Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Gov. Rick Scott is done with high-speed rail; advocates explore court challenge

More than 500 people showed support for Gov. Rick Scott’s move on a feature on Facebook.

More than 500 people showed support for Gov. Rick Scott’s move on a feature on Facebook.

TALLAHASSEE — An intense last-ditch effort to save high-speed rail in Florida collapsed Thursday with Gov. Rick Scott rejecting the plan, and then angry lawmakers accused him of overstepping authority and threatened legal action.

"I remain convinced that the construction cost overruns, the operating cost risk, the risk that we would give the money back if it's ever shut down, is too much for the taxpayers of the state," Scott told the Times/Herald.

The proposal to divert responsibility to a group of cities, including Tampa and Orlando, was presented to Scott's office Wednesday. He saw nothing to change his mind — a stance critics attacked as politically motivated and profoundly stubborn.

U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson deemed it "one heck of a mistake." U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor, D-Tampa, said she was "devastated" by the loss of potential jobs.

In Tallahassee, Sen. Thad Altman, R-Melbourne, said he hoped U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood would grant Florida more time before reallocating the $2.4 billion to other states so lawmakers can explore challenging the governor on constitutional grounds. The deadline had been today and LaHood's office showed no sign of backing away from that.

"I believe that he exceeded his executive authority and in a very strong sense we have a constitutional crisis on our hands," Altman said.

Senate Republican leader Andy Gardiner acknowledged there are concerns about the "parameters" of the governor's use of his executive power. He did not reject the possibility that a fellow caucus member would have a legitimate basis for suing the Republican governor.

Altman noted that the Legislature voted to accept the federal money and build high-speed rail in a special session.

"We have a law on the books," he said, and quoted the portion of the Florida Constitution that reads: "The Governor shall take care that the laws of Florida are faithfully executed."

"The governor has completely ignored that," Altman said.

Even before Thursday, there was virtually no chance Scott would budge from last week, when he rejected the federal stimulus funding for the 84-mile Orlando-Tampa line.

Scott, who relied on studies from conservative organizations including the Reason Foundation, said taxpayers could be on the hook for billions and doubted ridership would be high enough.

Still, bullet train backers began working feverishly to craft an alternative, to get around Scott's insistence that the state not be financially liable in any regard. They continued to hold onto a shred of hope that Scott would come around, saying it would create thousands of jobs.

• • •

The plan, calling for local governments to take over the project, was submitted to Scott on Wednesday after meetings between the governor's office, federal transportation officials and representatives from local governments including Tampa, Orlando, Lakeland and Miami.

This new partnership would be considered a "non-recourse entity," which is the key piece of the proposal. It means that if the project goes bust, in no way would the state or local governments be held liable for construction or operating cost overruns. The new entity would oversee the design, building and operation of the rail system, which would effectively be privatized, with the private company bearing all risks for construction and operating cost overruns.

The state would effectively be rendered into little more than a pass-through agency for the federal grants, accepting the money and turning it over to the "non-recourse entity." The state would still provide the land on which rail lines are placed and provide some consulting to ensure a smooth transition.

The U.S. DOT would be in charge of determining that the winning company has the financial wherewithal to assume the risks. The company would be required to provide a guaranty on both the construction and operating side and surety bonds or some other form of insurance against cost overruns. It would be required to submit a fixed bid for construction costs, meaning if it misses its target it's on the hook to make up the difference. The company would be responsible for operating costs for a period covering 30 years.

All "costs, fees and expenses and general liability of cost overruns and operating shortfalls shall be passed on to and guaranteed by the winning bidder selected from a concourse of bidders from the private sector," the proposal stated.

• • •

In the end, it failed to garner Scott's support.

Asked Thursday if he had contacted federal transportation officials, Scott said no and reiterated his opposition.

"I've said that all along, so there's nothing new," Scott said. The governor also seemed unmoved by talk of a lawsuit, again stating his reasons for rejecting the project.

