Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

First Amendment Foundation joins suit against St. Pete Beach concerning Sunshine Law

ST. PETE BEACH — A lawsuit over the city's handling of its development rules, originally filed in Circuit Court, is now in the hands of the 2nd District Court of Appeal and could potentially go all the way to the Florida Supreme Court.

The issue, which has drawn the involvement of the First Amendment Foundation, centers on whether the City Commission violated the state's Government-in-the-Sunshine Law during closed meetings with its lawyers in 2011.

Last April, Circuit Court Judge David Demers ruled both that the city had not committed such a violation and even if it had, those acts were "cured" by subsequent actions the commission took.

Last week, the foundation joined Jim Anderson, a resident who originally filed the lawsuit against the city, in an appeal of the circuit court ruling.

"The case is egregious," Jonathan Kaney Jr., attorney for the foundation, said Wednesday. "They (the City Commission) used the state law's litigation exemption as a way to deal with a combination of political, legal and financial issues."

The Sunshine Law requires governments and agencies at both the state and local levels to conduct business in public session.

One major exemption to that requirement allows closed-door or "shade" meetings for discussions on litigation settlement negotiations or strategy sessions regarding litigation expenses.

Anderson, and the foundation in its amicus curiae brief, argue that the St. Pete Beach commission discussed matters outside those permitted areas during shade meetings.

That contention was sharply denied by Susan Churuti, an attorney for the city. She said the city will submit a brief defending the city and the lower court ruling.

"The record includes minutes or more than 90 public discussions of the issues and the trial judge found all these cured any possible Sunshine Law violations," Churuti said.

Kaney disagrees and says the foundation is prepared to take the issue all the way to the Florida Supreme Court, if necessary.

"We want to knock down this abuse of the exemption, which if allowed to stand would be a terrible outcome and leave a gaping hole in the Sunshine Law. It would make the law toothless," he said.

The First Amendment Foundation was formed in 1984 with a mandate to protect and advance the public's constitutional right to open government. Its 200-plus members include most of Florida's daily newspapers and leading media organizations, attorneys, students, private citizens and public interest organizations.

Kaney argues that the St. Pete Beach case centers on the scope of the litigation exemption and at what point a violation can be "cured" or absolved.

He maintains that some actions — particularly those taken by the St. Pete Beach commission — are "uncurable" and therefore expose the city and city commissioners to civil and criminal penalties, as well as costs incurred by Anderson for fees and costs of litigation.

Aside from the foundation's arguments relating to the Sunshine Law, Anderson's attorneys, Ken Weiss and Tim Weber, also are seeking to have the comprehensive plan completely thrown out, and the state law that permitted the plan to be put in place declared unconstitutional.

"The city has been using shade meetings to discuss matters that should be discussed in public. We claim that because they violated the Sunshine Law, the comprehensive plan is void," says Weiss.

Among the challenged actions taken by the commission during their shade meetings were discussions of a subsequently successful effort to seek passage of a special state law that would allow the city to implement a previously state-approved comprehensive plan without submitting the plan for repeated review.

Ironically, that is just what the city is now doing.

City Manager Mike Bonfield said the plan, which sets the rules for development in the city, is under review by state agencies, which are expected to submit their comments to the city this month.

First Amendment Foundation joins suit against St. Pete Beach concerning Sunshine Law 07/06/13 [Last modified: Friday, July 5, 2013 6:08pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Chris Archer, 25,000 Cubs fans and Tampa Bay's painful truth

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — The biggest ovation inside Tropicana Field on Tuesday night was not for Cubs manager Joe Maddon, who was returning for the first time since managing the Rays.

    "W" flags fly in the stands after the game between the Chicago Cubs and the Rays Tuesday at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg. [WILL VRAGOVIC   |   Times]
  2. A rendering of the Bucs' indoor practice facility.
  3. Poorly assembled 'Lego Ninjago Movie' waters down Lego movie franchise


    Well, that didn't take long.

    After only three movies, the Lego franchise is already a shadow of its original self, less irreverent and go-for-broke bricky. The watering down of an ingenious formula comes with The Lego Ninjago Movie, the sort we expected all along from plastic construction toys.

    A scene from "The Lego Ninjago Movie." (Warner Bros.)
  4. Irma slows curbside trash service in Pasco


    Hurricane Irma brought a hiccup to twice-weekly curbside trash service in Pasco County.

Pasco officials are asking for patience about the slow pace of residential trash service from private haulers. In some areas, trash hasn't been collected since Friday, Sept. 8, because of the volume of waste left after Hurricane Irma.
  5. Clemson reunion for Bucs' Adam Humphries, Vikings' Mackensie Alexander


    Bucs receiver Adam Humphries will have a familiar face lining up against him Sunday when he's in the slot and the Vikings have Mackensie Alexander guarding him as their nickel defensive back.

    Bucs wide receiver Adam Humphries (10) makes a reception before being tackled by Chicago Bears defensive back Marcus Cooper (31) Sunday at Raymond James Stadium. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]