Wednesday, April 25, 2018
News Roundup

Court ruling on term limits may throw wrinkle into Pinellas elections

Way back in 1996, Pinellas voters overwhelmingly approved a measure to limit the number of terms elected county officials could serve before stepping aside for a fresh face.

Six years later, the Florida Supreme Court overturned that charter amendment, saying it was unconstitutional.

A week ago, the state Supreme Court did what it seldom does — changed its mind. It's now okay for voters to place term limits on their county commissioners.

What does that mean for Pinellas? Does this revive the 1996 amendment? If so, does that mean term limits start tolling from that time? Or does it begin from last week when the new decision was handed down? Does it mean some officials will have to leave office midterm or stop re-election bids?

Those answers pretty much depend on whom you ask.

About the only thing they seem to agree on is that the new decision gives activists a chance to go back to the beginning so voters can once again decide if they want term limits for county officials.

Other answers are more murky.

County attorney Jim Bennett, who will have to advise county commissioners on their best strategy, says he's not sure about the effect of the new ruling. He said he plans to meet with a group of lawyers Friday to discuss the case and any possible fallout. Bennett also notes that it might be a bit early to talk about the situation because the parties in the most recent case, which did not involve Pinellas, have until Monday to ask the Supreme Court for a rehearing.

Bennett said he was clear on one fact: The court did not overrule itself. It simply "receded" from its decision in 2002. While that may seem like splitting hairs, Bennett's interpretation, if correct, could mean county commissioners are not subject to the new ruling.

Former county attorney Susan Churuti, on the other hand, is definite in thinking that the court did not overrule itself.

"I don't think it does affect Pinellas," she said.

Clearwater lawyer Ed Armstrong differs, saying the new ruling trumps the first.

"It certainly has implications for Pinellas County," Armstrong said. "It's a new world now. … The potential for significant change is present. It depends on what citizens do with this thing, if anything. That's hard to predict."

T. Wayne Bailey, a professor of political science on the DeLand campus of Stetson University, said the situation is perfect for the final exam in a law school class on constitutional issues. It's "very clear," he said, that the court overruled itself.

"The easy answer is nothing happens because the case (last week) doesn't change Pinellas' status quo," Bailey said. "My offhand feeling is you're in a legal wasteland, (a) never-never land."

Churuti says the future is not murky: The only way term limits could return for elected county officials is for voters to pass a new referendum.

The reason, she said, lies in the history of the 1996 amendment, which was supported by more than 72 percent of the voters. Known as "Eight is Enough," the initiative limited to eight consecutive years the terms of county commissioners and the five constitutional officers — the sheriff, supervisor of elections, clerk of the circuit court, property appraiser and tax collector.

Once passed, it was supposed to be inserted into the county charter, or constitution.

But that never happened.

"Because it was a controversy and we thought it was wrong," Churuti said, the county asked a judge for permission to keep it out of the charter until all lawsuits had been resolved. And, after losing in two lower courts, those who opposed the term limit amendment narrowly won in the state Supreme Court. With the final decision on its side, the county never inserted the language into the charter.

Therefore, even if last week's ruling does apply, it can't be used to knock out any sitting commissioners or to prevent them from running this election, Churuti said. In short, last week's ruling would not "revive" the term limit amendment.

To get term limits, a movement would have to start from the beginning, she said.

Bailey said it's not that simple.

"I think the system is under a cloud at the moment," Bailey said. "Somebody could come out of the woodwork, could file a legal challenge. … It is one of those answers which is still out there in the ether."

If term limits come back, either because of a grass roots effort or because it is somehow revived and placed into the charter, a majority of the seven-member County Commission could be affected.

Ken Welch and Karen Seel are running for re-election this year. Both have been on the commission for at least eight years. Neither could be reached Wednesday for comment. The others with eight or more years of service are John Morroni and Susan Latvala.

"This is big time because it affects the whole power structure of the community," said Bailey. "It will ignite, as it should, serious consideration in a great many directions. The answers are not so clear cut."

Anne Lindberg can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 893-8450.

Comments
Carlos Gomez says he was guilty of only one thing in Sunday’s epic walkoff homer celebration

Carlos Gomez says he was guilty of only one thing in Sunday’s epic walkoff homer celebration

BALTIMORE – Carlos Gomez is perfectly willing to explain the specific elements that went into his epic celebration tour around the bases following Sunday's walkoff home run.The bat flip and raised arms were his initial reaction to how well he h...
Updated: 1 hour ago

High school scoreboard for April 24

Tuesday’s scoreboardBaseballCalvary Chr. 8, Jesuit 1Boys TennisClass 3A, District 9-10 Regional Semifinal: Osceola 4, King 1Girls TennisClass 3A, District 9-10 Regional Semifinal: Osceola 4, Freedom 1...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Days before graduation, crash kills Lakewood High senior, injures two others

Days before graduation, crash kills Lakewood High senior, injures two others

ST. PETERSBURG — Caps and gowns were in the future for Bryson Welton-Williams and his two friends.Then came Tuesday’s horrific car crash.The three 18-year-old Lakewood High School seniors drove off from school a few minutes early, just 22 days away f...
Updated: 3 hours ago
SRO being investigated in Pasco County for arrest of student

SRO being investigated in Pasco County for arrest of student

LAND O’LAKES — A school resource officer at Sunlake High School is under investigation after he tried to take a female student into custody on Tuesday, according to the Pasco County Sheriff’s Office.School officials asked the SRO remove the student f...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Teen killed after SUV runs red light; man who fled scene captured

Teen killed after SUV runs red light; man who fled scene captured

NEW PORT RICHEY — A 17-year-old girl was killed Tuesday when her car was hit by a sport-utility vehicle that ran a red light, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.One of the occupants of the SUV who ran from the crash scene was captured hours late...
Updated: 3 hours ago
Softball: Haley Murphy, East Bay back in top form

Softball: Haley Murphy, East Bay back in top form

PLANT CITY — East Bay senior Haley Murphy had to take a few games off early this season to give the flaring tendinitis in her left knee a rest.When Murphy did come back around midseason, East Bay coach Glenn Rodriguez eased her into the fl...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Sarasota student, family apologize for racist ‘promposal’

Sarasota student, family apologize for racist ‘promposal’

The family of the 18-year-old Sarasota high school student under fire for the racist prom proposal he sent out on social media this weekend has publicly apologized for their son’s actions.They also said that as a result of his actions, he will not at...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Softball: Boca Ciega gets a shot at defending district champ

DUNEDIN — Standing in centerfield during her team's Class 6A-9 district semifinal Tuesday night, Boca Ciega's Mia Blasingane had one dominating thought: "We want Tarpon Springs real bad. I was saying that to myself. I want to see Tarpon Springs...
Updated: 4 hours ago

Softball: Alonso knocks off defending state finalist PHU in 9A-8 semifinals

PALM HARBOR — To get an idea of just how tough the competition is in Class 9A, District 8, consider that there has been a different tournament champion each of the past three seasons.All three — Newsome (2015), Alonso (2016) and Palm Harb...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Rays Journal: On the early rainout, pitching plans, medical matters, more

Rays Journal: On the early rainout, pitching plans, medical matters, more

BALTIMORE – If the Rays were going to get rained out Tuesday, they were happy  the Orioles made the decision at a good hour, around 5 p.m."I think they probably did the right thing in the fact that they knew there's a bunch of rain coming,...
Updated: 4 hours ago