Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Should we fork over cash to the "homeless"?

For me, it's the ones with the dogs.

I might roll down my window at a stoplight for a guy in a wheelchair, or someone with a witty sign about his naked need for beer like we're in on the joke together, or just hungry eyes looking at me through the windshield. But a homeless guy with a dog always gets me reaching for my wallet.

So what exactly am I contributing to?

A provocative story this week by Times reporter Lane DeGregory explored a more cynical side of some who panhandle our streets advertising themselves as disabled or veterans or homeless, the truth apparently being flexible. Some spoke of working shifts, of creating different signs for different audiences, of regularly making enough to stay in a motel — all of which could make a person who's usually ready to hand over a few bills think twice.

A lot of us already do. Panhandlers said drivers in Lexuses and Beemers don't give like people in sorrier cars, maybe because having your own life even slightly closer to the edge makes you more willing to help.

So it turns out the real world can be a dirty one, and every homeless person is not some down-on-his-luck hobo (remember hobos?). They can have arrest records, substance abuse problems and mental health issues, and, yes, they can spend your street corner singles on beer or something less legal.

As a lot of us might if we slept nights on concrete and endured that kind of life. People "self-medicate," says Lesa Weikel of Hillsborough's Homeless Coalition.

So if you are so inclined, should you give? "It comes down to a personal decision," Weikel says.

Interestingly, some people who work daily in the business of feeding and housing the homeless told me no, they personally do not hand out cash, preferring to give to agencies with homeless programs. Give food if you want to give on the street, they said. Gift cards, even.

Tim Marks, chief operating officer of Metropolitan Ministries, says he's offered food to people who don't want it, though plenty do. Some will take advantage of a good heart, but some are genuinely hurting. His agency, by the way, once had one of the best and most basic pleas for help: a sign that read Urgently Need Peanut Butter. This week, they're down to a two-week supply.

I call Pinellas Sheriff Jim Coats, wondering if a sheriff gives to panhandlers. Turns out he, too, prefers to donate to programs to help them, though he says his wife has been known to roll down the window.

And there's the dilemma. You're doing well enough to live under a roof and ride around in a car. A man on the corner clearly has less, and he is looking at you.

"That's just simply a human exchange of caring," says the Rev. Warren Clark of Tampa, who hands over 50 cents or a buck. But the question is a superficial one, he says, the real issue being public policy and jobs to get people off the streets.

There used to be this guy by the interstate. His handmade sign talked about HIV and regularly updated his T-cell count, and if this was scripted, the man deserved an Oscar. He's gone now, no clue as to how those crumpled bills helped or didn't, only the lingering thought when you pass his spot that you wish he hadn't had to be there in the first place.

Should we fork over cash to the "homeless"? 07/07/09 [Last modified: Wednesday, July 8, 2009 9:52am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Bono and Bush: Former president shares photo of visit


    A surprising photo showed up Friday on former President George W. Bush's Instagram feed. Apparently Bono made a visit to the ranch:

  2. After trip's final day, Trump to return to tumult at home


    TAORMINA, Italy — Down to the final day of his lengthy first international trip, President Donald Trump will lift off for Washington having rattled some allies and reassured others, returning to a White House that sits under a cloud of scandal.

    G7 leaders sign the G7 Taormina Statement on the Fight Against Terrorism and Violent Extremism at the G7 Summit in Taormina, Italy on Friday.  (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press via AP)
  3. Islamic State claims responsibility for Egypt attack


    MINYA, Egypt — The Islamic State group on Saturday claimed responsibility for the attack on a bus carrying Christians on their way to a remote desert monastery south of the Egyptian capital, Cairo, which killed 29.

    Relatives of killed Coptic Christians grieve during their funeral at Abu Garnous Cathedral in Minya, Egypt, on Friday. Egyptian officials say dozens of people were killed and wounded in an attack by masked militants on a bus carrying Coptic Christians, including children, south of Cairo.(AP Photo/Amr Nabil)
  4. This Tampa Bay Lightning wing rides the newest wave of fan interaction

    Lightning Strikes

    TAMPA — There are photos of Lightning fan Shaun Egger as a toddler at center ice at the then-Thunderome, aka Tropicana Field. He's played in the Lightning's high school hockey league for Palm Harbor University. But his closest personal encounter with players had been waving through a crowd after a training camp …

    Tampa Bay Lightning player J.T. Brown wears his anti UV glasses as he talks over the headset with a hockey fan while they play against each other on line in an XBOX NHL video game in Brown's game room at his home in south Tampa. The fan chose to be the Washington Capitals and Brown, of course, was the Tampa Bay Lightning. Brown interacts with fans through video game systems as he streams the games live on Twitch with plans for the proceeds to go to charity.
  5. Video: Rays Souza on that oh-so-bad dive, and reaction from Twins fans


    What was Rays RF Steven Souza Jr. thinking when he made that oh-so-bad dive for a ball in the seventh inning Friday? Well, we'll let him tell you ...