Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

High court ruling against Obamacare would put pressure on Florida families, lawmakers

Nicole Peterson already struggles to provide for her three daughters with the $36,000 she makes managing a Kenneth City day care center.

If she were to lose her $150-a-month health insurance subsidy from the federal government?

"That's an electric or a water bill, or groceries and gas," Peterson said. "These aren't luxuries. These are things we need for survival."

So in between 11-hour days at the child care center and the demands of being a single mom, Peterson looks for updates on the U.S. Supreme Court case known as King vs. Burwell. The decision, expected this month, will determine whether she and 6.4 million other Americans continue receiving the subsidies associated with the Affordable Care Act.

The stakes are particularly high in Florida. A ruling against the health care law could cause more than 1.3 million Floridians to lose their financial assistance. That's more people than in any other state, according to the federal government.

Other consumers could also feel the sting. Experts say the elimination of subsidies would prompt thousands to leave the individual health insurance market, causing premiums and out-of-pocket costs to climb for those who keep their coverage.

"I could see the insurance market really caving under this pressure," said Dr. Mona Mangat, a St. Petersburg allergist and chairwoman of the pro-Obamacare group Doctors for America. "It is a very, very dire situation."

Not everybody buys the doomsday predictions. Some conservative think tanks say the situation will be manageable. But there is widespread consensus that a ruling against the subsidies would ratchet up pressure on both Washington and Tallahassee.

• • •

The case before the court centers on four words in the 900-page Affordable Care Act. The law guarantees financial aid to low-income people who buy coverage on insurance exchanges "established by the state."

Here's the rub: Thirty-four states, including Florida, didn't establish exchanges. They opted instead to use an insurance marketplace run by the federal government.

Federal health officials have been giving the subsidies to people in all 50 states. But the plaintiffs in King vs. Burwell say the law should be read literally, meaning the aid should go only to those in the state exchanges — not the federal ones.

A ruling against the subsidies would shock the market for individual insurance. A recent analysis by the RAND Corp. predicted enrollment would plunge by 70 percent in states on the federal exchanges. That could cause premiums to rise by an average of 47 percent, or about $1,610 a year for a 40-year-old who doesn't smoke.

"It's going to affect the people who don't get the tax credits and pay out of pocket for their insurance today," said Laura Brennaman, a registered nurse and health policy consultant for the consumer advocacy group Florida CHAIN. "Those premiums are going to become unaffordable to them."

Edmund Haislmaier, a senior research fellow at the conservative Heritage Foundation, envisions a less dramatic scenario. He noted that people who receive subsidies make up only a small fraction of the private insurance market, and predicted that some of them would keep their plans.

"Some subset of these people will be able to afford it," he said.

Beverly Borrelli says she won't be one of them.

A 63-year-old Tarpon Springs resident who was laid off by her longtime employer in 2012, she receives $625 a month to help offset the cost of health insurance. It's the only way she can afford the $670 monthly premium for her "silver" plan living on a fixed income, she said.

"If they eliminate the (subsidies), I will have no medical insurance until I qualify for Medicare," Borrelli said, naming the federal health insurance program for adults 65 and older. "It's that simple."

Borrelli worries about the potential consequences. She suffers from chronic bronchitis and arthritis. She's also allergic to insect bites. Last year, she needed steroid shots five times.

"I'm going to gamble with my life," Borrelli said. "Hopefully, I won't get critically ill."

Peterson, the mother of three from Kenneth City, isn't willing to go without coverage. "If I'm not healthy, I can't take care of my kids," she said.

She could switch to a plan with lower premiums, but that could be more expensive over the long run. She chose her current plan — a "platinum" plan with a $468 monthly premium — because there is no deductible, and she is prone to injuries and long bouts of bronchitis.

The family budget is already tight. Peterson and her daughters are moving into a townhouse because their single-family home is in foreclosure.

• • •

President Barack Obama is predicting the Supreme Court will uphold the law.

"For years what we've heard is the biggest problem on the bench was judicial activism or the lack of judicial restraint, that an unelected group of people would somehow overturn a duly constituted and passed law," he said this week. "Well, there's a good example, and I'm pretty confident that this court will recognize that and not take that step."

If he's wrong, lawmakers will have the chance to intervene.

Congress could tweak the health law to allow subsidies in every state. But the Republican-led House, which has voted more than 50 times to repeal or water down the law, seems unlikely to take any action that would strengthen it.

