Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Florida judge: States should move forward with federal health care law

Senior U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson set a deadline of seven days for the Obama administration to file an appeal of his earlier ruling.

Associated Press (2007)

Senior U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson set a deadline of seven days for the Obama administration to file an appeal of his earlier ruling.

A Florida judge who ruled the federal health care law unconstitutional says states must implement the law as they wait for President Barack Obama's administration to appeal the case.

"It would be extremely disruptive and cause significant uncertainty" to halt implementation, U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson wrote in an opinion Thursday. "… The sooner this issue is finally decided by the Supreme Court, the better off the entire nation will be."

Several states, including Florida, had interpreted Vinson's January ruling to mean that implementation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act should stop, so the federal government asked him to clarify.

Vinson chastised the Obama administration for delaying an appeal and set a seven-day deadline to file it. After that, his ruling could be viewed as an injunction, he wrote. A spokeswoman for the Department of Justice said it would file a notice of appeal promptly and seek an expedited ruling.

In Florida, which has already rejected two $1 million federal grants to help implement the law, the governor's office didn't budge, echoing Vinson in urging a fast-track appeal process to the U.S. Supreme Court.

"We'll continue to review the full impact of the ruling," said Brian Hughes, a spokesman for Gov. Rick Scott.

Meanwhile, Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi praised Vinson's original declaration that the law is unconstitutional.

"With this order from Judge Vinson, the 26 states and National Federation of Independent Business as plaintiffs are assured that there will be no more stalling from the federal government," she said.

Bondi's spokeswoman acknowledged Vinson's opinion meant implementation should continue.

"States must follow whatever requirements bind them within the health care act," Jennifer Davis said.

Jay Wolfson, a professor of health law at Stetson College of Law, said the Obama administration should have filed an appeal quickly, or at least asked for a stay of the judge's decision. Instead it waited weeks, then asked for a "clarification." The judge's frustration showed, Wolfson said.

"He didn't think it was courteous for them to have waited this long, and they say, oh, gee, could you clarify what you said?" Wolfson said. "… Under other circumstances, he might have held whoever the appellant would have been in contempt."

But it's in the administration's interest, he said, to draw out legal battles. The longer it takes, the harder it will be to undo the law's effects, and the more politically charged the atmosphere will be as the 2012 elections near. Many of the act's central provisions don't take effect until 2014, including requirements that most individuals obtain health insurance and that employers of a certain size offer coverage to workers or pay a penalty.

Vinson ruled the massive overhaul unconstitutional in January, saying the federal government had overstepped its authority to regulate interstate commerce by requiring nearly all Americans to carry health insurance.

He said lawmakers do not have the power to penalize citizens for not doing something.

But he wrote in Thursday's ruling that other judges will probably disagree with him.

"It is likely that the Court of Appeals will also reach divergent results and that, as most court-watchers predict, the Supreme Court may eventually be split on this issue as well," he wrote.

Still, he said, it is in the nation's best interest for states to continue following the law for now.

The health care law faces legal challenges from at least 27 states. Florida is the lead plaintiff in the 11th Circuit case, joined by 25 states and the National Federation of Independent Businesses.

Other states that joined Florida in the lawsuit were Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, North Dakota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming.

Information from Times wires was used in this report.

Florida judge: States should move forward with federal health care law 03/03/11 [Last modified: Thursday, March 3, 2011 11:01pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Man taken into custody after live streaming drive along Clearwater Beach sand

    Public Safety

    CLEARWATER — Clearwater Police took a man into custody Thursday afternoon after, they said, he drove his car over beach chairs and umbrellas along Clearwater Beach and streamed it on Facebook.

  2. Once trapped and wounded, manatee and calf return to the wild


    NEW PORT RICHEY — The small crowd readied cameras and craned their necks, peering over heads and through bodies to try and catch a glimpse. Brittany Pharel, 10, wanted to see the hulking manatees, a mother and her calf, laid out on blue tarps Thursday along the edge of the Pithlachascotee River.

    Tampa's Lowry Park Zoo's associate veterinarian Lauren Smith, 33, examines the heart rate of a manatee calf named Cottee just before it was released into the waters of the Pithlachascotee River on Thursday. 
Cottee's mother Pascow was released at the same time in New Port Richey. 
The pair became stranded in May and the mother was found wounded. They needed to be rehabilitated before they could be released into open waters. [ALESSANDRA DA PRA  |   Times]
  3. Gov. candidate Chris King: Climate change is biggest threat to Florida's economy


    Democratic gubernatorial candidate Chris King today made his case for how economic growth and fighting climate change go hand in hand. His rivals for the Democratic nomination, Gwen Graham, …

    Winter Park businessman Chris King and his family
  4. Editorial: Buckhorn's proposed tax increase is too high for Tampa


    Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn's proposed city budget for 2018 confronts some hard realities of the times. With debt payments looming and another fire station opening in fast-growing north Tampa, the City Council needs to consider raising property taxes, especially with the prospect of another homestead exemption around the …

    Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn’s proposed city budget for 2018 confronts some hard realities of the times. But it seems overly ambitious, and the City Council should be cautious about raising taxes too much in a single swoop.
  5. The next step in a sex abuse survivor's recovery: Erasing her tattoo


    TAMPA — Even after 20 years, Sufiyah can't escape the memories of being sexually exploited by gang members as a teenager.

    The tattoo makes it impossible.