Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Jury to decide whether St. Petersburg or Wachovia is to blame for lost millions

TAMPA — A jury of seven will begin deliberations today to decide if St. Petersburg should recoup more than $10 million in bad investments in Lehman Brothers, the Wall Street firm that went bankrupt in 2008.

During closing arguments Monday in U.S. District Court, lawyers framed the weeklong case in simple terms: "It's the other guy's fault."

For the city, it's the fault of Wachovia Global Securities, its former financial adviser now owned by Wells Fargo. The city says Wachovia didn't tell city officials that Lehman Brothers, of which the city held $15 million in corporate bonds at the time of its bankruptcy, was downgraded on three separate occasions by three separate ratings agencies in the summer of 2008.

Wells Fargo disputes the allegation that Wachovia didn't alert the city, but there's no written documentation that it did.

In a forceful closing argument that tapped into popular discontent with the banking industry, attorney Rob Marcus said that Wachovia's failure to notify violated the bank's contract with the city and makes it liable for about $10.4 million in losses.

"They were negligent," Marcus told the jury. "They had all the information, and they never told St. Petersburg. It's really simple. Wachovia didn't do what it was asked to do. That's really not much to ask from a bank. If we pay you for advice, give it. That's what we pay you for."

Wells Fargo attorney Jack Cobetto pushed back, blaming the city by hanging the case on one man: former city financial adviser Jeff Spies.

It was Spies who gave contradictory testimony, undermining his credibility and the city's contention that officials didn't know, Cobetto said. Spies at times said he did his due diligence in checking the monthly financial reports that would have contained information about the Lehman Brothers downgrades.

If he had, Cobetto argued, why wouldn't he have noticed that Lehman Brothers had been downgraded twice in June of that year, which was noted in a report he said he reviewed? And a Lehman Brothers subsidiary had been working with the city in a proposal to develop Tropicana Field. The condition of Lehman Brothers was discussed at a June 19, 2008, meeting. And then-Mayor Rick Baker had asked a top city administrator to meet regularly with Spies after March 2008 to analyze the city's investments.

"You couldn't do any due diligence of Lehman at that time and miss the fact that Lehman had been downgraded," Cobet­to told the jurors. "This comes down to the credibility of Mr. Spies … to say Mr. Spies wasn't doing his job is an understatement."

Cobetto said the city was shifting responsibility to Wachovia because it didn't want to share the blame.

Marcus had time for one more response. This wasn't about Spies, he told the jury. Spies gave confusing testimony because he has been retired for two years and this is a complicated case.

"This is about Wachovia shifting responsibility," he said.

Where the jury will come down is anyone's guess. But the verdict could have ramifications nationwide. It's the first of about 12 lawsuits that have been filed against Wachovia that Wells Fargo is defending. Throughout the trial, attorneys representing other clients have attended.

On Monday, Sarasota officials were in the courtroom to watch proceedings. Sarasota lost $40 million in Lehman Brothers corporate bonds. That trial is set to begin in August.

Jury to decide whether St. Petersburg or Wachovia is to blame for lost millions 04/02/12 [Last modified: Monday, April 2, 2012 11:10pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Police commander among 6 charged in deadly 1989 UK soccer deaths


    LONDON — British prosecutors charged six people Wednesday in the 1989 Hillsborough stadium disaster where 96 soccer fans were crushed to death.

    Police, stewards and supporters tend and care for wounded supporters on the pitch at Hillsborough Stadium, in Sheffield, England, on April 15, 1989. British prosecutors on Wednesday June 28, 2017, are set to announce whether they plan to lay charges in the deaths of 96 people in the Hillsborough stadium crush _ one of Britain's worst-ever sporting disasters. [Associated Press]
  2. Supreme Court term ended much different than it began


    BC-US—Supreme Court, 1st Ld-Writethru,899

    AP Photo WX109

    People visit the Supreme Court in Washington, Monday, June 26, 2017, as justices issued their final rulings for the term, in Washington.  The Supreme Court began its term nine months ago with Merrick Garland nominated to the bench, Hillary Clinton favored to be the next president, and the court poised to be controlled by Democratic appointees for the first time in 50 years.  Things looked very different when the justices wrapped up their work this week. [Associated Press]
  3. SPC's Bill Law leaves with pride for the faculty, concern for students — and a story about hotdogs


    ST. PETERSBURG — The local community college had already made a name for itself when William Law Jr. first arrived on campus in the early 1980s as a vice president. Still, the school, then named St. Petersburg Junior College, was just a shadow of the sprawling state college it would later become.

    Bill Law, outgoing St. Petersburg College president, said he is proud of the college cultivating stronger relationships with the community.
  4. Forecast: Pattern of hot, humid air and inland, late-day showers continues across bay area


    Storms again will pop up midday around Tampa Bay, but are forecast to mostly stick inland.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day. [WTSP]
  5. UCF suspends fraternity amid sex assault and hazing claims (w/video)


    ORLANDO — A University of Central Florida fraternity has been suspended while the school investigates allegations of sexual assault and hazing.