Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge denies request to stop Florida voter purge

TALLAHASSEE — A judge on Wednesday rejected the federal government's attempt to block Florida's voter purge of non-U.S. citizens, partly because the purge has been suspended.

U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle said federal laws that prohibit the systematic removal of voters close to an election do not refer to noncitizens. He also accepted the state's claim that its purging efforts are over for now.

The ruling came as part of a request by the U.S. Department of Justice, which sought a retraining order stopping the purge efforts.

The agency argued that the purge violates a federal law, the 1993 National Voter Registration Act, which outlaws systematic removals of voters less than 90 days before a federal election. Florida's primary is Aug. 14.

Hinkle interpreted the law to refer to people who were lawfully registered to vote before being removed, such as felons or the deceased. He said the law is silent as to noncitizens.

Justice Department lawyer John Bert Russ deplored the Florida "dragnet" that he said has unfairly forced U.S. citizens to prove their legitimacy. But he could not cite any instances of a legitimate voter being removed from the rolls.

At one point, Russ asked the judge to restore the voting rights of everyone who has been purged from the rolls, an idea Hinkle flatly rejected.

"Leaving ineligible voters on the list is not a solution. Noncitizens should not be voting," the judge said. "People need to know we are running an honest election."

Attorney Michael Carvin, representing Secretary of State Ken Detzner, said the state is suing to seek access to a Department of Homeland Security database to better ascertain the citizenship status of voters. The federal agency has so far refused the state's request, claiming it has not received necessary information from the state.

"If we get the (federal) data, I do expect the state to proceed and protect the integrity of the voter rolls," Carvin said.

The state argued that it has a duty to make sure noncitizens don't cast ballots that would dilute the votes of citizens. But the purge set off a furor because it occurred so close to a presidential election and more than half of suspected noncitizens are Hispanics.

"That's discriminatory, at least in effect," Hinkle said. "I don't suggest that that was the purpose of this."

Hinkle voiced concern over what he called an "overreach" by Collier County, which he said sent letters to potential noncitizens challenging whether people born in Puerto Rico are considered U.S. citizens. (They are.)

A staff member in the Collier elections office, Tim Durham, said the county never sent such a letter.

Hinkle, who was appointed to the federal bench by President Bill Clinton in 1996, expressed disappointment that the two sides are battling in court so close to the election.

"The federal government and the state government ought to be working together to try to minimize the mistakes," he said.

In starkly political terms, the judge's decision was a victory for Scott and a defeat for President Barack Obama and Democrats.

Scott praised Hinkle's ruling. "The court made a commonsense decision consistent with what I've been saying all along: that irreparable harm will result if noncitizens are allowed to vote," Scott said.

Even though the purge has stalled, it has caught fire across the country.

Sixty percent of Floridians in a recent Quinnipiac University poll said they agreed with Scott that noncitizens should not be on the rolls.

Democrats accuse Scott of trying to suppress votes in Florida, and the liberal group is running a TV ad calling the purge "racist" and challenging Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney to condemn it.

The state motor vehicle agency last year created a database of about 2,600 people whose citizenship was in question. But county election supervisors stopped scrubbing the rolls two weeks ago, after concluding the list was unreliable and contains the names of many voters who are U.S. citizens.

Judge denies request to stop Florida voter purge 06/27/12 [Last modified: Thursday, June 28, 2012 12:06am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Next up in Bucs renovations? A $20 million indoor practice facility


    Renderings of the Bucs' new indoor practice facility (Courtesy of the Bucs)
  2. Want to feel old? It's been 20 years since the first 'Harry Potter' was published


    He was so cute: Blond hair, blue eyes and a killer smile. He was dressed in a black robe with a fake scar on his forehead and regaling our fifth-grade class with his book report on Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. As a 10-year-old with only the most sophisticated of tastes (give me a Baby-Sitters Club any day), …

    An auctioneer holds a first edition copy of the first Harry Potter book "Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone" containing annotations and illustrations by author J.K. Rowling. The tale has turned 20,  published in Britain on June 26, 1997. Since then, it has sold more than 450 million copies worldwide and has been translated into 79 languages. (Associated Press [2013])
  3. Dunedin selects Jennifer Bramley as its next city manager

    Local Government

    DUNEDIN — In a unanimous vote Monday, the City Commission chose Jennifer Bramley as the next city manager.

    Jennifer Bramley, 52, was selected Monday as Dunedin's new city manager. She currently works as deputy city manager for the city of Coral Springs. [Photo courtesy of Jennifer Bramley]
  4. People leave the Supreme Court in Washington, Monday, as justices issued their final rulings for the term. The high court is letting a limited version of the Trump administration ban on travel from six mostly Muslim countries to take effect, a victory for President Donald Trump in the biggest legal controversy of his young presidency. [AP photo]
  5. Lightning re-signs Andrej Sustr to one-year, $1.95 million deal


    The Lightning locked up another piece of its blueline Monday, re-signing defenseman Andrej Sustr to a one-year, $1.95 million deal.

    Andrej Sustr 14 points in 80 games last season, a minus-10.