Wednesday, October 17, 2018
News Roundup

Romano: Why flood insurance might not be enough to save your home

Irma is gone, and Maria never came.

And yet this is as good a time as any to worry.

Because if recent storms have taught us anything, it is that Tampa Bay homeowners are at risk not just from flooding but from the regulatory hurdles that inevitably follow.

They’re learning that today in Jacksonville. And in Miami. And in every other community that saw floodwaters rise as Irma cut a path through the middle of the state last month.

You see, having a policy from the National Flood Insurance Program is essential, but it’s no Get-Out-Of-Hell free card. Not with relatively new government regulations meant to cut down on NFIP losses.

And if you have a hard time digesting that, then you might want to read a report released this month in conjunction with the fifth anniversary of Hurricane Sandy. The New Jersey Resource Project surveyed hundreds of residents whose homes were damaged in 2012 and are still without resolution.

The result is "The Long Road Home," a 56-page study advocating for NFIP reforms by detailing the stories of homeowners caught in bureaucratic limbo.

"It was the worst, it was awful,’’ said Amanda Devecka-Rinear, one of the report’s authors. "When we showed up at their doors, they were so glad that somebody cared and was willing to listen, but it was heartbreaking to see what had happened to their lives.

"There was layer after layer of failure that was just devastating. And what makes it worse is that we know what happened to us up here, and when we see the storms coming toward you all, our hearts break because we know what everybody is going to be facing.’’

So what are we talking about here?

Well-meaning regulations that can lead to life-altering realities.

Concerned about homes with repetitive flood losses, FEMA decided not to write NFIP policies in communities that did not pass laws that enforced stricter flood mitigation plans. And so local governments had no choice but to follow those FEMA guidelines.

And that means if your home is considered "substantially damaged’’ (an insurance claim of more than 50 percent of the structure’s value) then you need to raise your home’s elevation before you will be issued permits to begin repairs.

For example:

Let’s say you have a $150,000 home in a low-lying area. A flood causes $80,000 in damage. You have an NFIP policy, so you think you’re in the clear. Except, because you now fall under the substantially damaged category, the house must be raised 11 feet above the flood baseline.

In a worst-case scenario, for a concrete slab home, that type of elevation project could cost as much as $160,000. In other words, twice as much money as the actual damages. For some people, it’s easier to simply tear the home down and start over at a higher elevation. For others, abandoning the house is the only solution.

"If we have a catastrophic flooding event, a great majority of St. Petersburg is going to be in a lot of trouble,’’ said Noah Taylor, the city’s flooding expert. "That’s why the quicker we continue mitigation efforts, whether that’s tearing them down or elevating them, the safer everyone will be.’’

Making sure houses are elevation-compliant is not the only obstacle residents face in the wake of a flood event.

Of the homeowners who responded to the New Jersey Resource Project, just about half (48 percent) said their homes had reported damages of more than $150,000. And yet only 5 percent actually got payouts of more than $150,000.

How can that be?

Devecka-Rinear said private insurers who administer NFIP policies can face government fees if they overestimate damage costs. Invariably, that leads to underestimating damage costs.

She said the problem was so rampant in New Jersey that elected officials forced FEMA to reopen tens of thousands of claims to make sure homeowners got what they deserved.

"The NFIP, in our humble opinion, needs to be overhauled,’’ she said. "States like ours and yours, that have survived these disaster and flood events, need to band together and push for reforms.’’

About 40,000 homeowners in New Jersey suffered flood losses from Sandy this week in 2012. Exact numbers are hard to come by, but Devecka-Rinear said an estimated 20 to 30 percent of those homeowners are still not back in their homes.

That would be 10,000 families.

Five years later.

Worry, much?

Comments
Man files suit against Diocese of St. Petersburg saying a Tampa priest sexually abused him in the 1980s

Man files suit against Diocese of St. Petersburg saying a Tampa priest sexually abused him in the 1980s

ST. PETERSBURG — A man who said he was sexually abused by a priest at Christ the King Catholic Church in Tampa has filed a lawsuit against the Diocese of St. Petersburg and the Long Island diocese from which the priest had been transferred. According...
Updated: 14 minutes ago
Pedestrian, 79, critically injured while crossing U.S. 19 in Clearwater

Pedestrian, 79, critically injured while crossing U.S. 19 in Clearwater

A 79-year-old woman remains in critical condition after being struck by a car on U.S. 19.
Updated: 23 minutes ago
New Port Richey councilman: Should the city spend $800,000 on a fire truck or let the county handle it?

New Port Richey councilman: Should the city spend $800,000 on a fire truck or let the county handle it?

Councilman also suggests Pasco County pay the city for services
Updated: 26 minutes ago
Plant City man arrested, 74-year-old in critical condition after Polk hit-and-run

Plant City man arrested, 74-year-old in critical condition after Polk hit-and-run

Ricky Perez wanted to visit his mother’s grave. On the way back, Polk County deputies said, he nearly sent someone else to their own.
Updated: 30 minutes ago
Bunny Ranch owner and GOP candidate Dennis Hof dies in Nevada

Bunny Ranch owner and GOP candidate Dennis Hof dies in Nevada

Dennis Hof, the limelight-loving Bunny Ranch owner who parlayed his legal pimp fame into a GOP nomination for the Nevada Assembly, has died.The brothel boss who billed himself as the “Trump from Pahrump” turned 72 on Sunday.Porn star Ro...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Mayor Mel Jurado drops

Mayor Mel Jurado drops "Ph.D." from bio at Temple Terrace website

TEMPLE TERRACE — Mayor Mel Jurado said nothing as speaker after speaker took to the microphone during Tuesday’s city council meeting to address revelations that the Ph.D. she has long touted comes from a diploma mill and that she cannot prove she hol...
Updated: 1 hour ago

Find A Friend: Panhandle Pablo The Shepherd Mix

New Life Dog Rescue will make Pablo and other adoptables available on Oct. 27.
Updated: 1 hour ago
USF football midseason review: Jury still out on unbeaten Bulls

USF football midseason review: Jury still out on unbeaten Bulls

TAMPA — Here we stand at the halfway point of USF's season, with nary half a clue of where the Bulls appear destined.Peach Bowl or a pedestrian one? At this juncture, who can say? The No. 21  Bulls may be unbeaten (6-0) but they're ha...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Searing heat continues to remain intact across Tampa Bay

Searing heat continues to remain intact across Tampa Bay

Another October day, another potential record-high temperature in Tampa Bay.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Casey Levy adds an edge to Clearwater Central Catholic’s ground game

Casey Levy adds an edge to Clearwater Central Catholic’s ground game

CLEARWATER — Casey Levy can absorb pain. Two years ago, he was helping a friend chop down a tree with an axe. Suddenly, the steel blade flew off the wooden handle, striking Levy in the knee.The cut required about 10 stitches."I'm not allow...
Updated: 2 hours ago