He added a feature to his Facebook page allowing supporters to add a badge to their own profile saying, "I stand with Governor Scott against high-speed rail." In a few hours, more than 500 people had clicked on button indicating they "like this."

Information was also stripped off a state high-speed rail website. Officials behind the effort to save the deal were outraged.

"A wise man's quote favored by President Kennedy was that 'an error does not become a mistake until you refuse to correct it,' " Sen. Nelson said.

"Well, today, Rick Scott made one heck of a mistake. Forget the fact that we answered all the governor's concerns, there still were 24,000 other good reasons why this project should have been approved."

Tampa Mayor Pam Iorio said: "His reasoning does not take into account the work that has been done in the past week, which lays out a clear path for private investment and risk responsibility. The facts are clear: We have addressed his concerns on risk — the risk will fall to the private sector."

Iorio and others, including prominent Republicans like former Gov. Jeb Bush, have questioned why Scott did not let the project go out to bid, to at least see what private companies could offer in assurances of assuming financial liability.

"In effect, the message being sent to eight worldwide business consortiums across the globe and the United States is 'don't bother,' " Iorio said. "As a mayor who cares about economic development and the encouragement of investment by the private sector, I can not understand or justify his stance."

Times/Herald staff writers Steve Bousquet, Marc Caputo and Michael C. Bender contributed to this report.

Gov. Rick Scott is done with high-speed rail; advocates explore court challenge 02/24/11 [Last modified: Friday, February 25, 2011 1:01am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Today is not a dream;' St. Petersburg ready to start building new pier

    Local Government

    ST. PETERSBURG —Three years ago, with the now demolished inverted pyramid still standing stubbornly in the background, Mayor Rick Kriseman laid out a plan to replace or renovate the iconic structure.

    St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman addresses the crowd Wednesday morning at the groundbreaking ceremony for the new pier. Construction will start next week. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Times]
  2. Hillsborough and Pinellas officials can't even agree that they agreed to meet

    Local Government

    Tampa Bay political leaders often tout taking a regional approach to solve the region's most pressing issues. But the challenge has been getting Hillsborough and Pinellas County leaders together on the same page.

    Or in this case, in the same room.

    This month Hillsborough County administrator Mike Merrill (above) nixed a joint meeting of the Hillsborough and Pinellas County Commissions. But Pinellas County Commission chair Janet Long said her Hillsborough counterpart, Stacy White, had already agreed to two meetings. [DANIEL WALLACE   |   Times]
  3. Ex-sheriff's official says sheriff intentionally hid federal inmate revenue from county

    Local Government

    BROOKSVILLE — The former third-in-command at the Hernando County Sheriff's Office has filed a complaint, alleging that Sheriff Al Nienhuis intentionally hid from the County Commission $1.3 million in revenue he collected from housing federal inmates last year.

    OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times  Hernando County Sheriff Al Nienhuis said he was "extremely disappointed'' to hear of James Terry's allegations about the sheriff's handling of federal inmate dollars and noted that Terry was "offered the opportunity to resign from his position at the Sheriff's Office when numerous complaints as to his unprofessional conduct began flowing into the front office.''
  4. Fewer minions make things better in 'Despicable Me 3'


    Despicable Me 3 doubles down on Steve Carell's silly way with words, a smart idea after too much Minions gibberish spoiled part 2. They're still here, in smaller doses and somewhat funnier for it.

     voiced by Trey Parker, in a scene from "Despicable Me 3."  (Illumination and Universal Pictures via AP)
  5. After Rick Scott veto, Tarpon Springs renews push for money to dredge Anclote River

    Local Government

    In a pocket formed at the end of a branch of the Anclote River, Kevin Meisman has seen the size of the boats coming by his family's business get smaller.

    Kevin Meisman, 37, looks out from the dock of his family’s business, Quality T-Tops & Boat Accessories, in Tarpon Springs. Meisman says that, without dredging along the Anclote River, the number of boats he can service is limited.