Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Q&A: Should Joyce Kaufman statement be prosecuted as sedition?

Few prosecutions for sedition

Radio host Joyce Kaufman says to a crowd at a rally: "I am convinced the most important thing the Founding Fathers did to ensure me my First Amendment rights was they gave me a Second Amendment. And if ballots don't work, bullets will." Why is this not prosecuted as sedition?

Prosecutions for sedition, which is the crime of revolting or inciting revolt against the government, are very rare because the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech offers very broad protection.

In the case of Kaufman's statement, the government would have to consider: Does any perceived threat someone hears in her speech constitute a real danger, or is it just rhetoric? Do her statements create a clear and present danger to rights that the government protects? Is there any action associated with the perceived threat?

The courts have tightened laws enacted against sedition since the first one passed, in 1798, though they have declined to declare all such laws unconstitutional.

The most prominent recent case of sedition was successfully brought against Sheik Omar Abdel Rahman, a blind Egyptian cleric living in New Jersey, and nine others. They were convicting of seditious conspiracy by plotting crimes against the United States. Rahman was convicted and is serving a life sentence in North Carolina.

Kaufman is a right-wing radio talk show host in South Florida. She was going to serve as Republican Rep.-elect Allen West's chief of staff, but withdrew after the statement you cited in your question was reported.

She didn't apologize. Instead, she complained about being electronically "lynched" by the "liberal media."

It's not the first time her statements have drawn attention. In 2007 she suggested that illegal immigrants who committed crimes in the United States should be hanged, and she recently referred to Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., and former House Speaker, as "garbage."

Limiting political mudslinging

What prompted the inclusion of "and I approved this message" on federal election ads?

Attack ads became so numerous in the final four decades of the 20th century that the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act was passed in 2002. Its chief sponsors were Sen. Russell Feingold, D-Wis., and Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz.

It requires a statement from a candidate that identifies him or her and states that the candidate approved the message in an attempt to limit mudslinging in commercials. The candidate must appear on the screen or in a voice-over, accompanied by a clearly identifiable photographic or similar image of the candidate, according to the law.

For more information about the law's requirements, visit

Q&A: Should Joyce Kaufman statement be prosecuted as sedition? 11/29/10 [Last modified: Monday, November 29, 2010 6:41pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Hillary Clinton said her 'skin crawled' when Donald Trump stood behind her on debate stage


    In her most detailed public comments about what happened during the second presidential debate, Hillary Clinton said her "skin crawled" as Donald Trump loomed behind her on the stage in St. Louis last October.

    Hillary Clinton speaks as Donald Trump listens during the second presidential debate at Washington University in St. Louis on Oct. 9, 2016. In her upcoming book, Clinton says "It was incredibly uncomfortable. He was literally breathing down my neck. My skin crawled." [Pool photo by Rick T. Wilking via AP]
  2. After 17 years, Pasco-Hernando State College attorney steps away


    The longtime attorney for Pasco-Hernando State College has resigned for what he says are "purely personal reasons."

    Steve Schroeder, the general council for Pasco-Hernando State College, resigned last week. His last day will be Sept. 8.
  3. Apple Scales Back Its Ambitions for a Self-Driving Car


    SAN FRANCISCO — As new employees were brought into Apple's secret effort to create a self-driving car a few years ago, managers told them that they were working on the company's next big thing: A product that would take on Detroit and disrupt the automobile industry.

     In this Monday, April 10, 2017 file photo, Luminar CEO Austin Russell monitors a 3D lidar map on a demonstration drive in San Francisco. Russell, now 22, was barely old enough to drive when he set out to create a safer navigation system for robot-controlled cars. His ambitions are about to be tested five years after he co-founded Luminar Technologies, a Silicon Valley startup trying to steer the rapidly expanding self-driving car industry in a new direction. Apple says it will scale back its amitions to build a self-driving car.  [AP Photo/Ben Margot]
  4. Studies: Automated safety systems are preventing car crashes


    WASHINGTON — Safety systems to prevent cars from drifting into another lane or that warn drivers of vehicles in their blind spots are beginning to live up to their potential to significantly reduce crashes, according to two studies released Wednesday.

    A side mirror warning signal is shown in a Ford Taurus at an automobile testing area in Oxon Hill, Md., in 2012. Safety systems to prevent cars from drifting into another lane or warn drivers of vehicles in their blind spots are beginning to live up to their potential to significantly reduce crashes, according to two studies released Wednesday, Aug. 23, 2017. [Associated Press]
  5. Pet Vet: Why a cat's color can make it more susceptible to skin cancer


    Snowball is a fluffy female cat 10 years of age. Can you guess what color she might be? I ask the question because it is relevant to what might be causing her problem.

    White fluffy cat  [Dreamstime | TNS]