Sunday, June 24, 2018
News Roundup

Brownfield status for Brooksville project means money for developers, frustration for Commission

BROOKSVILLE — Promotional materials on the website of developer Housing Trust Group show drawings depicting a completed 104-unit garden-style apartment complex with an inviting swimming pool.

The development will include "a stand-alone clubhouse with exceptional amenities including a fully equipped fitness center, open-concept gathering room, kid’s playtime room, computer lab, and media/gaming station. The landscaped grounds provide a playground and resort-style pool with a pergola and barbecue station for all residents,’’ according to the article on the Hammock Ridge I complex.

The apartments, which have been under construction on Omaha Circle in Spring Hill for several months, with plans for an opening soon, seem like any other multifamily development built in recent years.

But there is a difference, and it is one that has caused the County Commission some angst.

The developer wants the county to designate the site a "Brownfield" — a property on which development "may be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant,’’ according to the definition by the Environmental Protection Agency.

Only the developer’s representative has told the commission there is no contamination on the site. Months ago, before the Housing Trust Group broke ground and began to build, photos were taken of trash piled up nearby. But there was no testing for contaminants to find out what might lie beneath the site before construction began.

The designation of a "Brownfield site" brings with it a monetary reward in the form of tax incentives. In this case, sales tax incentives which could total $456,000 for the $19 million project.

The actual designation takes two public hearings. At the first hearing several months ago, commissioners balked and tried to keep the second hearing from happening. But commissioners were convinced by their attorney to schedule the second hearing for the end of October.

But even after that presentation, which included what the county attorney called a threat of a lawsuit "in a very humble manner" by the developer’s attorney, the commission still balked. Now the decision is slated for Tuesday.

At the October hearing, Commission Chairman Wayne Dukes told the developer’s attorney, Michael Goldstein, that, while the property met the requirements of the law for designation, "we haven’t gotten any results, borings, to show that it (contamination) is there.’’

Dukes asked, "what’s to stop any developer from now on doing the same thing ... if you don’t have to produce evidence?’’

Goldstein said while there was evidence the land could have been contaminated, the federal government and the states have all adopted rules for Brownfield sites which require only the perception of contamination.

This shows that the Legislature acknowledges that "it’s not just actual contamination which causes dysfunction in the marketplace but ... perceived contamination which is sometimes just a hint, the fear that actual contamination will exist,’’ Goldstein said.

That can cause a developer or a government or an individual to back away from a development opportunity because the potential high cost of dealing with real contamination, Goldstein said.

None of the five criteria required by the law for Brownfield designation relate to environmental requirements. They include the developer proving he owns the site and his agreement to rehabilitate and develop it, that the redevelopment would make the site economically productive, that it follows local land use rules, that the hearings were public noticed and that the developer has the financial means to build the project.

Goldstein said Hammock Ridge I meets those standards and the county staff agrees. He also argued that the wording of the state law makes the county’s approval mandatory once those standards are met. That didn’t sit well with commissioners.

"No doubt you’re well within your bounds, Michael, but wow,’’ Dukes said.

Commissioner John Allocco, who spoke to the Legislative Delegation several days earlier asking for a change in the mandatory nature of the law, wanted a delay until changes could be made to the law during next year’s legislative session. But county attorney Garth Coller said that would not be appropriate.

"There is no rehabilitation plan filed with the county, none at all. He has admitted there is no actual contamination. He hasn’t found any. I don’t think he even looked for any, but that’s my opinion,’’ said Commissioner Nick Nicholson.

"They just want this designation so they can get the money,’’ Nicholson said. "I’m not in favor of this at all ... I’m not going to vote for this.’’

Dukes warned his fellow commissioners that balking on approval might be costly and that the county has been sued and lost before over issues they were not personally in favor of approving. But when he called for a vote on the designation, no commissioner would make a motion to approve it.

Finally, Commissioner Steve Champion made a motion to continue the discussion until Tuesday so that commissioners could talk with their attorney and further examine the evidence provided by the developer. The commission agreed to the delay.

