Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Judge to rule in Pinellas County term limits case by May 17

In a much-anticipated court hearing Thursday, Pinellas County lawyers squared off against a group of residents seeking to unseat four county commissioners accused of violating term limits.

Though the lawsuit was filed in June 2012, it was not until Thursday's hearing that lawyers for both sides delved into the legal arguments at the heart of the case. Up until this point, they have been obscured by disagreements over who ought to be included in the lawsuit, which names Commissioners Susan Latvala, Ken Welch, Karen Seel, and John Morroni.

Plaintiffs Maria Scruggs, H. Patrick Wheeler, and Beverley Billiris sued the commissioners, citing a 1996 referendum that voters approved that limited commissioners to two four-year terms. They contend that in the years following the vote, elected officials flagrantly ignored the term limits and did not write them into the county's charter.

Arguing before Pinellas Pasco Circuit Court Judge John Schaefer, Steven Dupre, a private lawyer hired by the county, countered that term limits in Pinellas are moot. In the years after 72 percent of Pinellas voters approved term limits, Florida's Supreme Court found them unconstitutional and sent the lower courts a mandate instructing them to quash earlier rulings upholding them.

The fact that the Supreme Court issued a new ruling last year upholding term limits does not automatically revive them, Dupre said.

"The plaintiffs' theory here is that [the second Supreme Court ruling] is like a time warp," Dupre said. "And they jumped through a black hole and went back in time … and suddenly the commissioners that have been serving as good county servants for years are serving illegally."

The commission also is composed differently today than it was in the '90s, he argued, noting that in 1999 voters approved expanding the number of members from five to seven.

In this response, the plaintiffs' lawyer, John Shahan, said the Supreme Court's initial ruling didn't apply. Although Pinellas voters approved term limits for both county commissioners and constitutional officers, the state's high court only ruled them unconstitutional for the latter group, he said.

"The county commissioners were not part of that ruling," Shahan said. Untouched by the decision, they should be subject to term limits, he added. Dupre said that documents show the ruling covered both the commissioners and the constitutional officers.

Following the arguments, Judge Schaefer said he would issue a ruling by May 17.

Wheeler, one of the plaintiffs, said the hearing was "magnificent."

"I really think we're winning," he said, with a grin. "We had everything well at hand. And they just didn't have all the facts in the right order."

Asked whether he planned to appeal the case if the judge does not rule in favor, Wheeler shot back: "Are you standing on the floor? That's your answer."

The four commissioners named in the suit did not attend the hearing, nor did Billiris, one of the plaintiffs.

Judge to rule in Pinellas County term limits case by May 17 05/02/13 [Last modified: Thursday, May 2, 2013 11:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Trump to speak at Arlington cemetery on Memorial Day


    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump is preparing his first Memorial Day address at Arlington National Cemetery.

    President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump wave as they board Air Force One at Naval Air Station Sigonella, Saturda, in Sigonella, Italy. [AP photo]
  2. Two in serious condition after early-morning shooting in Tampa


    Two people are in serious condition after a shooting occurred early Monday morning in Tampa, according to the Tampa Police Department.

  3. Wrong-way driver on Courtney Campbell Causeway intercepted by police, faces DUI charge

    Public Safety

    A woman driving in the wrong direction on the Courtney Campbell Causeway early Monday morning was intercepted by Tampa Police officers and faces a DUI charge.

  4. Relative 'devastated' after shooting kills 8 in Mississippi


    BROOKHAVEN, Miss. — Head in hands, his voice strained, Vincent Mitchell sat outside his little yellow home and tried to make sense of how a family dispute led to a rampage that killed eight people, including the deputy who tried to keep them safe.

    Christianna May-Kelly, center, is supported by family members as she cries after answering reporters questions outside her parents' home in Brookhaven, Miss., Sunday. May-Kelly said her parents and mother were among the people gunned down during a shooting in rural Mississippi Saturday night. [AP photo]
  5. Forecast: Sunny, clear Memorial Day ahead of increased rain chances throughout the week


    If you're planning on heading outside today for Memorial Day activities, the weather shouldn't get in the way.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day forecast. [WTSP]