Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

The Affordable Care Act: Know the facts and make up your own mind

The Supreme Court next week hears arguments for and against the Affordable Care Act. Did you know that the act would ban “gender rating” by insurers? Know the facts, then make up your own mind.

Associated Press

The Supreme Court next week hears arguments for and against the Affordable Care Act. Did you know that the act would ban “gender rating” by insurers? Know the facts, then make up your own mind.

It's an election year, so people who like polls, statistics and fun facts are in our glory.

Lovers of clarity, however, may not be having such a good time.

Consider a new Harris Poll that tried to find out how Americans feel about various laws and policies that are supposed to protect us. Here are some highlights:

• 91 percent support a ban on texting while driving.

• 78 percent support requiring restaurants to post nutrition information on menus.

• 86 percent support requiring the regular round of childhood vaccinations.

• 80 percent support banning smoking in public places.

• 76 percent oppose employers citing obesity as a reason not to hire.

• 62 percent oppose taxing sugar-sweetened soft drinks.

Here's the kicker: More than three-quarters agree that such public health initiatives work. Yet 61 percent fear they may impede individual freedoms.

"The public is somewhat schizophrenic about laws and policies that are intended to improve health and safety and reduce injuries and accidents," said Humphrey Taylor, chairman of the Harris Poll.

Schizophrenic? No, I don't think it's crazy to resist help, even when you know you need it. Any kid whose mom makes him come home when it's getting dark out knows this. Sure, he'll whine, but he'd really be unhappy if mom left him outside all night.

These feelings aren't crazy, but they are complicated.

Balancing safety and freedom is no easy thing. We'll be hearing plenty about this next week as the U.S. Supreme Court hears arguments for and against the Affordable Care Act.

Florida is leading the 26 states opposing the law, mostly over the requirement that everyone have insurance, and I'm sure that plenty of citizens are glad about this.

But it's also worth considering that freedom to buy your own insurance might be more meaningful with more official help in the form of tougher rules.

Did you know that women who buy individual insurance are charged far more than men? Now, this might seem logical because women do spend more on health care than men do. Most of the difference is because women: a) bear children; and b) live longer. So it's not because we're wimpy.

But most individual policies do not cover childbirth. And when we're old, we're on Medicare, so these policies don't care for us in our dotage. Yet a new report by the National Women's Law Center found that this "gender rating'' costs women about $1 billion a year.

Am I the only one who thinks this makes about as much sense as . . . texting while driving?

There are some states that forbid so-called gender-rating by insurers, but Florida is not among them. There are states that require maternity coverage in the individual market, but Florida is not among them.

The Affordable Care Act would ban gender rating by 2014, just one of many ways the law seeks to expand access to medical care. And it aims to spread the costs around by requiring everyone, even those who are healthy now, to have insurance.

Follow the news, read the law, make up your own mind. But don't let anyone call you schizophrenic if you don't come down squarely on one side or the other.

I suspect most of us are muddling around in the middle, seeking a compromise that respects freedom while helping those who need medical care. And that, eventually, is just about everyone.

Crazy? Not at all. Complicated? Definitely.

The Affordable Care Act: Know the facts and make up your own mind 03/23/12 [Last modified: Friday, March 23, 2012 11:34am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Florida football has become something to be endured, not enjoyed


    The Jim McElwain era at Florida is something to be endured, not enjoyed.

    Florida Gators defensive lineman Khairi Clark (54) leaves the field after the Florida Gators game against Texas A&M, at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium, in Gainesville, Fla. The Florida Gators lost to the Texas A&M Aggies 17-16 MONICA HERNDON   |   Times
  2. Who wants to trade? Hillsborough offers to swap land with Ybor-area property owners for potential Rays ballpark

    Real Estate

    TAMPA — Trades are common when assembling a professional baseball team. Apparently, they're also useful when assembling land for a professional ballpark.

    Aerial photo of Ybor City centered around Centro Ybor and 7th Avenue. Hoping to assemble the land for a ballpark near Ybor City and the Channel District, Hillsborough County officials could government property with landowners there. LUIS SANTANA   |   Times.
  3. Hurricane Irma thrashed Tampa Bay homes sales in September

    Real Estate

    Hurricane Irma not only downed thousands of trees throughout the Tampa Bay area: It also sent home sales plunging in September.

    This home on Tampa's Davis Islands home sold in September for $5.2 million, making it the priciest sale of the month in the Tampa Bay area.
[Courtesy of Judson Brady Photography]
  4. Cannon Fodder podcast: Most important stat in Bucs-Bills game


    Greg Auman talks about the uncertainty at quarterback for the Bucs as they go to Buffalo in his latest Cannon Fodder podcast.

    Interceptions, such as this one by Brent Grimes against Arizona, will be the most important stat in Sunday's game.
  5. Encounters: In the quiet of exam rooms, women have been saying 'Me too' for years

    Human Interest


    Meet her with her clothes on.

    Don't make her greet you in a paper gown, slits down the front and flimsy ties. Shake her hand, if she wants to, and introduce yourself. Pause between sentences. This will make it clear that you are listening; that you will listen, to whatever she has to say. Observe what …

     Pam Kelly, a gynecologist at Tampa General Hospital's Family Care Center at HealthPark, teaches future doctors at the University of South Florida how to identify and treat victims of sexual assault. Gabriella Angotti-Jones  | Times