County staff also informed commissioners that a second application for a Brownfield designation by the same developer is pending for Hammock Ridge II, awaiting their decision on the first site.

Contact Barbara Behrendt at bbehrendt[email protected] or (352) 848-1434.

Comments
Father dead, suspect in custody after hit-and-run driver plows into New Tampa family on bike ride

Father dead, suspect in custody after hit-and-run driver plows into New Tampa family on bike ride

A Tampa man is dead and his 3-year-old son is in serious condition after being struck by a hit-and-run driver as they went on a family bike ride Sunday afternoon.A male suspect is in custody and being interviewed by police but his name has not yet be...
Updated: 4 hours ago
A local hockey draftee? Mitchell grad Nathan Smith is just that

A local hockey draftee? Mitchell grad Nathan Smith is just that

TAMPA — Every year during draft season, players from the Tampa Bay area are selected in the NFL, MLB and even NBA drafts.But NHL?Sure enough, in the third round of Saturday's NHL draft, the Jets selected Nathan Smith, a forward who was born in ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Office building demolition at Midtown Tampa site proves tougher than expected

Office building demolition at Midtown Tampa site proves tougher than expected

TAMPA — Stripped to the girders, the old Bromley office building looked about as substantial as fish bones on a dinner plate.But the 5-story structure proved Sunday it still had a surprising amount of fight left in it.A demolition team had planned to...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Rays season turning into good one

Rays season turning into good one

ST. PETERSBURG — The Tampa Bay Rays are not the best team in baseball. They are not going to win the World Series this year. Heck, they probably won't even make the playoffs.But I tell you what. This team is a heck of a lot of fun to watch.And ...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Rays beat Yankees in 12 innings on Jake Bauers homer

Rays beat Yankees in 12 innings on Jake Bauers homer

ST. PETERSBURG — Rays first baseman Jake Bauers sat at his locker after Sunday afternoon's 7-6, 12-inning win over the Yankees and thumbed through his text messages. There was no way he could get through them all. That's what happens when ...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Rays journal: Yarbrough comes through, Venters to DL, support for Ramos

Rays journal: Yarbrough comes through, Venters to DL, support for Ramos

ST. PETERSBURG — Ryan Yarbrough was only supposed to throw on Sunday if it was an emergency. In the 12th inning with the score tied 6-6 and a runner on first, there was an emergency.Jonny Venters tweaked his right hamstring trying to cover firs...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Suspect dead, 2 injured in St. Petersburg home invasion-turned-shooting

Suspect dead, 2 injured in St. Petersburg home invasion-turned-shooting

ST. PETERSBURGSuspect dead, 2 injured in home invasion, shootingThree people forced their way into a St. Petersburg house before dawn Sunday before gunfire broke out, killing a suspect and injuring two residents, police said.About 5:30 a.m., the peop...
Updated: 7 hours ago
A jogger accidentally crossed into the US from Canada and was detained for two weeks

A jogger accidentally crossed into the US from Canada and was detained for two weeks

The coast of White Rock, British Columbia, in western Canada looks to be an ideal place for a run, with its sweeping views of the Semiahmoo Bay to the west and scores of waterfront homes and seafood restaurants to the east. That’s what 19-year-old Ce...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Head-on crash kills Pasco teenager, injures three

Head-on crash kills Pasco teenager, injures three

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 19-year-old driver died in a three-car crash on Moon Lake Road on Saturday afternoon, the Florida Highway Patrol reported.Jillian Faith Hitt, 19 and of New Port Richey, was driving north on the road in a 2008 Hyundai Accent, weari...
Published: 06/24/18
President Trump’s trade war threatens the US newspaper industry

President Trump’s trade war threatens the US newspaper industry

STERLING, Ill. - As a longtime editor of small-town newspapers, Jeff Rogers has seen his industry face the collapse of print advertising, the rise of the internet and more. Today, his 18 employees work in a newsroom here that puts out two daily newsp...
Published: 06/24/18