LARGO — Richard Farnham was hired as a deputy by the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office in 2000 when Everett Rice was sheriff. He resigned in disgrace in 2007 under Sheriff Jim Coats.
From hiring to evaluations to discipline, supervisors had multiple chances to discern that Farnham was a risk. Some of these same supervisors now occupy key positions with Sheriff Bob Gualtieri.
No single citizen complaint was blatant enough to disqualify Farnham as an officer. But taken as a group, they suggest an officer with a pattern of losing control.
Here is a sampling.
January 2002: Farnham arrested a Naples man who kicked the van of a woman who had hit and dragged his dog. The man said he was handcuffed in Farnham's office when the deputy rammed his head into a bookshelf and said, "This is my town. I am in charge here. . . . Don't you ever raise your voice in my office again.''
A deputy who witnessed the exchange said the man was erratic and cursing and jumped out of his chair at Farnham. Farnham said he pushed the man into the bookcase as a defensive maneuver.
Farnham was disciplined for not reporting his use of force.
April 2002: Farnham stopped a Largo woman with three young children in her car for an expired license tag. Flustered, she threw the owner's manual and other documents out the window, hitting Farnham in the chest. Farnham handcuffed her and put her in the back of his cruiser for a while, leaving her children, ages 6 months to 8 years, in her SUV with the windows rolled up.
In her complaint, the woman wrote that Farnham scared her children by saying he was taking her and them to jail. She also said he remarked that it "must be nice not to have to work and drive a $40,000 car. . . . I can't drive a $40,000 car.''
Her 8-year-old testified that the children waited for about 20 minutes in the SUV until another deputy rolled one window halfway down. "Me, my brother and my sister were crying. The windows were all up,'' he said.
Sgt. Greg Handsel — now a captain in charge of internal affairs — found the woman's story "not credible,'' noting that she cursed in front of her children and exaggerated how much time passed during the incident.
Farnham was not disciplined. Handsel declined comment for this story.
September 2004: Farnham Tasered Daniel Thompson in the Panhandle.
January 2005: Farnham put a Largo man in a cruiser, handcuffed, during an arrest for obstruction and disorderly conduct. The man was drunk, cursing and threatening officers. He complained that Farnham Tasered him twice for no reason.
Farnham wrote that he first fired the Taser when the man tried to get out of the cruiser and had put both feet on the ground. After the man slumped toward the inside of the car, Farnham wrote, "he then made derogatory comments, wouldn't cooperate and was Tased again."
Farnham never reported the Tasering until the man complained five days later. Farnham was disciplined for not filing an immediate report, as required.
October 2005: Farnham and another deputy told a Clearwater homeowner to turn down the music at his backyard party. The other deputy said the man tried to push him out the front door, then ran back through the house toward the back door. Farnham, who was in the house, Tasered the homeowner, who tumbled into the back yard. Farnham said the man then tried to get up and was Tasered again.
Farnham was not disciplined. The man sued the Sheriff's Office and won a settlement.
May 2006: Farnham stopped a man who had reportedly brandished a gun in a bar fight. When the man refused several orders to get on the ground, Farnham Tasered him.
The man complained that Farnham then asked him, "How did that feel?'' When he answered, "mild but effective,'' Farnham Tasered him again. He said Farnham and another deputy then exchanged high-fives.
Both deputies denied any such celebration. Farnham said the man was Tasered the second time because he refused to roll onto his abdomen to be handcuffed.
Farnham was not disciplined.
During this and other 2005 and 2006 cases, current chief Deputy Daniel Simovich ran the patrol division and received copies of internal affairs reports on Farnham.
Simovich declined to comment for this report.