Haislmaier, of the Heritage Foundation, sees a chance for Congress to remove some of the law's mandates, including the so-called age-rating restrictions that place limitations on premium differences by age. Doing so could reduce annual premiums for Floridians to the tune of $1,241 for a 21-year-old and $650 for a 64-year-old, according to a foundation analysis.

The state Legislature could also take action.

Florida already has a state-run exchange for private health insurance known as Florida Health Choices that enrolls about 80 people. State lawmakers could make the marketplace compliant with the Affordable Care Act, and in turn, make Floridans eligible for the subsidies.

A spokeswoman for Senate President Andy Gardiner, R-Orlando, said Gardiner would be "open to making (Florida Health Choices) the state's ACA exchange."

"Preserving and expanding access to affordable coverage options is a top priority for President Gardiner, so he will view the ruling and resulting impacts from that standpoint," Katie Betta said.

A spokesman for Republican House Speaker Steve Crisafulli would not speculate how the Legislature would respond to the Supreme Court ruling. It is no secret, however, that the House opposes the politically charged health care law. House leaders torpedoed recent efforts to expand Medicaid by tying the plan to Obamacare.

Republican Gov. Rick Scott declined to answer questions from the Tampa Bay Times. He, too, has been a vocal opponent of Obamacare. In an op-ed published in Politico Magazine in March, Scott said state-run exchanges were "collapsing under their own weight throughout the country."

Peterson hopes it doesn't come to a legislative fight.

"It's scary what could happen," she said. "I hope (the Supreme Court justices) take all the information, look at the facts and make the right decision."

Contact Kathleen McGrory at [email protected] or (727) 893-8330. Follow @kmcgrory.

Health care by

the numbers

The Affordable Care Act provides subsidies to help low-income people afford the cost of health insurance. Here's how the numbers break down in Florida:

1.4m Floridians enrolled in Obamacare

1.3m Floridians receiving subsidies

$294 Average monthly subsidy in Florida (March 2015)

$382m The total amount of federal money used to help Floridians buy health insurance in March

Source: U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services

Subsidies in states

If the U.S. Supreme Court strikes down health insurance subsidies this month, these states would see the largest number of residents lose their financial aid:

Florida: 1.3 million

Texas: 832,334

North Carolina: 458,738

Georgia: 412,385

Pennsylvania: 348,823

Source: U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services

High court ruling against Obamacare would put pressure on Florida families, lawmakers 06/12/15 [Last modified: Friday, June 12, 2015 8:53pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Empire' star Grace Byers keynotes USF Women in Leadership & Philanthropy luncheon

    Human Interest


    TAMPA — The first University of South Florida graduate to address the USF's Women in Leadership & Philanthropy supporters, Grace Gealey Byers, class of 2006, centered her speech on her first name, turning it into a verb to share life lessons.

    Grace Byers, University of South Florida Class of 2006, stars on the Fox television show Empire. She delivered the keynote at the USF Women in Leadership and Philanthropy luncheon Friday. Photo by Amy Scherzer
  2. Southeast Seminole Heights holds candlelight vigil for victims' families and each other


    TAMPA — They came together in solidarity in Southeast Seminole Heights, to sustain three families in their grief and to confront fear, at a candlelight vigil held Sunday night in the central Tampa neighborhood.

    A peaceful march that began on east New Orleans Avenue was held during the candlelight vigil for the three victims who were killed in the recent shootings in the Seminole Heights neighborhood in Tampa on Sunday, October 22, 2017.
  3. It's not just Puerto Rico: FEMA bogs down in Florida, Texas too

    HOUSTON — Outside Rachel Roberts' house, a skeleton sits on a chair next to the driveway, a skeleton child on its lap, an empty cup in its hand and a sign at its feet that reads "Waiting on FEMA."

    Ernestino Leon sits among the debris removed from his family’s flood-damaged Bonita Springs home on Oct. 11. He has waited five weeks for FEMA to provide $10,000 to repair the home.
  4. McConnell says he's awaiting Trump guidance on health care

    STERLING, Va. — Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said Sunday he's willing to bring bipartisan health care legislation to the floor if President Donald Trump makes clear he supports it.

    Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says he’s “not certain yet” on what Trump wants.
  5. Tampa's Lance McCullers shows killer instinct in pitching Astros to World Series


    HOUSTON — It felt like the beginning on Saturday night at Minute Maid Park, the arrival of a new force on the World Series stage. The Astros are back, for the first time in a dozen years, and they want to stay a while.

    Houston Astros starting pitcher Lance McCullers (43) throwing in the fifth inning of the game between the Houston Astros and the Tampa Bay Rays in Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Fla. on Sunday, July 12, 2015.