Sunday, February 25, 2018
News Roundup

Clearwater may sue contractor over sewage spewing into homes

CLEARWATER — One morning in 2010, food chunks and cigarette butts surfed a wave of human waste through the toilets and bathtubs of three homes on Pinebrook Drive.

Paid by the city to clean a new sewer line, a contractor's crews had accidentally blasted sewage backward, defiling oak floors, closets and family mementos under a 6-inch fecal flood.

Days later, with two of the homes rendered uninhabitable, the city began cleaning the putrid mess, repairing the damage and reimbursing residents for things soiled in the sludge. After about eight months, the cleanup tab came to more than $150,000.

For months, city leaders have asked BRW Contracting, the Land O'Lakes contractor, to pay them back. Now officials are planning to take their case to court.

The messy lawsuit, which the City Council is expected to approve tonight, marks one of the rare cases over the last two decades where the city sued its own contractor for damages. Assistant city attorney Dick Hull said, "It doesn't often go this wrong."

But Clearwater could have a high-priced fight on its hands. BRW leaders told Hull they had launched their own investigation, which found they were not at fault. They insist they owe nothing. Phone and e-mail messages left with BRW this week were not returned.

BRW's work for the city started simply enough that February, when the company was hired to replace a sewer main that pumps sewage between two city lift stations. The job was to cost the city about $430,000 and end that October.

But one Tuesday morning in August, as crews pumped water at high pressure through the new line, a backflow of sewage spewed into three neighboring homes at 1018, 1020 and 1022 Pinebrook Drive.

The homes, on the shore of Stevenson Creek and just north of the Clearwater Country Club, were flooded with half a foot of used toilet paper and sludge gushing from sinks and faucets.

The problem, BRW owner Randy Blankenship told the Times then, began with the city's order to "pig the line." In the piping industry, pigs are bullet- or ball-shaped widgets launched by water through pipelines to blast out clogs and crud.

But in ordering the pig, Blankenship said, the city did not account for elevation: the homes were lower than the main pipe, allowing the muck to surge downhill. He said officials also did not ask for one-way valves that could have stopped the backflow.

City officials contend it was BRW's responsibility to decide how to do the project. If crews found a problem, officials said, they should have reported it to the city first.

The city's suit could also turn on a standard "hold harmless" clause in its contract with BRW, which Hull said could protect the city from liability due to a "negligent act."

In the wake of the disaster, with BRW refusing to pay for cleanup, officials offered to pay to book residents into motels and begin the massive cleanup.

Restoration cleaners, carpenters and painters had to rebuild the homes from the ground up, city records show, scrubbing with antimicrobial cleansers and replacing ruined oak floors, carpets, baseboard and drywall.

Bundles of soiled clothing, from leather boots and blankets to shawls and cocktail dresses, were sent to specialized restoration dry cleaners. One home sent nearly 100 pieces of clothing, at a laundry cost of $1,200.

Gone were all manner of books, throw rugs, mattresses and sofas, which absorbed the swampy muck. Some things could not be replaced: one resident lost a one-of-a-kind poster from her late husband's memorial service.

"Legally, maybe we didn't have the responsibility," said Wayne Barker, a city risk management specialist. "But morally, we did, because they were our citizens, and they were in a pinch."

Ron Patella returned from work that day to find the home he had spent three years remodeling partly flooded: his billiards room, with $80-a-yard carpeting, was soaked in dark muck.

The city paid for all the demolition, cleanup and even the electrical bills for the dehumidifiers and fans used to dry the mess. A home-remodeling contractor himself, Patella said BRW should pay for the cleanup with its insurance — or brace for a loss in court.

"We did not want to live with that diseased water, any part of it," he said. "I didn't really care whose fault it was."

Contact Drew Harwell at (727) 445-4170 or [email protected] Send letters to the editor at tampabay.com/letters.

Comments
Mexican president won’t visit White House after Trump reportedly ‘lost his temper’ in call

Mexican president won’t visit White House after Trump reportedly ‘lost his temper’ in call

Tentative plans for a trip by Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto to the White House have been scrapped after he and President Donald Trump spoke by phone and tangled once again over Trump’s plans to erect a border wall, according to news reports.Th...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
Pasco deputies: New Port Richey man shot during home invasion

Pasco deputies: New Port Richey man shot during home invasion

A New Port Richey man was in critical condition on Sunday after being shot during a home invasion that the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office said may be drug related.Detectives say a call was received at 2:22 a.m. Sunday that the resident at 4429 Tidal P...
Updated: 8 minutes ago
Students, parents make emotional return to Marjory Stoneman Douglas campus

Students, parents make emotional return to Marjory Stoneman Douglas campus

Liam Kiernan’s first stop when he reentered Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School for the first time on Sunday afternoon was the band room. The 15-year-old took his dad to the closet where he hid during the shooting."I walked in and showed him, that’s...
Updated: 22 minutes ago
In Black Panther, kids finally see themselves starring on screen

In Black Panther, kids finally see themselves starring on screen

TAMPA — Ezekiel Mills went to the movies on Saturday and after two hours and 15 minutes of make-believe felt something the 13-year-old should be able to feel all the time."I kind of felt special," he said.The movie was Black Panther, the story of the...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Billy Graham had pride and regret on civil rights issues

Billy Graham had pride and regret on civil rights issues

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. — The Rev. Billy Graham was single-minded when he preached about God, prefacing sermon points with the phrase "The Bible says ..." Yet he had a complicated role in race relations, particularly when confronting segregation in his nati...
Updated: 3 hours ago
5 dead after tornado, flooding from central US storms

5 dead after tornado, flooding from central US storms

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — The death toll rose to at least five on Sunday after severe thunderstorms swept through the central U.S., spawning a tornado that flattened homes, gale force winds and widespread flooding from the Upper Midwest to Appalachia.The s...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Michelle Obama’s memoir ‘Becoming’ will be released in November

Michelle Obama’s memoir ‘Becoming’ will be released in November

Former first lady Michelle Obama’s first book post-White House will be a memoir titled "Becoming" that will hit book shelves on November 13."Becoming," which publishing company Penguin Random House called "unusually intimate" in a news release Sunday...
Updated: 3 hours ago
NRA spokeswoman becomes new face of gun rights movement

NRA spokeswoman becomes new face of gun rights movement

CHICAGO — Dana Loesch is the new public face of the National Rifle Association, an organization long associated with older white men. At 39, she’s poised, photogenic and a skilled public speaker, yet she’s not softening the message of the NRA as it b...
Updated: 3 hours ago

Updated: 3 hours ago
Hit-and-run driver in fatal accident sought by law enforcement

Hit-and-run driver in fatal accident sought by law enforcement

A hit-and-run crash has left a Tampa man dead, his female passenger in critical condition and law enforcement in search of the man who was driving the vehicle that struck them from behind.A Nissan Sentra was traveling north in the inside lane of U.S....
Updated: 4 hours ago