Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Jim Lehrer takes hits as presidential debate moderator

There's one person who may have earned even more criticism than Preident Barack Obama for his performance in Wednesday night's presidential debate: moderator Jim Lehrer.

Everyone from lefty comic Bill Maher to Fox News anchor Chris Wallace lined up on Twitter and TV shows to blast the semiretired PBS news legend for losing control of the event. "Worst moderator ever," actor Rob Lowe tweeted at one point.

Lehrer, 78, who retired as anchor of PBS' NewsHour last year, pushed back a little against the criticism in a statement emailed to the Tampa Bay Times.

"I thought the format accomplished its purpose, which was to facilitate direct, extended exchanges between the candidates about issues of substance," he wrote. "Part of my moderator mission was to stay out of the way of the flow and I had no problems with doing so. My only real personal frustration was discovering that ninety minutes was not enough time in that more open format to cover every issue that deserved attention."

GOP nominee Mitt Romney, known for his strong debate performances, talked over Lehrer even when the moderator tried to move on.

By the debate's end, both Obama and Romney regularly exceeded the time allotted to them, with the president even chiding Lehrer at one point.

"I had 5 seconds left before you interrupted me," Obama said sternly, before cracking a smile and continuing for much longer. The president talked four minutes longer than Romney, despite all the rules on timing.

Lehrer seemed to decide early on that allowing each man to make his case was better than refereeing or interjecting too many questions. But that meant the debate often got bogged down in select topics — with huge amounts of time spent on taxes and health care — while Romney controlled the flow of the discussion with a more aggressive performance.

Still, the longtime debate moderator had his defenders. CNN analyst David Gergen, a veteran of four presidential administrations, noted on Twitter: "Contra critics, Jim Lehrer did exactly right as moderator: ask basic ?s, let candidates talk. Result: serious conversation."

But Los Angeles Times columnist Jim Rainey summed up the media world's sentiment best, writing, "Lehrer's 12th, and, doubtless final, turn in the referee's chair would not go down as his finest."

Jim Lehrer takes hits as presidential debate moderator 10/04/12 [Last modified: Thursday, October 4, 2012 11:03pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Yep, 2017 hurricane season really is more intense than normal


    It was only 25 days ago that Hurricane Harvey made landfall.

    A handout satellite image from Sept. 8, 2017, of, from left, Tropical Storm Katia, Hurricane Irma and Tropical Storm Jose, which would intensify into a hurricane. The 2017 Atlantic hurricane season has been unusually active. There have been 13 named storms this year. Only four other seasons since 1995 have had that many by Sept. 18. [NASA/NOAA GOES Project via the New York Times]
  2. Cannon Fodder podcast: Bucs could run into their nemesis


    Greg Auman finishes wrapping up the Bucs' win against the Chicago Bears and looks ahead to Sunday's game at Minnesota, where Tampa Bay could run into nemesis Case Keenum, in our latest Cannon Fodder …

    Bucs outside linebacker Lavonte David (54) sacks Los Angeles Rams quarterback Case Keenum (17) during a 2016 game. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times]
  3. How to vamp out for Buffyfest in St. Petersburg

    Music & Concerts

    Who's your favorite superhero? I always answer Buffy.

    Photo illustration RON BORRESEN, Photo by Warner Brothers, Photo by SCOTT KEELER   |   Times
Members of the Florida Bjorkestra rehearse, Monday, 3/13/17, at the Palladium Theater, St. Petersburg for their upcoming concert. In the foreground is percussionist Joe Coyle.

Sarah Michelle Gellar
  4. The Mill restaurants offering half off when customers donate items for hurricane relief


    The Mill restaurant in St. Petersburg and its newly-opened location in Brandon are collecting donations to help residents of the Florida Keys who've been affected by Hurricane Irma.

    The dining room at The Mill in St. Petersburg photographed in 2015.
  5. Navy removes Jacksonville hospital workers who called babies 'mini satans' (w/video)


    JACKSONVILLE — A Navy hospital in Florida has removed some employees from patient care after Snapchat photos showed a nurse giving the middle finger to a newborn with a caption that said, "How I currently feel about these mini Satans."

    A Navy hospital in Florida has removed some employees from patient care after Snapchat photos showed a nurse giving the middle finger to a newborn with a caption that said, "How I currently feel about these mini Satans." [Photo from video]