Thursday, July 19, 2018
News Roundup

Legal experts weigh in on soundness of Lindsey defense strategy

LARGO — Nicholas Lindsey did it. He just didn't mean to do it.

That was the legal strategy defense attorneys unveiled this week in the trial of the teenager accused of killing St. Petersburg police Officer David S. Crawford.

It seems counterintuitive. Why start by conceding defeat? But legal experts said focusing on the issue of criminal intent could mean the difference between the 17-year-old spending the rest of his life in prison — or just a few decades of it.

"It ain't the only possible strategy," said University of Florida law professor Bob Dekle. "But it sounds like the only viable strategy."

Veteran defense attorney Keith Hammond agreed.

"It's probably the only strategy at this point," the New Port Richey lawyer said.

That's because a tearful Lindsey confessed in a video recording played for the jury on Wednesday. The jury also spent the day listening to witnesses describe the Feb. 21, 2011, shooting and linking Lindsey to the crime. One witness said he saw Lindsey running away holding a silver gun.

"Not guilty is no longer on the table," said Clearwater defense attorney Bjorn Brunvand.

So the defense team apparently chose to fight the only battle it could still win: Did Lindsey intend to kill the officer?

Prosecutors have argued that Lindsey acted with premeditation, that he intended to kill when he shot Crawford five times. Intent is the key element of first-degree murder.

If the state proves intent, the jury will have to convict Lindsey of first-degree murder. That carries an automatic sentence of life in prison without parole.

But if the teen's lawyers, Dyril Flanagan and Frank McDermott, can convince the jury that Lindsey didn't intend to kill, he could be convicted of a lesser charge: manslaughter of a law enforcement officer. Then Lindsey would face a sentence of 30 years.

To do so, jurors would have to find that Lindsey acted with "culpable negligence" and reckless disregard for human life, but did not mean to take a life.

"Then there's some light at the end of the tunnel," Dekle said. "There's some hope of getting out eventually."

McDermott explained the defense's theory to the jury when the trial began Tuesday, describing what they believe happened between Crawford and the teen that fatal night.

When Crawford first encountered Lindsey he ordered the teen to show his hands. Lindsey pulled out a .380 semiautomatic pistol from his sweatshirt pocket. He thought the safety was on, but it wasn't. The gun went off accidentally.

Crawford then went for his gun, the defense said, and a frightened Lindsey started firing.

"In Nicholas' mind, he didn't want to die," McDermott told the jury Tuesday. "Now that's not a justified killing. But … it's not a premeditated killing. It's something that happened in seconds.

"This scared child has a firearm and it accidentally goes off."

In his videotaped confession, Lindsey made statements that align with the defense's theory. "I thought it was on safety," he said. He also said it just "went off."

Prosecutor Jim Hellickson countered the defense's attempt to portray Lindsey as a frightened child by repeatedly saying that "man" killed the officer.

"Quite frequently, as a defense attorney, what you're doing is damage control," Dekle said, "and trying to mitigate the damage that the defendant has done to himself."

Hammond said the defense could still challenge the confession and argue that it was coerced. However, defense attempts to get the video thrown out before trial failed.

The one thing Dekle said he would not do is put Lindsey himself on the stand. A 17-year-old being cross-examined by veteran prosecutors? Not a good idea, he said.

Another bad idea: trying to sell the jury on some made-for-TV defense theory.

"You can use all kinds of defenses," Dekle said. "There's the mysterious disappearing twin brother defense. But none of them are going to hold any water with the jury."

Comments
Police: Pinellas infant on life support after father stuffs balled-up baby wipe down his throat

Police: Pinellas infant on life support after father stuffs balled-up baby wipe down his throat

TARPON SPRINGS — Cali’yah Anderson heard a scream Tuesday night and she thought someone was dying. "Help me! Help me! I can’t get it out!" Anderson sprinted into the living room at 1410 Starlight Cove two doors down from her own apartment and found a...
Updated: 11 minutes ago
Dive outing among friends turns deadly Wednesday evening in Weeki Wachee

Dive outing among friends turns deadly Wednesday evening in Weeki Wachee

WEEKI WACHEEIt was the first time Said Marjane and his friends had gone free diving near the Eagle’s Nest, in a pool of water in the Chassahowitzka Wildlife Management Area in Weeki Wachee better known as the entrance to a dangerous cave-diving site....
Updated: 20 minutes ago

Lottery resultsNumbers drawn after 9 p.m. are no longer available by our deadlines. For results, please go to tampabay.com/lottery.Pick 2, 3, 4, 5Thurs., July 20, midday:522152201e_SRit80354Thurs., July 20, evening:319928247e_SRit47856Mega MillionsTo...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Quarterback rankings: The best seasons in Buccaneers history

Quarterback rankings: The best seasons in Buccaneers history

It was Dec. 20, 1981, the final Sunday of the NFL regular season, and the NFC Central title was on the line. The Buccaneers were in Detroit, where the Lions hadn’t lost all season.The Lions, who were favored by a touchdown, took a 7-3 lead in t...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Hernando sheriff: Two dead after three shootings in Hudson, Spring Hill

Hernando sheriff: Two dead after three shootings in Hudson, Spring Hill

SPRING HILL — A string of shootings in Pasco and Hernando counties Thursday left two people dead, including the suspected shooter, and another person seriously injured, authorities said.Theodore Parker, 41, shot at a woman at her home on Chestnut Dri...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Judge grants ex-girlfriend’s restraining order against ex-Plant QB Robert Marve

Judge grants ex-girlfriend’s restraining order against ex-Plant QB Robert Marve

PLANT CITY — Robert Marve hesitated to get out of his attorney’s car when they pulled into the parking lot of the Plant City Courthouse on Thursday afternoon. The former Plant High and University of Miami quarterback was there to plead no contest to ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
‘Bigs in Blue’ mentoring program teaches kids that cops aren’t the bad guys

‘Bigs in Blue’ mentoring program teaches kids that cops aren’t the bad guys

TAMPA — Tampa police Detective Shane Gadoury knew people sometimes viewed him with suspicion when he landed in their neighborhoods, dressed in a midnight black uniform and carrying a gun.But then he met Maurice, an 8-year-old student from Oak Park El...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Longtime Tampa Catholic athletic director Nick DiMaggio dies

Longtime Tampa Catholic athletic director Nick DiMaggio dies

Nick DiMaggio, the longtime athletic director at Tampa Catholic who was a fixture at the school's sporting events for more than 50 years, died Wednesday from complications related to a stroke. Funeral arrangements have yet to be made."Nick was an ico...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Chickens remain free to range in Ybor

Chickens remain free to range in Ybor

TAMPA — Ybor City chickens have escaped the political chopping block — again.The Tampa City Council on Thursday declined to do anything about a wild flock of poultry that drew a loud, strong throng of supporters to City Hall to ask council members no...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Florida State defensive forecast not that simple

Florida State defensive forecast not that simple

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — His debut at the ACC kickoff attracted a wholly unsurprising assortment of topics. New FSU coach Willie Taggart was asked about his culture, his quarterbacks, his catch phrases.He handled each question deftly, hardly devi...
Updated: 3 hours ago