Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

USF St. Petersburg debate revives death of Osama bin Laden

Adrian O’Connor conducts a discussion in a class about the history of assassination at USF St. Petersburg recently.


Adrian O’Connor conducts a discussion in a class about the history of assassination at USF St. Petersburg recently.

ST. PETERSBURG — The syllabus was all but set in the spring. Assistant professor Adrian O'Connor envisioned History 3930 at the University of South Florida St. Petersburg as a fast-paced survey of the last roughly 2,500 years seen through the specific prism of assassination. Who killed whom, or tried, and what could that tell us about the broader significance of that time and place in the world?

And then Osama bin Laden was killed.

The elimination in May of the leader of al-Qaida, arguably the biggest news story of the year, turned O'Connor's history course this semester into the best, most useful kind — one in which the past is used to better interpret the present.

Maybe, O'Connor hoped, his couple of dozen undergraduates could have the kind of challenging but important conversation the country as a whole mostly did not.

Was this form of justice just?

From late August to last week, the students studied the assassinations of Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus. Henry IV. Abraham Lincoln. Archduke Franz Ferdinand. John F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. They studied the attempts on Adolf Hitler and Fidel Castro.

They tried to define assassination. It had to be targeted. It had to be politically significant. It had to have symbolic value. Motive mattered. Assassinations, it seemed, happened at the hinges of major historical moments.

Back in May, in Abbottabad, Pakistan, a member of a team of Navy SEALs shot an unarmed bin Laden, first in the chest, then in the face.

Nobody in the United States in any official capacity called it an assassination. The few voices that made that argument got lost in the general exultation.

O'Connor's students read a book this fall called Political Murder in which author Franklin L. Ford described assassination as "a highly unreliable expedient" and pointed out that it "has tended to ignore man's hard-won regard for due process."

They read a question-and-answer debate in the Guardian in London from the week bin Laden was killed.

"You don't just shoot an unarmed person," a prominent philosopher said. "That's what terrorists do, and you don't want to emulate them."

"No," a counterinsurgency expert said. "It's achieved its aims so it was a successful mission."

They read an opinion piece from November in the Los Angeles Times in which investigative journalist Andrew Cockburn called the bin Laden killing a "taxpayer-funded assassination."

They noted the U.S. executive orders that ban state-sanctioned assassinations of foreign leaders. An assassination, with rare exceptions, according to the initial order in 1975, "violates moral precepts fundamental to our way of life."

They were by last week ready to discuss bin Laden.

O'Connor, 30, an assistant professor who got his Ph.D. from the University of Pennsylvania in modern European history and wears a daily uniform of blue jeans and short-sleeve button-downs, stood at the front of Room 228 in Davis Hall and set some ground rules.

"It's very important that we are able to debate," he told the students. "Not just for the health of this class, but for the body politic in general."

And so he asked: Was the killing of Osama bin Laden an assassination?

Most students said yes.

"Anyone want to contest the idea that it was an assassination?" O'Connor said.

"They were sent in to take him dead or alive," said Kevin Pace, 26 — technically a military mission, he explained, not an effort to assassinate.

"But they were going to kill this guy," said Brooke Bennett, 28. "There was no way they were going to put him on trial."

"To me," said Hugh Tulloch, 72, auditing the class, "this was an act of legitimate war."

"Yes? No?" O'Connor said. "On what terms?"

"Revenge," Bennett said.

"There's a difference between what's been said on paper and what common sense is telling us is reality," said Alaura Marriott, 20. "We all know bringing Osama bin Laden back alive was not an option. Common sense? This was an assassination."

O'Connor then asked: "What did Osama bin Laden represent?"

The students agreed: He was the face of terrorism.

But Timothy McVeigh was a terrorist, O'Connor pointed out, and so was Ted Kaczynski. They got trials.

What if he had been captured and put on trial?

"He would have recruited," Tulloch said.

He also, O'Connor said, would have had a forum for his ideology. For many people, particularly in the Muslim world, he said, bin Laden represented not terrorism but a response to American imperialism. O'Connor told his students they didn't have to agree with that. But it is, he said, worth some consideration.

"I don't care what you think when you get out of my classes," he told the students. "It's that you think well."

Class was dismissed.

Michael Kruse can be reached at or (727) 893-8751. Follow him on Twitter at @michaelkruse.

USF St. Petersburg debate revives death of Osama bin Laden 12/04/11 [Last modified: Sunday, December 4, 2011 11:29pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Comedy legend Jerry Lewis dead at 91


    Jerry Lewis, who teamed with Dean Martin in the '50s before starring in The Nutty Professor and later founding the annual Jerry Lewis MDA Labor Day Telethon has died at 91 at his home in Las Vegas, according to his publicist.

    More to come.

  2. Mastermind of lottery rigging scam that netted millions faces 25 years


    DES MOINES, Iowa — For a decade, computer programmer Eddie Tipton reliably showed up for work at the central Iowa office of the Multi-State Lottery Association and earned the confidence of his co-workers, a team of technicians entrusted to build computers used to randomly pick numbers for some of the most popular …

    FILE - In this June 29, 2017, file photo, Eddie Tipton, the former Multi-State Lottery Association information security director who admitted to masterminding a scheme to rig lottery games that paid him and others $2 million from seven fixed jackpots in five states, is seen in court in Des Moines, Iowa. Tipton is scheduled to be sentenced Tuesday, Aug. 22. (Rodney White/The Des Moines Register via AP, File) IADES501
  3. Pasco County man killed in wrong-way crash on New Jersey Turnpike


    MOUNT LAUREL, N.J. — Authorities say a Florida man driving the wrong way on the New Jersey Turnpike was killed when his SUV crashed head-on into another vehicle.

  4. No bond for suspect in Kissimmee officers' fatal shooting


    KISSIMMEE — A suspect in the fatal shooting of two police officers in Florida will be staying in jail after a judge denied him bond Sunday, saying there was probable cause for his first-degree murder charge

    Officers Matthew Baxter, left, and Sam Howard, right, who were both shot and killed in Kissimmee, Florida, on Friday, Aug. 18, 2017. [Kissimmee Police]
  5. Tampa police arrest 22-year-old man in July murder


    TAMPA — Police arrested Sunday a 22-year-old man who detectives said shot and killed a Tampa man after an argument.

    Tampa police arrested Dejonta Felder, 22, in the murder of 32-year-old Julius R. Carter. [Tampa Police Department]