Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pregnant woman's involuntary hospitalization raises legal, ethical, medical questions

The case of a pregnant Florida woman hospitalized against her will is raising a legal, ethical and medical storm around this issue: Can a doctor's order to quit smoking and rest in bed trump a woman's right to control her own body?

In a Tallahassee court ruling, the answer was yes.

Now under appeal, the highly unusual case is attracting widespread attention months after the baby in question was delivered stillborn by caesarean section. Samantha Burton, the mother, is appealing the judge's order that forced her to stay at Tallahassee Memorial Hospital. Her lawyer says she's not interested in money, but hopes to keep her case from setting a precedent for other women with troubled pregnancies.

"The entire experience was horrible and I am still very upset about it," Burton said through her lawyer. "I hope nobody else has to go through what I went through."

Experts in medical ethics say the case could have broad significance for personal health decisions of all kinds. Implications for the polarizing debate over when human life begins are the most controversial aspect of it.

"If a mother or father were doing something that directly endangered a child, everybody would agree that they should be stopped," said Kenneth Goodman, director of the Bioethics Program at the University of Miami and the Florida Bioethics Network. "(But) we do all sorts of things that endanger our sperm cells, our egg cells, and our fetuses."

As abortion is legal, he said, "then the lesson drawn is, 'Back off: Women have a responsibility to control their own bodies.' "

In a phone conference between a Tallahassee hospital room and a judge's office, a different conclusion was reached last spring.

Judge orders woman to stay in hospital

Burton checked into the hospital in March for what appeared to be premature labor. She was 29, in her 25th week of pregnancy. A couple of days later, Burton's doctor came into her private room, along with attorneys for the hospital. One of them carried a phone. According to the lawyer Burton later retained, she soon was talking to a Leon Circuit Court judge on the other line.

Burton, who was dissatisfied with her doctor and the hospital, asked to go elsewhere for care.

But Judge John C. Cooper ordered her to stay. In the ruling, he said the state has a right "to ensure that children receive medical treatment which is necessary for the preservation of life and health."

"As both a nurse and an attorney, I was stunned," said David Abrams, who heard about the case later and is representing Burton pro bono.

"Does the state own the inside of a woman's womb, that it can kind of intervene at will?"

He said that while Burton, who has two children, did smoke some, she was not a heavy smoker and had prenatal care.

According to legal precedents, Abrams said, doctors should have determined if the fetus was "viable," or could survive outside of the womb without medical heroics. There also should have been a second opinion, he said.

The doctor and the hospital referred questions to state attorney Willie Meggs, who sought the court order after the hospital contacted him.

"Sometimes there is not time for two doctors," Meggs said. "It's not time for a committee."

As it turned out, the baby was delivered stillborn a few days after the ruling.

Professor is reminded of the Schiavo case

Dr. Catherine Lynch, an obstetrician and interim chairwoman for Women's Health at the University of South Florida, said she has never used such a court order. But, she said, it can be a balancing act to serve both mother and fetus.

"It's a very gray zone in terms of, at what point do you actually … do something for the baby when it's against mom's wishes?" she said.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists frowns on such legal sanctions, as they could discourage women from seeking health care.

Mother vs. fetus cases can become "a proxy for the abortion issue,'' said Dr. Sharon Phelan, an obstetrician at the University of New Mexico and spokeswoman for the organization. "Does a woman's life have to be totally controlled by Big Brother, or by a third party, for what they think is best for that pregnancy without any consideration or input by the woman?"

In the legal issues involved, USF public health and medicine professor Jay Wolfson sees shades of a right-to-life court case that riveted the nation — that of Terri Schiavo, the Pinellas County woman who spent years on life support.

"This is a very serious case because it goes right back to Roe vs. Wade, Schiavo, right to life," said Wolfson, who was Schiavo's court-appointed guardian. "And whether a woman has control of dominion not only over her body, but over the fetus and child that resides within her."

For Meggs, it's more straightforward. "This is good people trying to do things in a right fashion to save lives, whether some people want them saved or not."

A three-judge panel of Florida's 1st District Court of Appeal heard oral arguments this month but has not indicated when it will rule.

Information from the Associated Press was used in this report. Letitia Stein can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 226-3322.

Pregnant woman's involuntary hospitalization raises legal, ethical, medical questions 01/26/10 [Last modified: Wednesday, January 27, 2010 11:45am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. No. 16 USF hangs on at Tulane, off to first 7-0 start


    NEW ORLEANS — After half a season of mismatches, USF found itself in a grudge match Saturday night.

    USF quarterback Quinton Flowers (9) runs for a touchdown against Tulane during the first half of an NCAA college football game in New Orleans, La., Saturday, Oct. 21, 2017. (AP Photo/Derick E. Hingle) LADH103
  2. Lightning buries Penguins (w/video)

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — Ryan Callahan spent a lot of time last season rehabilitating his injured hip alongside Steven Stamkos, who was rehabbing a knee after season-ending surgery. During those hours, Callahan noticed two things about Stamkos: his hunger and his excitement to return this season.

    Tampa Bay Lightning defenseman Slater Koekkoek (29) advances the puck through the neutral zone during the first period of Saturday???‚??„?s (10/21/17) game between the Tampa Bay Lightning and the Pittsburgh Penguins at Amalie Arena in Tampa.
  3. Spain planning to strip Catalonia of its autonomy


    BARCELONA, Spain — The escalating confrontation over Catalonia's independence drive took its most serious turn Saturday as Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy of Spain announced he would remove the leadership of the restive region and initiate a process of direct rule by the central government in Madrid.

    Demonstrators in Barcelona protest the decision to take control of Catalonia to derail the independence movement.
  4. Funeral held for soldier at center of political war of words (w/video)


    COOPER CITY — Mourners remembered not only a U.S. soldier whose combat death in Africa led to a political fight between President Donald Trump and a Florida congresswoman but his three comrades who died with him.

    The casket of Sgt. La David T. Johnson of Miami Gardens, who was killed in an ambush in Niger. is wheeled out after a viewing at the Christ The Rock Church, Friday, Oct. 20, 2017  in Cooper City, Fla. (Pedro Portal/Miami Herald via AP) FLMIH102
  5. Chemical industry insider now shapes EPA policy


    WASHINGTON — For years, the Environmental Protection Agency has struggled to prevent an ingredient once used in stain-resistant carpets and nonstick pans from contaminating drinking water.

    This is the Dow chemical plant near Freeport, Texas. Before the 2016 election, Dow had been in talks with the EPA to phase out the pesticide chlorpyrifos, which is blamed for disabilities in children. Dow is no longer willing to compromise.