Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Jury verdict leaves Tampa Bay Water officials stunned and uncertain

TAMPA — Tampa Bay Water directors were reeling Wednesday, a day after losing a lawsuit they were counting on to pay for more than $100 million in repairs to the state's largest reservoir.

With legal fees surpassing $10 million, board members said they don't know whether they will appeal their case against the engineering firm that designed the C.W. Bill Young Reservoir. That decision could come Monday, during a closed meeting of the board.

"I don't know what the board will decide, but it's a tragedy for the entire area," said Charlie Miranda, a Tampa City Council member who sits on the water board.

Tampa Bay Water, which represents more than 2 million Pinellas, Pasco and Hillsborough county ratepayers, filed a lawsuit four years ago seeking $73 million in damages from HDR Engineering to help pay for repairs of the 15.5-billion gallon reservoir.

The Nebraska-based HDR designed the $146-million reservoir, which opened in June 2005 to store water from the Tampa Bypass Canal and the Alafia and Hillsborough rivers. Cracks were first discovered in December 2006. Some stretched 400 feet and 15 1/2 inches deep and wouldn't stay patched.

Cracks now show up along two-thirds of the reservoir's embankment and continue to spread, a water official said during the month-long trial.

In 2008, Tampa Bay Water sued HDR and two contractors. The contractors settled for $6.75 million and agreed to cooperate with Tampa Bay Water's lawsuit.

Last fall, HDR offered to settle the suit for $30 million but water officials rejected the offer, something Miranda does not regret.

"Sometimes you have to stand up for what was right," Miranda said. "The board didn't design the reservoir. The board didn't build it.''

Neil Brickfield and Susan Latvala, board members and Pinellas commissioners, agreed.

"We had a strong case and we don't believe that the ratepayers — our six-member government customers — should be stuck with that bill,'' Latvala said. "The design was flawed, and I think we had a responsibility to fight as hard as we could to show that (HDR) had responsibility."

Said Brickfield: "We were confident when we moved forward that we had a very good case. The jury didn't see it that way."

Jurors could not be reached Wednesday for comment. It took them just four hours of deliberation to decide the engineering firm was not responsible for fixing the reservoir.

"Our attorneys had advised us that we had a good case,'' said Sandra Murman, a water board member and Hillsborough commissioner. "Jurors couldn't see that in the end they're going to have to pay for a mistake that they don't see is a mistake."

Lead attorney Richard Harrison said his firm is evaluating grounds for an appeal but would not offer any opinions except to board members.

Board chairwoman Ann Hildebrand, a Pasco commissioner, said she was leaning toward supporting an appeal, but Murman said she wanted to evaluate attorneys fees first.

Thus far, Tampa Bay Water has incurred about $10.6 million in legal fees and costs. Appealing the decision could add between $200,000 and $400,000, water spokeswoman Michelle Biddle Rapp said.

Attorneys expect HDR to file a motion for its legal fees and costs as the winning party, a claim Tampa Bay Water anticipates will be between $13 million and $18 million.

"I don't want to pay another cent of legal fees," Murman said. "We're already $122 million in the hole with ratepayers."

Last year, Tampa Bay Water authorized reservoir repairs and hired Kiewit Infrastructure South to fix cracks and boost capacity by 3 billion gallons for $162 million. Construction is slated to start this fall and last two years.

Repairs alone are estimated to cost about $122 million, and Murman wondered if the project could be scaled back to just that.

Even so, much of the bill seems destined to fall on the backs of ratepayers.

Tampa Bay Water staff is predicting that rates might have to rise 10 to 15 cents per thousand gallons of water used to pay for the $162 million repair and expansion project. The average Tampa Bay area household uses about 8,000 gallons, so ratepayers would see an increase of between 80 cents and $1.20 per month on average.

"Regardless of what the jury had to say, it doesn't really change the fact that we have a reservoir that begins cracking as soon as the water is lowered and it does have to be fixed," board and St. Petersburg council member Karl Nurse said. "We'll have to look at the choices of how we're going to pay for that."

Times staff writer William R. Levesque contributed to this report. Justin George can be reached at or (813) 226-3368.

Jury verdict leaves Tampa Bay Water officials stunned and uncertain 04/11/12 [Last modified: Wednesday, April 11, 2012 11:22pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. GOP's new repeal bill would likely leave millions more uninsured, analyses suggest


    WASHINGTON — The latest Republican bid to roll back the Affordable Care Act would likely leave millions of currently insured Americans without health coverage in the coming decades, and strip benefits and protections from millions more, a growing number of independent studies suggest.

    Vice President Mike Pence listens as President Donald Trump talks to reporters about the Graham-Cassidy health care bill during a meeting with Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi at the Palace Hotel during the United Nations General Assembly, Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017, in New York. [Evan Vucci | Associated Press]
  2. Mueller casts broad net in requesting extensive records from Trump White House


    WASHINGTON — The special counsel investigating Russian election meddling has requested extensive records and email correspondence from the White House, covering the president's private discussions about firing his FBI director and his response to news that the then-national security adviser was under …

    In a photograph provided by the Russian foreign ministry, President Donald Trump meets with Sergei Lavrov, left, the Russian foreign minister, and Sergey Kislyak, the Russian ambassador, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, May 10, 2017. Special counsel Robert Mueller is interested in this meeting, where Trump said dismissing FBI Director James Comey had relieved "great pressure" on him, the New York Times reported on Sept. 20. [Russian Foreign Ministry via  New York Times]
  3. 'We will find our island destroyed': Hurricane Maria demolishes Puerto Rico


    SAN JUAN — Sleepless Puerto Ricans awoke Wednesday knowing to expect a thrashing from the most ferocious storm to strike the island in at least 85 years. They met nightfall confronting the ruin Hurricane Maria left behind: engorged rivers, blown-out windows, sheared roofs, toppled trees and an obliterated electric …

    Rescue vehicles from the Emergency Management Agency stand trapped under an awning during the impact of Hurricane Maria, after the storm  hit the eastern region of the island, in Humacao, Puerto Rico, Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2017. The U.S. National Hurricane Center says Maria has lost its major hurricane status, after raking Puerto Rico. But forecasters say some strengthening is in the forecast and Maria could again become a major hurricane by Thursday. [Carlos Giusti | Associated Press]
  4. Obamacare repeal bill offers flexibility and uncertainty


    The latest Republican proposal to undo the Affordable Care Act would grant states much greater flexibility and all but guarantee much greater uncertainty for tens of millions of people.

  5. Manafort offered to give Russian billionaire 'private briefings' on 2016 campaign, report says


    Less than two weeks before Donald Trump accepted the Republican presidential nomination, his campaign chairman offered to provide briefings on the race to a Russian billionaire closely aligned with the Kremlin, the Washington Post reports.

    Paul Manafort, then Donald Trump's campaign chairman, talks to reporters on the floor of the Republican National Convention at Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland. [Associated Press]