Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Riata defibrillator problems worry patients, doctors

TAMPA — In 2005, Kevin Fountain had surgery intended to ease fears that his damaged heart might beat irregularly.

Surgeons implanted in his chest a cellphone-sized device to deliver a shock and correct the problem. But late last year that defibrillator — specifically, the lead that connects it to his heart — became a source of anxiety, not reassurance.

The 53-year-old Tampa man is among patients told they might have a defective lead in their chests. The news left them with more questions than answers.

"It looked kind of funny," Fountain recalled of seeing his defibrillator on an imaging scan. "I could see the wires sticking out."

His wife reacted more strongly.

"My thought was, 'Oh my God,' " said Carol Johnson, 44. "You put it in to save people's lives and then it's coming apart."

Fountain's lead was made by St. Jude Medical, and is known as the Riata. According to the company, the Riata was placed in 128,000 heart patients, children and adults, worldwide between 2001 and 2010. In 2010, the company voluntarily stopped making it after numerous reports of externalization — when the lead's outer covering breaks down, exposing interior wires and giving the frayed appearance Fountain saw.

St. Jude estimates that 24 percent of its larger Riata leads and 9 percent of its smaller leads developed the problem.

In 2011, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration recommended that all patients with a Riata be screened, though St. Jude advised against it because it wasn't clear that externalization was dangerous and might lead people to unnecessarily undergo removal surgery. Removal can be difficult and carries its own dangers.

The problem is being studied by the company and independent researchers. A large group of physicians met in January at a summit organized by the Mayo Clinic and the Minneapolis Heart Institute to share information. But in the meantime there's no clear protocol to follow.

Sanders Chae is a USF Health cardiac electrophysiologist, a physician who specializes in implanted electrical devices for the heart. Fountain is among his patients facing this decision.

"With the Riata, there's no clear data to show the exposed wires are harmful, so it's unclear what the effect can be," said Chae. "It's unclear what to do."

Patients face questions their specialists can't answer fully. Do they get screened to see if the lead is damaged? Do they have it removed whether or not damage is seen? Do they leave it in place and hope that careful monitoring by their doctor will catch a problem before it kills them?

Adding to the worry: In some patients, the Riata replaced another lead, made by the Medtronic Corp., that failed, in some cases misfiring and shocking patients.

In a letter to patients posted on the company website, St. Jude says even if the outer layer is frayed, the lead will still do its job. It analyzed faulty leads removed from patients and found 87 percent had no electrical problems. The rest had electrical abnormalities but only 2 percent were caused by externalization.

"The (exposed wires or) conductors have another layer of insulation on them, it's not bare wire. They are still insulated and perform normally in the majority of cases," said Dr. Mark Carlson, a cardiac electrophysiologist with St. Jude Medical.

The company says no one has died as a result of lead failure or malfunction but there were two deaths and one serious injury associated with removal of externalized leads.

But published studies suggest Riata leads may be more dangerous than the company says.

"Whether Riata leads with externalized conductors truly perform normally is not known,'' said Vanderbilt University electrophysiologist Christopher R. Ellis, who was among the experts at the Minneapolis summit. He pointed to a study published just last month in the journal Heart Rhythm that "sheds doubt on long term Riata performance.''

Chae says most of his patients who have the Riata want it removed.

Dr. James Irwin, a cardiac electrophysiologist at St Joseph's Hospital in Tampa, has one patient with a Riata she received elsewhere that shows signs of externalization, but she has another illness that makes surgery even more dangerous.

Otherwise, he said, "I would recommend removal,'' said Irwin, who has never used the Riata. "We look at what leads last longer and, if they fail, how difficult it is to remove. The Riata is more difficult to remove. So, I never used it for that reason."

Chae and his USF colleagues have seen an increase in patients seeking removal or guidance on what to do. The longer a lead is in place, the more scar tissue forms, and the tougher it can be to remove.

With his battery due for replacement soon, Fountain elected to have his defibrillator and faulty lead changed in December. His wife insisted.

"He thought I was over-reacting but, it was scary for me," said Johnson, "If it would have stopped working and something happened with his heart, then what?

Irene Maher can be reached at

Riata defibrillator problems worry patients, doctors 03/13/13 [Last modified: Wednesday, March 13, 2013 11:31pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Bucs journal: Kicker Nick Folk has up and downs against Jaguars


    JACKSONVILLE — If the Bucs had hoped for a drama-free night in their kicking game, they'll have to wait another week.

    Bucs kicker Nick Folk celebrates one of his two made field goals against the Jaguars, but he also misses a field goal and has an extra point blocked.
  2. Late night update: Second wave follows Tropical Storm Harvey


    UPDATE: At 11 p.m. the National Hurricane Center said a hurricane hunter plane had determined that Tropical Storm Harvey had formed with sustained winds of 40 mph.

    Three tropical waves are expected to strengthen as they move across the Atlantic Ocean. [Courtesy of the National Hurricane Center]
  3. Stealth anti-Jack Latvala group tied to Adam Putnam campaign


    Politico reports:

     A longtime political consultant for Republican gubernatorial candidate Adam Putnam is behind a website calling one of his rivals in the race, state Sen. Jack Latvala, a “liberal.”

  4. Council gives in to pension dispute with St. Pete firefighters

    Local Government

    ST. PETERSBURG — The City Council was forced to consider its first labor dispute in years Thursday when it gave the firefighters union most of the pension enhancements it has long asked for.

    The firefighters’ union won a pension victory at Thursday’s City Council meeting. [SCOTT KEELER    |      TIMES]
  5. Bucs top Jaguars behind strong first half



    There is a reason why the air in Tampa Bay is filled with playoff talk. If Thursday night's 12-8 Bucs preseason win over the Jaguars is any indication, it's also going to be filled with footballs thrown by quarterback Jameis Winston.

    Doug Martin gets the Bucs’ only touchdown  on a 2-yard run, squeaking past linebacker Telvin Smith in the first quarter. He has five carries for 30 yards.