Tuesday, October 16, 2018
News Roundup

Tampa plan to pump water from sinkholes alarms neighbors

TAMPA

A century ago, water flowed freely from the Hillsborough River down into Tampa Bay. The millions of gallons of freshwater used to keep the bay's salinity in check, which was important for the health of the snook and other fish living there. But in 1897, Tampa dammed the river, creating a reservoir to supply its drinking water. Since then, freshwater has continued to spill out of the dam into the riverbed, but during dry seasons there is sometimes no water to spare.

Under pressure to fix that situation, Tampa officials now plan to restore the flow into Tampa Bay — but not with river water. Instead, the city plans to pump up to 2 million gallons a day from Blue Sink, a complex of sinkholes in Sulphur Springs, then pipe that water to the base of the dam and pour it out.

To the people who live in the suburbs around Blue Sink, this is a Rube Goldberg solution that can only lead to further problems — for them. They fear pumping water from the sinkholes will create even more sinkholes, not to mention draining their lakes and sucking their private wells dry.

"When our lakes go dry, who pumps the water back into our lakes?" one resident asked in an email to the agency in charge of permitting the project.

During a recent community meeting that drew more than 100 people, Jim Wilson of the North Forest Hills Neighborhood Association said he told city officials "we were worried about our water and our quality of life."

After all, he pointed out, the sinkholes, nearby Sulphur Spring and the neighborhood's lakes all connect underground to the aquifer, so "all this stuff is tied together."

But Tampa Water Department boss Brad Baird said the homeowners shouldn't worry. Any impacts to the aquifer and lakes, he predicted, "will be minimal."

For one thing, the pump won't be running all the time, only as needed. The city's engineers, in their application for a 30-year pumping permit, estimate that at most that would be 287 to 318 out of 365 days. "In some years we won't need it at all," Baird said.

The city's studies say none of the 800 wells within a 1-mile radius "is expected to be significantly impacted" by that amount of pumping. At most they might drop two-tenths of a foot, the city's engineers predict.

They've based those conclusions on a pair of 30-day pumping tests and a computer model. The neighbors are not buying the test results.

"I don't know how you can look at 30 days and project out 30 years," Wilson said. "If you can tell me from 30 days what's going to happen over the next 30 years, you're smarter than I am."

They have not questioned the computer model, but others have. Hydrologists know that for years Florida officials have based all their water permitting decisions on computer models that use a false assumption. The models assume that the aquifer flows at a steady rate through layers of sand and gravel.

Actually, what's beneath our feet isn't sand. It's called karst — a landscape made of limestone that's full of holes both big and small, where water sometimes shoots through as if sprayed by a firehose.

As a result, the computer models are so far off base "they shouldn't be used to make decisions," David Still, former executive director of the Suwannee River Water Management District, said in an interview earlier this year.

Both the model and the pump tests for Blue Sink were provided by the Southwest Florida Water Management District, more commonly known as Swiftmud. Swiftmud is Tampa's partner on the Blue Sink project, paying half of the $11 million bill.

Swiftmud also happens to be the regulator that pushed for restoring the river's flow into Tampa Bay and is now overseeing how Tampa carries out that order.

The state agency issued Tampa a construction permit in October, but has yet to approve the city's water-use permit. That's slated for a decision next month. Baird said the city hopes to begin work near year and finish in 2015.

Swiftmud began pressing Tampa to restore the river flow in 1999, setting a goal that was challenged by a nonprofit group, Friends of the River. The Friends group sued, saying Swiftmud's goal didn't provide enough freshwater to support snook, baby manatees and other wildlife, and settled for a five-year study.

Ultimately Swiftmud set a new river flow goal that was twice as much as its original one, about 13 million gallons a day. Friends of the River hoped the city would use the water in the 1,300-acre reservoir to meet that goal.

"The most elegant option is to release water at the dam," Rich Brown, a member who as an engineer had worked on water quality issues for the Navy, said in 2007. "You just turn a button, crank the gate open."

