Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Sand Key dissolving into civil war over Civic Association's disagreements

CLEARWATER — The first casualty of the Sand Key Civic Association's civil war fell during a secret meeting, hurriedly assembled Monday morning at a tony condominium tower.

The association's nine-member board, ruled by an alliance of five, had called a rare executive session, sealing doors against the media. Members emerged at noon having expelled one of their own: Dorie Platz, a vocal critic of the group that detractors call the Gang of Five.

The board's leaders said the cause for Platz's removal was confidential. But detractors say Platz's resistance to the board's majority had hastened her demise. One of the charges against Platz, board member Peggy Dagostino recalled: "She doesn't act like a lady."

The civic club of Sand Key, one of Clearwater's wealthiest neighborhoods, has descended into battle, with neighbors on this island enclave severing friendships and calling police.

Members past and present accuse the alliance of staging a coup through shifty politicking and secretive power plays, aimed at pushing through reforms of the Civic Association's constitution.

Opponents say the alliance's aim is to transform this neighborhood group into an arm of legal force, driven by personal interests and empowered by a $200,000 "war chest."

However, the group's embattled leadership calls these claims misinformation. Board member Cynthia Remley said changes to the group's founding bylaws were only aimed at better defending the island and protecting its way of life, much as the group's "courageous activist founders intended it to be when they created it 21 years ago."

Dubbed a "condo canyon" for the coastal towers that line its two-lane road, the mile-long community of Sand Key has long been seen by local politicos as more insular and traditional than its tourist-targeting northern neighbor, Clearwater Beach.

With 30 condo complexes and more than 3,000 members, the Civic Association has helped protect that reputation through legal might: funding opposition against redevelopment, taking up legal arms against a zip-line course and even considering seceding from the city, an "Islands Independence Initiative" that divided its membership and ultimately failed.

That rift — between members seeking a social club and the so-called "condo commanders" — lies at the center of the current conflict, which began in January when a newly elected board created a committee for bylaw review.

That committee returned with sudden changes that former board member Don Van Weezel called a "radical departure" from the bylaws, including the creation of a reserve account that would be declared fully funded once it reached $200,000.

Funded by a third of the group's $70,000 treasury and half of future dues, the account could help pay for experts, accountants and legal advice, said Remley, a business attorney. In three years, the group and its members had spent $170,000 on lawyers, planners and appraisers alone.

But the changes, opponents said, were covertly designed and rushed to approval last month, ignoring members' dissent. Some, like former president Gene Gillespie, suspected the changes had "sinister" motives: Remley, who lives near a site of potential development, could draw from the "super litigation fund" as a way to protect her water view.

Cue angry emails, retiree saber-rattling and mid-meeting cries of "You're out of order!" Saying they had no way to repeal the changes, board members opposed to the Gang of Five declared themselves disenfranchised in the face of unstoppable 5-4 votes. The alliance "got carried away with the power," said board member Dagostino.

Some members resorted to desperate measures to express their discontent. At a meeting last month at the Clearwater Community Sailing Center, Platz staged a sit-in, blocking the closet holding the bylaw committee's table. Chairman Dick Jackson called police to break up the disturbance; no one was arrested. ("I'm a policeman from New York City," Platz recalled the officer saying. "I don't know how to handle this.")

At a tense three-hour meeting Wednesday, the chairman likened rumors fueling the escalating conflict to "a game of Telephone: you don't know what you're going to hear next." Rumors of the account slammed as a "slush fund" had been especially overblown, Jackson added: "The mountain gave birth to a mouse."

The war appears far from armistice. Some members hope to vote in new board candidates at their next election in December — or, failing that, lead a schism from the group that could sever ties for good.

Platz, whose empty seat on the board has yet to be filled, said the civil war has raged so fiercely due to Sand Key residents' passion for the island, albeit sometimes misdirected. Though she said it hurt to even consider, she expects the rift could lead to the group's unpleasant end.

"Will it stay like that? Heck no. It'll be a phoenix," Platz said. "It's going to burn to the ground. But when the whole of Sand Key unites, that is when we will rise from the ashes."

Contact Drew Harwell at (727) 445-4170 or Send letters to the editor at

Sand Key dissolving into civil war over Civic Association's disagreements 05/03/12 [Last modified: Thursday, May 3, 2012 8:13pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. What to watch this weekend: 'The Last Tycoon,' 'Room 104,' 'Rick and Morty'


    Checking in: Room 104

    Listen up, fans of Hitchcock and American Horror Story. Room 104 might be your next obsession. With a premise that feels experimental, Room 104 explores one of film's most traditional styles - telling a story from the inside of just one room. The HBO series is from …

    Each episode of Room 104 follows the guests of a single motel rom and the strange and wonderful things they experience.
  2. Rubio: I intend to keep campaign promises on Obamacare


    WASHINGTON - Sen. Marco Rubio says he remains committed to overturning Obamacare following the collapse of the latest attempt.

  3. Family spokeswoman: British baby Charlie Gard has died


    LONDON — Charlie Gard, the critically ill British baby at the center of a legal battle that attracted the attention of Pope Francis and U.S. President Donald Trump, has died. He would have turned 1 next week.

    This is an undated photo of sick baby Charlie Gard provided by his family, taken at Great Ormond Street Hospital in London. [Family of Charlie Gard via AP]
  4. Editorial: Here's one way Florida courts can measure a quality education


    The question before the 1st District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee is whether Florida is following its constitutional duty to provide a high-quality education to public school students. The point was originally raised in a lawsuit brought by advocacy and parents groups and dismissed by a circuit judge in 2016. When it …

    The question before the 1st District Court of Appeal in Tallahassee is whether Florida is following its constitutional duty to provide a high-quality education to public school students.
  5. Paul Shanley, ex-priest in Boston sex abuse scandal, released from prison


    BOSTON — A notorious figure in Boston's Roman Catholic priest sex abuse scandal was quietly released from prison Friday morning after completing a 12-year sentence for the rape of a boy in the 1980s.

    This undated identification photo released via the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board website shows Paul Shanley, released Friday from the Old Colony Correctional Center in Bridgewater, Mass. Shanley, now 86, was a figure in the Boston Roman Catholic priest sex abuse scandal. He was released after completing a 12-year sentence for the rape of a boy in the 1980s. [Massachusetts Sex Offender Registry Board via AP]