appeal of the state's denials of the permit in 2009 and 2011. "Every time we followed through on their requests to modify our landfill."

Angelo's promised a double liner, extra layers and grout for sinkhole prone areas.

Arnold even affirmed the existence of an email from Deputy DEP Secretary Jeff Littlejohn after a meeting last year that urged a "speedy issuance" of the permit.

Then DEP reversed course and denied the landfill permit for a second time, citing the risk of sinkholes on the property. Officials noted that when workers drilled into the soil in 2007 to test the strength of the land, a 4-foot-wide sinkhole cracked open.

The proposed landfill would have been about a half mile from Angelo's construction and debris landfill near the edge of the Green Swamp. The proposal first was promoted as another option to solve Pasco's growing garbage disposal problem in addition to a solid waste incinerator. It quickly drew opposition from a host of groups, including neighbors, two prominent ranchers and local governments who fear its proximity to drinking water sources for Zephyrhills and Tampa. It also spurred involvement from corporate giant Nestle Waters North America Inc., which pumps hundreds of gallons from Crystal Spring for its spring water label.

The hearing, which is being held at DEP's regional office in Hillsborough County, is expected to take up to four weeks. Administrative law judge Bram Canter will review all the evidence and rule later.

All anti-landfill groups had attorneys lined up on the same side of the hearing room this week to oppose Angelo's legal team. They are calling themselves "the Aligned Parties."

Angelo's team is smaller but includes heavy hitters such as Linda Loomis Shelley, former chief of staff for Gov. Lawton Chiles and a secretary for the Florida Department of Community Affairs. Also working on the case for Angelo's is Jake Varn, former secretary of the state Department of Environmental Regulation from 1979 to 1981 and assistant executive director for the Southwest Florida Water Management District, and Karen Brodeen, a former attorney for DCA.

Shelley said Monday during opening statements that Angelo's has done more to provide "reasonable assurance" of safety than any other landfill in DEP history.

"Challengers have taken what I would call a spaghetti approach and have thrown a lot of issues into the proceeding that don't go to the main points," she said.

Those include the fact, supported by 50 years of evidence from the U.S. Geological Survey, that water does not run toward their properties, she said. Also, in the unlikely event poisoned water should escape Angelo's extensive monitoring system, "that it will travel through ground and rock and groundwater for miles and we think that is not the case."

Attorneys for the opponents cited tests that showed sinkhole activity.

"The more data they produce on the site the worse the site looks for a landfill," said Doug Manson, attorney for Nestle and the city of Tampa. "There is no way to engineer a monitoring plan to capture that (poisonous water) before it goes off site."

Attorney David Smolker, who represents nearby landowner Bill Blanchard and WRB Enterprises, said the site is part of an area called the Brooksville Ridge, known for lime rock formations that resemble Swiss cheese.

"We would contend they cannot provide enough evidence that their garbage dump would not cause pollution," he said. Two mounds of groundwater at the site rise and fall, he said, meaning "pollution could go almost anywhere." Smolker also cited several warning letters the company had received from DEP regarding the two area landfills it operates. One involved spotters not sufficiently detecting forbidden waste and another was for using too little soil to cover the waste.

Arnold outlined on Tuesday how the company went to great lengths to deal with any potential problems at the site proposed for the new landfill.

He said Angelo's did more testing, and even added an extra liner that had been used in a Hernando County landfill.

He said he met with Blanchard early in the process, and the rancher expressed no opposition.

"He said it sounded like a good idea, and he wish he'd thought of it," Arnold said.

David McCrary, then director of Tampa's Department of Solid Waste, also said he had no problem with the project when Arnold met with him in 2007, Arnold testified.

"He said this was the Mercedes Benz of solid waste facilities," Arnold said. "He said he wished they had a landfill like this."

And contrary to what opponents describe, he said, the site is far from pristine. Chicken farms and an old county landfill surround the site, which sits across the street from the company's existing construction debris landfill.

Arnold said the chicken farm emits a stench that "will actually knock you back if you get too close."

Angelo's says DEP once supported controversial Dade City landfill 09/25/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, September 25, 2012 8:58pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Trigaux: Tampa Bay lands on Forbes 2017 ranking of best places for young professionals

    Working Life

    Consider this one more notch in the belt of Tampa Bay starting to win serious attention from millennials as place to live and build a career.

    Mike Griffin is a senior managing director in Tampa for Savills Studley Occupier Services, which provides integrated real estate services. He is also chairman for 2017 of the Greater Tampa Chamber of Commerce, the first of the next generation of leadership emerging in this metro market. [Courtesy of Greater Tampa Chamber of Commerce]
  2. Column: Trump beat Bush, Rubio but has become an 'establishment sellout'


    NYT’s Ross Douthat's Sunday column: Donald Trump, Establishment Sellout

  3. Haitians get a reprieve from Trump administration


    Haitians living in Florida, and the rest of the country, will be allowed to stay an additional six months, federal officials have decided.

  4. Veteran big game hunter dies after elephant, felled by gunfire, collapses on him


    Theunis Botha led his first guided hunting safari through South Africa's grasslands in 1989. A college student at the time, he used the money he received to help put himself through school.

    Big game hunter Theunis Botha, shown here with elephant tusks, was killed during a hunt in west Zimbabwe.
  5. Starting at top: O.J. Howard becomes first Bucs rookie to sign


    The Bucs have begun the process of signing their rookie draft picks and they started at the top.

    Alabama tight end O.J. Howard has signed a four-year contract with a fifth-year club option with the Bucs.