Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge says Tampa Bay trauma hospitals will lose more money if HCA expansion is approved

The hospitals that treat the Tampa Bay area's most critically injured patients are struggling financially — and their plight could rapidly worsen if the HCA hospital chain opens competing trauma centers under a partnership with the University of South Florida.

That's the word from a Tallahassee judge, who last week sided with three bay area hospitals seeking to stop a plan to open a network of new trauma centers in the state, including one at Pasco County's Regional Medical Center Bayonet Point.

State health officials, who are reviewing HCA's applications, said Wednesday they plan to appeal the judge's decision.

Tampa General Hospital, Bayfront Medical Center and St. Joseph's Hospital led the legal challenge to the HCA-USF trauma centers. They say there simply isn't enough business for so many costly facilities that are staffed and equipped to deal with the most severe injuries. Beyond the revenue that is at stake, they argue that trauma surgeons and other staff must stay busy to maintain quality.

"A community filled with trauma centers caring for too few patients is not good for anyone, especially the patients," said Bayfront spokeswoman Kanika Tomalin. The hospital's priority "is all about patient care and preserving a level of volume that's a prerequisite to a trauma center's success."

Even without added competition, fewer people need trauma care these days, possibly because of a decline in auto accidents.

HCA's plan calls for new centers in Pasco and Manatee counties that would draw more business away from the existing Tampa Bay trauma centers. All three said in the court case that they already are losing millions of dollars in trauma care.

With added competition from HCA, the court ruling indicates, Bayfront could stand to lose 669 patients based on 2010 numbers — 42 percent of that year's volume. That would cost the hospital more than $2.3 million a year, and it already is struggling to stem operating losses.

In recent years, the court noted, Bayfront has deferred building projects due to finances, and last year posted an operating margin of less than 1 percent.

Tampa General at best is expecting to break even this year, and may even lose $4 million in operations, according to the ruling, which had less detail about St. Joseph's overall finances.

Nearly a year ago, USF made a public announcement that it was joining with for-profit HCA to run the proposed centers.

This summer, Bayfront, TGH and St. Joseph's joined with another trauma hospital, Shands Jacksonville Medical Center, to challenge a 1992 state administrative rule that could be used to approve the HCA plan.

After a hearing, Tallahassee administrative court Judge W. David Watkins declared that the rule is outdated. He said it fails to take into account factors including advancements such as more helicopters to fly trauma patients farther and advanced life support capabilities in ambulances.

In 2005, a statewide analysis led by USF investigators determined that "Tampa Bay has adequate trauma center access." But it and other recent research were never incorporated into the state's approval process.

State Surgeon General Dr. Frank Farmer said Wednesday his agency will appeal the judge's decision. And HCA, the hospital chain formerly headed by Gov. Rick Scott, vowed to fight for its new trauma centers.

"We remain committed to improving access to quality trauma care to the citizens of Florida who live in underserved areas of the state," spokeswoman Ginger Mace said in a statement.

USF spokesman Michael Hoad said the university "wasn't a party to the suit and won't be in the future, so it would be inappropriate to comment about a legal issue between other people."

TGH is the main teaching hospital of USF, which plans to run the HCA trauma centers independent of the Tampa hospital.

Times researcher Shirl Kennedy contributed to this report.

How much they lost

The court ruling said Tampa Bay trauma hospitals all lost money on the costly programs in 2010.

Tampa General

$15.7 million


$3 million

St. Joseph's

$8.3 million

Judge says Tampa Bay trauma hospitals will lose more money if HCA expansion is approved 09/28/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, September 28, 2011 11:47pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. No. 21 USF Bulls roll over Temple to stay undefeated


    TAMPA — They emerged from Raymond James Stadium's southwest tunnel on the 11-month anniversary of their public humiliation at Temple.

    Bulls tailback Darius Tice, who rushes for 117 yards, is elated by his 47-yard run for a touchdown in the second quarter for a 10-0 lead.
  2. Fennelly: USF thrashes Temple to stay unbeaten; too bad not many saw it in person



    No. 21 USF ran its record to 4-0 Thursday night with some payback against Temple, a 43-7 trouncing, no contest, as if anyone cares, at least judging by the paltry crowd at Raymond James Stadium. Where was everybody?

    Bulls cornerback Deatrick Nichols (3) celebrates with teammates after making a defensive play during the first half.
  3. Former Ray Tim Beckham's over being traded, or is he?

    The Heater

    BALTIMORE — As the Rays reunited Thursday with Tim Beckham for the first time since he was dealt July 31 to Baltimore, it became very clear that not everything in assessing the trade is as it appears.

    Tim Beckham, here in action Monday against the Red Sox, has hit .310, with 10 homers and 26 RBIs since going to the Orioles.
  4. Bucs probe how to fix deep-ball chances missed vs. Bears


    TAMPA — It was only minutes after the Bucs had demolished the Bears 29-7 Sunday when quarterback Jameis Winston tried one final time to connect with receiver DeSean Jackson.

    QB Jameis Winston says he’s focused on the deep-ball chances to DeSean Jackson he missed in the opener: “We left a lot out there.”
  5. Rays journal: Ugly first inning dooms Andriese, Rays against Orioles (w/video)

    The Heater

    BALTIMORE — Rays manager Kevin Cash said before Thursday's game that RHP Matt Andriese was among the pitchers who would most benefit from a strong finish to the season.

    Matt Andriese has a tough first: hits to four of first five batters, leading to three runs, the only ones he gives up in six innings