Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Is it child abuse if your youngster gets obese?

Marla Richter comes from, to use her term, a "fat family." Her mom was fat, as are her kids and most of her grandkids. So a recent case hit home: A 219-pound Cleveland third-grader was taken from his mother by child welfare officials, in part, because of his obesity hit home. • Richter, 61, of Corinth, Texas, says a 13-year-old relative who weighs more than 200 pounds saw a news report on the case and immediately tried to nix an upcoming medical appointment. "I'm not going to the doctor now," Richter quoted the girl as saying. "No way. I'm not going to be taken away from my mother."

Cases of children being temporarily taken from their homes due to obesity-related concerns remain extremely rare. In Florida, the Department of Children and Families has stepped in when parents fail to provide adequate medical care for their children. But children have never been removed from their homes due to weight issues, said agency spokeswoman Erin Gillespie.

Still, the Ohio case has fanned concern among obese kids, their relatives and their advocates.

"I see our freedom being stripped from us more and more every day, so I don't really see (removing kids) as so outrageous that it's not a real possibility," says Peggy Howell, a spokeswoman for the National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance. "We don't even have enough foster parents as it is in this country, so what are we going to do? Create fat concentration camps that we're going to put these children in?"

A handful of influential doctors have come forward in recent years to discuss the possibility of temporarily removing extremely obese kids from their homes. But that discussion has generally been extremely cautious and moderate, with an emphasis on a very small subset of very obese kids who face severe and immediate health risks because of their weight.

A high risk of developing diabetes as an adult, for instance, wouldn't meet the standard outlined in a 2009 article in the journal Pediatrics. A respiratory condition that could lead to death in a matter of days, on the other hand, very well could.

"These are extraordinarily unusual situations," says David Allen, a professor of pediatrics at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and a co-author of the Pediatrics study.

Allen and his co-authors wrote that removal of a child from his home could be justified, but only if the child faced a high risk of serious and immediate harm. Mere obesity, however severe, would not meet the standard. Plus, there would need to be effective treatment available for the child, and all other alternatives to removal would have to be exhausted.

Advocates object that the vast majority of people who lose a large amount of weight gain it back, making all obesity treatment ineffective in the long run; that claim is backed by numerous scientific studies. But Allen says kids are different, because parents and other adults really can control their calorie intake and exercise. He pointed to group homes where children with genetic syndromes that lead to obesity have lost weight.

In the Cleveland case, Allen said, news reports haven't provided a lot of detail, but it appears that child welfare workers made substantial efforts to help the family of the 8-year-old honor student who lost and then rapidly regained weight.

Fat rights advocates, however, see the Cleveland case as part of a broader threat to the well-being of fat people and their families.

"Most people I've talked to are disgusted. They think about the emotional toll it takes on the child, the parents and the other children (in the family)," says Richter.

"I have a friend who's thin, her husband is thin, her girls are thin, but she has this chubby little boy. She says, 'He eats just like we do. What are we supposed to do? Are they going to come and take him away from me?'"

Times staff writer Irene Maher contributed to this report.

Dr. Pallavi Iyer, a pediatric endocrinologist at All Children's Hospital in St. Petersburg, specializes in helping obese children and their families. We talked to her about the controversy.

Is a child's weight a reason to call the authorities and report abuse?

There is a precedent already for reporting kids and removing them from families where they have failure to thrive — they don't gain adequate weight or height for their age or if we believe they aren't getting sufficient love or food. That can be dangerous and stunt their growth. But there's not much precedent on the other side of the issue for kids who are obese ... If the child is the victim of abuse or neglect, or the child's safety is in danger, of course, we would report that. (But) just being overweight isn't reason enough to remove a child from the home.

Could putting an obese child in a new environment even temporarily help deal with the weight problem?

Taking the child away doesn't resolve the family issues that led to the obesity. You have to work on the whole family. Everyone has to be willing to change, not just the child.

So many kids are big these days. Why are doctors so concerned about obese children?

Left untreated obesity can lead to heart problems, high blood pressure, diabetes, joint problems, psycho-social issues. That's why we speak with (parents) when we are concerned, give them useful recommendations that are realistic for that family and help them find a solution.

How do parents react when you tell them they need to help their child lose weight?

I speak with families routinely about their children who have weight problems. That's why they come to see us, to be evaluated for metabolic or endocrine disorders that could be causing weight gain. Most families are receptive to guidance, especially if you tell them that it's not about how your child looks, it's about preventing serious health problems. Families get that.

Are there some kids who simply can't lose weight, no matter what you try?

Only in rare cases will a child remain obese despite their best efforts to lose weight. There are genetic conditions that can prevent weight loss, but that is extremely rare. There's always something that you can do, something you can change with diet and exercise, to lose weight. We explain that there are certain people who hold on to food differently than others. You may be more at risk, but that doesn't mean you can't change it.

Is it child abuse if your youngster gets obese? 01/04/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, January 4, 2012 4:56pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Navy parachutist dies during demonstration over Hudson River


    JERSEY CITY, N.J. — In the shadow of the Statue of Liberty, a Navy Seal team member fell to his death Sunday after his parachute failed to open during a Fleet Week demonstration over the Hudson River.

    Officials surround a U.S. Navy Seal's parachute that landed in a parking lot after the parachutist fell into the Hudson River when his parachute failed to open during a Fleet Week demonstration over the river in Jersey City, N.J. The Navy said the parachutist was pronounced dead at Jersey City Medical Center. [Joe Shine | Jersey Journal via AP]
  2. As White House defends Jared Kushner, experts question his alleged back-channel move


    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration argued over the weekend that back-channel communications are acceptable in building dialogue with foreign governments, part of an effort to minimize fallout over White House adviser Jared Kushner's reported discussion about creating a secret conduit to the Kremlin at a Russian …

    President-elect Donald Trump embraces son in law Jared Kushner, as his daughter Ivanka Trump stands nearby, after his acceptance speech at the New York Hilton Midtown in the early morning hours of Nov. 9. [Mark Wilson | Getty Images]
  3. Sunstar ambulance unit overturns at Drew Street intersection in Clearwater, prompts road closures


    The intersection of Drew Street and Fort Harrison Avenue in Clearwater is closed following a crash that involved a Sunstar ambulance unit, according to the Clearwater Police Department.

    A Sunstar unit flipped in the intersection of Drew Street and Ford Harrison Avenue in Clearwater Monday morning after a car reportedly ran a red light and struck the ambulance, according to the Clearwater Police Department.
  4. Merkel spokesman: Germany still seeking stronger U.S. ties


    BERLIN — Berlin remains committed to strong trans-Atlantic relations, but Chancellor Angela Merkel's suggestion after meetings with President Donald Trump that Europe can no longer entirely rely on the U.S. "speaks for itself," her spokesman said Monday

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel delivers a speech during an election campaign of her Christian Democratic Union, CDU, and the Christian Social Union, CSU, in Munich, southern Germany, Sunday. Merkel is urging European Union nations to stick together in the face of new uncertainty over the United States and other challenges. [Matthias Balk/dpa via AP]
  5. Tampa police: 46 arrests, 47 ejections at two-day Sunset Music Festival

    Public Safety

    Times staff

    TAMPA — In a preliminary tally Monday morning, police declared there were "no major incidents" during the two-day Sunset Music Festival at Raymond James Stadium but boosted the number of arrests and rejections they provided in earlier reports during the weekend.

    A Tampa Fire Rescue all-terrain vehicle patrols the parking area north of Raymond James Stadum on Sunday, day two of the Sunset Music Festival. [LUIS SANTANA   |   Times]