Rather than give up drinking water, the city instead picked something far more complicated. The Blue Sink project is only the fourth of five projects Tampa has planned for supplementing the river, Baird said. Other sources include the Tampa Bypass Canal and the Morris Bridge Sink northeast of Temple Terrace.

That the city is now looking to Blue Sink as a water source for environmental restoration marks a turnaround in its attitude. A 2004 study found that the city had been funneling polluted stormwater into the sinkhole complex for years, and some sinks had become blocked by people dumping in old refrigerators, car parts, tires and battery casings.

Times staff researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. Craig Pittman can be reached at [email protected] or on Twitter @craigtimes.

 
Comments
Hurricane Michael: From atop bridges, those inside the destruction talk to the world

Hurricane Michael: From atop bridges, those inside the destruction talk to the world

PORT ST. JOE — Bridges span voids. Traditionally, the gaps are physical barriers, be it rivers, railroads or ravines.After Hurricane Michael, the bridges near Mexico Beach have become portals of sorts, the only place where communication is possible w...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Rays’ Rocco Baldelli interviews with Rangers

Rays’ Rocco Baldelli interviews with Rangers

Interest in Rays coach Rocco Baldelli as a manager continues to grow, as he interviewed for another opening on Monday, this time with the Texas Rangers.Baldelli, 37, has also interviewed with the Reds, and reportedly with the Twins. The Angels and Bl...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Buccaneers AfterMath: The kicker problem and how to solve it

Buccaneers AfterMath: The kicker problem and how to solve it

On “Separation Sunday” in the NFL, it was gut-check time for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. They didn’t pass, dropping their third straight game.In a 34-29 loss to the Falcons in Atlanta, the defense struggled to get off the field on thi...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Why the Bucs waited to fire Mike Smith

Why the Bucs waited to fire Mike Smith

TAMPA — Exactly two weeks ago, Bucs coach Dirk Koetter stood at the same podium following an embarrassing 48-10 loss at Chicago and asked this rhetorical question: "We fire Mike Smith. Okay, then what would the next move be?''Well, the Buc...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Judge throws out Stormy Daniels' lawsuit against Trump

Judge throws out Stormy Daniels' lawsuit against Trump

A federal judge on Monday dismissed a lawsuit from adult film actress Stormy Daniels that claimed President Donald Trump defamed her when he suggested she had lied about being threatened to keep quiet about their relationship. Federal District Judge ...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Microsoft co-founder, philanthropist Paul Allen dies at 65

Microsoft co-founder, philanthropist Paul Allen dies at 65

SEATTLE — Paul G. Allen, who co-founded Microsoft with his childhood friend Bill Gates before becoming a billionaire philanthropist who invested in conservation, space travel and professional sports, died Monday. He was 65.He died in Seattle f...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Why the recycling industry is in the dumps

Why the recycling industry is in the dumps

ALBANY, N.Y. — A crash in the global market for recyclables is forcing communities across the United States to make hard choices about whether they can afford to keep recycling or should simply send all those bottles, cans and plastic containers to t...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Microsoft co-founder Allen dies

Microsoft co-founder Allen dies

Paul Allen, the taciturn computer programmer who founded the software behemoth Microsoft with Bill Gates when he was 22 and walked away eight years later with what would become one of the largest fortunes in the history of American capitalism, died M...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Archaeologists find 'vampire burial' site of a child feared capable of rising from the dead

Archaeologists find 'vampire burial' site of a child feared capable of rising from the dead

Inside a miniature tomb, in the middle of what used to be a sprawling Roman villa, is the skeleton of a 10-year-old child who died more than 1,500 years ago. It is on its side, its mouth agape and stuffed with a limestone rock about the size of a big...
Updated: 8 hours ago
HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Terrel Ferrell and Mila Yarich

HomeTeam Hot Shot winners: Terrel Ferrell and Mila Yarich

Terrel Ferrell, BloomingdaleFor the first six games, Ferrell did not play at peak performance.The electrifying wideout had tweaked his ankle and pulled his groin.Ferrell said he took it easy the first half of the season as more of a precautionary mea...
Updated: 8 hours ago